I hate the Fair Tax Act in that it adds insult to injury for those disadvantaged, here I'm mainly thinking of families with expenses such as child care, medical care, senior care facilities.
Plus being in a 12% tax bracket, I'd rather have an effective tax rate of 13.6% rather than 30% . Currently to buy a $500 TV set I'd need to earn $568, of that $568, the government takes $68 off the top and I have $500 left over for the TV. $68/$500 = 13.6%.
Under the Fair Tax that touts a 23% tax rate I'd need to earn $650 for that TV. Seller pays a 30% tax, $500 x 30% = $150. Fair Tax proponents explain I'm only paying 23% because $150/$650 = 23%.
What I do like about the Fair Tax is its confidentiality. But that comes at one hell of a price.
I like pknopp's logic. The $1000 somebody earns trading stocks should be treated no differently tax-wise than the $1000 a guy earned for laying brinks.