Why has the government closed the air space over the gulf

Can anyone explain why this was done?

Two Reasons

1. Keep news stations helicopters from interfering with the clean up operations
2. they intend t use military airplanes to disperse chemicals over the spill to try to help aid the cleanup , and they don't want to risk an accident.


Logical decision.

So your arguement is to restrict air congestion. To me that isn't reason enough. Many accidents have happened and they have never restricted air space.

They most certainly do.
 
So your arguement is to restrict air congestion. To me that isn't reason enough. Many accidents have happened and they have never restricted air space.

No my argument is that is to eliminate the chance that some idiot helicopter runs into a tanker full of skimmed oil, or a military jet full of jet fuel and chemical and explodes creating an even bigger mess than we have now. Not to mention you know that if something like that happened WE would be the ones footing the bill for it. Unless Obama just billed BP.


Major accidents happen yearly, and no one has closed the airspace on those accidents.

They most certainly do.
 
It is all about safety. ...FAA responds to Gulf of Mexico story about Temporary Flight Restrictions | Helihub - the Helicopter Search Engine
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Today’s story by the Associated Press contains a number of inaccuracies with regard to the government’s oversight of flyovers in and around the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. Since May 28th, the FAA has approved every request to fly over the area – more than 176 requests. While the temporary flight restriction requires pilots to stay above 3,000 feet, the FAA is working with news organizations and granting exceptions so that pilots can fly at lower altitudes throughout the day.

The reason for these requirements is safety, pure and simple. So far, there have been a number of reported near misses over the Gulf due to heavy traffic and pilots flying above the oil spill to give their passengers a closer look.

On Sunday, a helicopter carrying a member of the Associated Press violated the temporary flight restriction around the oil clean-up efforts in the Gulf of Mexico. The helicopter operator was not authorized to fly into the restricted area and was flying at various altitudes well below 3,000 feet. For over 30 minutes, the pilot was not in communication with the Customs and Border Patrol aircraft that is providing traffic advisories for all participating aircraft. Customs and Border Patrol was forced to divert other traffic in the area, creating a dangerous situation for everyone involved. When the pilot was finally reached he was told to leave the area.

A pilot deviation (an action that results in the violation of a Federal Aviation Regulation) is being filed against the helicopter pilot
.
 
Let's recap what you have posted
1st you said:
"Its called hiding the evidence."
2nd you said:
When ever someone doesn't want photo evidence of something, there is always something to hide.

You are the one that said they were hiding something, But now you say there's nothing as far as you are concerned.. So which is it? Do you not have the balls to stand with your convictions?

You asked why they would close airspace:
Hiding evidence is one reason

you drew the question out and the answer is:
As far as i am concerned there is nothing to hide

Again as far as i am concerned there is nothing to hide. Operative word I How hard is that to understand. So back to your question

Why close the airspace. If you have balls state your theory of why instead of just asking lame questions. Otherwise you get what you get.

If you think they are not hiding something why did you make the speculation that they are?
As for me asking the question, I would like to see what others have heard. I am uncertain why they have closed the airspace and futher more I see no reason why it has been closed.


So don't be calling people on balls to stand with conviction when you've got diddly. You want to go fishing for opinions you get what you get.
 
They're going to pull a Kim Jong Il.

Oil spill? What oil spill? There never was, and never will be any spill. These are not the droids you are looking for....*waves hand*


Srsly tho. It's about safety. You know how many nutsos there are that have access to small aircraft that are going "Well hell Jethro...it's only thirty miles offshore...lets go take a looksee". Combine these idiots with random air traffic from many military aircraft...sooner or later someone is going to get hurt and killed.
 
What are they trying to hide? After all obama is the head of the government.

you're babbling.

now go read the post above.

next time do some factchecking before you spread your ODS all over the place.

Dear asswipe maybe if you would post the whole reply maybe you would not look like a total asswipe

My question was:

"Why has the government closed the air space over the gulf "

Quote: Originally Posted by syrenn
Its called hiding the evidence.

I then asked:
What are they trying to hide? After all obama is the head of the government.

And lets take it one more post from syrenn
Quote: Originally Posted by syrenn
When ever someone doesn't want photo evidence of something, there is always something to hide.
My reply was:
Not logical what is there to hide?
So next time you act like an asswipe I will be there to tell you about it.
 
No my argument is that is to eliminate the chance that some idiot helicopter runs into a tanker full of skimmed oil, or a military jet full of jet fuel and chemical and explodes creating an even bigger mess than we have now. Not to mention you know that if something like that happened WE would be the ones footing the bill for it. Unless Obama just billed BP.


Major accidents happen yearly, and no one has closed the airspace on those accidents.

They most certainly do.

When have they closed the airspace at a civillian accident?
 
Can anyone explain why this was done?

It has been an ADIZ for a long long time.(Air Defense Identification Zone). Several times when I was flying around the gulf I was met by the Florida Air National Gaurd flying Phantoms. The spill is one reason but another one is that smugglers would use the other aircraft as cover and try to get in by blending into the mix.
 
Srsly tho. It's about safety. You know how many nutsos there are that have access to small aircraft that are going "Well hell Jethro...it's only thirty miles offshore...lets go take a looksee". Combine these idiots with random air traffic from many military aircraft...sooner or later someone is going to get hurt and killed.



WRONG!!!!!

Thats too G-damned logical






:tongue:
 
hiding WHAT evidence?

He asked an opened ended stupid question, of why would they do that?

That could be an answer. I made no claim it WAS the answer. :)

So a question is stupid? It was not an open ended question you thought stupidly and I called you on your answer. Stupid peoiple will say the stupidest things.

No you called me on sticking to my statements. And I do :lol: Its no more a silly answer then UFO, subs, and magic or any other answer you got.

Do be annoyed when other people understand what i said and think your now babbling.

No question is ever stupid. But when you dont like the answers you get and try and run with it in foolish directions that are NOT there then that is stupid.

 
Last edited:
He asked an opened ended stupid question, of why would they do that?

That could be an answer. I made no claim it WAS the answer. :)

So a question is stupid? It was not an open ended question you thought stupidly and I called you on your answer. Stupid peoiple will say the stupidest things.

No you called me on sticking to my statements. And I do :lol: Its no more a silly answer then UFO, subs, and magic or any other answer you got.

Do be annoyed when other people understand what i said and think your now babbling.

No question is ever stupid. But when you dont like the answers you get and try and run with it in foolish directions that are NOT there then that is stupid.


You answered the question and you and one other asswipe thinks I was babbling. Don't be a bigger asswipe then you already are. You gave your answer then try to back out when you were busted for your stuipd reply.
 
No my argument is that is to eliminate the chance that some idiot helicopter runs into a tanker full of skimmed oil, or a military jet full of jet fuel and chemical and explodes creating an even bigger mess than we have now. Not to mention you know that if something like that happened WE would be the ones footing the bill for it. Unless Obama just billed BP.


Major accidents happen yearly, and no one has closed the airspace on those accidents.


Major accidents that are fought by low flying military jets spewing out chemicals? that is the current plan from what I've read.
The oil is not enough. So spray toxic chemicals.
 

Forum List

Back
Top