Birthright Citizenship…Arguments to begin this week at the Supreme Court.

[postman]

I would add that Google is becoming a big part of the problem,
Not just the media anymore.
God only knows what they're teaching in school.

I'd like to get back to natural born citizen.
Fascinating subject.

Natural born is anyone subject to our jurisdiction (meaning we have control over them such as making them pay taxes, or subjecting them to arrest and imprisonment) born within our sovereign territory. Which also includes the airspace above. And the seas (within 12 miles) around.

 

[postman]

diplomatic immunity

www.law.cornell.edu

This may help.

It also defines embassies as foreign territory.

 

[Delldude]

You can lead a horse to water.

But you can't make him swim.

 

[Delldude]

It also defines embassies as foreign territory.

No kidding?

 

[Rawley]

Illegals pay taxes. Therefor they are subject to our jurisdiction.
The indians not taxed, do NOT pay taxes

They sure do

Diplomats do NOT pay taxes

They sure do

Invading armies do NOT pay taxes.

They sure do.

See the pattern?

Yes. You're wrong 1,000% of the time. Kudos

 

[postman]

the fk they aren't. If they buy anything off reservation, they pay taxes, as do all diplomats.

Diplomats don't pay taxes.

Yes, diplomats are generally exempt from most taxes, including local taxes, in the country where they are stationed. This is a key aspect of diplomatic immunity, designed to allow diplomats to perform their duties without interference from the host government.

 

[jc456]

Diplomats don't pay taxes.

Yes, diplomats are generally exempt from most taxes, including local taxes, in the country where they are stationed. This is a key aspect of diplomatic immunity, designed to allow diplomats to perform their duties without interference from the host government.

the fk they don't. they pay every sales tax as anyone else. you are fking lunatic Ville dude. stay in your own lane, you are too fked up. take another pill.

 

[postman]

Indians became citizens in 1924 and pay federal income takes. Indians don't pay taxes on things tied to the reservations.

Income from trust lands: Income derived directly from allotted restricted lands held in trust by the United States government for their benefit is exempt from federal income tax. This includes income from activities like farming, logging, mining, or ranching on that land.

Income from treaty fishing rights: Income from activities related to treaty fishing rights is also exempt from federal income tax.

But when in Rome you render what is Caesars.

 

[Delldude]

Income from trust lands: Income derived directly from allotted restricted lands held in trust by the United States government for their benefit is exempt from federal income tax. This includes income from activities like farming, logging, mining, or ranching on that land.

Income from treaty fishing rights: Income from activities related to treaty fishing rights is also exempt from federal income tax.

But when in Rome you render what is Caesars.

Thanks for admitting you were wrong.

 

[Rawley]

Diplomats don't pay taxes.

Yes, diplomats are generally exempt from most taxes, including local taxes, in the country where they are stationed. This is a key aspect of diplomatic immunity, designed to allow diplomats to perform their duties without interference from the host government.

Nice link Ratty . Of course they pay taxes, like Indians do.

 

[Rawley]

the fk they don't. they pay every sales tax as anyone else. you are fking lunatic Ville dude. stay in your own lane, you are too fked up. take another pill.

They buys a condo for their mistress, the are paying property taxes. They have a side gig as a lounge singer, they pay income taxes

 

[Rawley]

Income from trust lands: Income derived directly from allotted restricted lands held in trust by the United States government for their benefit is exempt from federal income tax. This includes income from activities like farming, logging, mining, or ranching on that land.

Income from treaty fishing rights: Income from activities related to treaty fishing rights is also exempt from federal income tax.

But when in Rome you render what is Caesars.

Just admit you were barking out your ass.

 

[Mac-7]

It's a simple truth of what it means to be subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.

It means whatever 5 unelected black robes say it means

And this time I hope the roulette wheel stops on my number

 

[Mac-7]

Everyone is afforded due process even if they sneak in.

That should probably be changed.

They can get their due process on the way to the airport

 

[Etymology gaslight]

So what do you guys think
the definition of natural born citizen is ?

 

[WEATHER53]

The 9-0 ruling today surprised me greatly and indicates they are thinking and not caving to popular sentimentality for illegals

 

[jc456]

Also the parents with a us birth certificate, the certificate is invalid because they owed allegiance to another country. Such as anyone with duel citizenship, like Elon Musk.

Baby has dual citizenship.

 

[WEATHER53]

P

The provision is, that ‘all persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens.’ That means ‘subject to the complete jurisdiction thereof.’ What do we mean by ‘complete jurisdiction thereof?’ Not owing allegiance to anybody else. That is what it means.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

You do know that means thousand of Jews would lose their citizenship. As they are citizens of both the US and Israel. And as you said, if they owe allegiance to anybody else, they aren't eligible for birthright citizenship.

Babies born here as a result of illegal entry do not create the protective provision of jurisdictional benefits for themselves, They are referred to the country where the parents Are legal to receive that.
Such is the thought process .

 

[jc456]

That depends how they got here.
If they were an invading army, then we would not give them citizenship.
Same as if they had a diplomatic mission with a staff of 50 million.
Everyone under that diplomatic umbrella isn't subject to our jurisdiction either.

Are you George Carlin? Hey father what if...........

 

[jc456]

He seems to have a problem with a very simple test of jurisdiction.
If they are subject to our laws (criminal, civil, tax etc) they are subject to our jurisdiction.

nope, you are fking wrong salad man

Which is why diplomats don't pay sales tax, income tax, or even have to pay their parking tickets.

nope, just post that statute