A Thought on Judaism...no "pie in the sky"

[rupol2000]

Let's try again, tel us who's Ashkenazi Jew and who's the Iraqi -

I have already said who the Ashkenazim are. This is a nationality that lived mainly in the Pale of Settlement in the region of Belarus and Warsaw, of the south of modern Lithuania, which had a culture and language approximately identical to the Balto-German or Balto-Slavic. On the subject of Yemen, I am not well informed.

 

[Mindful]

Yes you people are indeed,
the largest illiterate group on earth!

A Note on Arabic Literacy and Translation

Discover the impact of illiteracy and translation limitations in the Arab world. Learn how increasing access to education and literature can help.

www.altalang.com

Yes, and how many times have we heard it all before?

Ad infinitum.

 

[rylah]

Do you have data separately for the mitochondrial haplogroups of Ashkenazim and Palestinians? This would be more clear.

Grasping at straws?

I've presented all relevant data,
Arabs cluster with Syrian Muslims and Saudis,
Jews on the other hand - with Lebanese predating Islam.

Can't be clearer than that -
Muslims foreigners can't even pronounce the name of the place.

 

[rupol2000]

Let's try again, tel us who's Ashkenazi Jew and who's the Iraqi -

Let's do it differently. Who is Jewish and who is Balto-Slavic?

 

[rylah]

Yes, and how many times have we heard it all before?

Ad infinitum.

Unlike Christianity,

Muslims are so insecure about Islam,
that since Jews laughed in Muhammads illiterate face,
they didn't dare once engage in disputations with Jewish scholars.

They really are ashamed, it may sound counter intuitive,
but in many unconscious ways, they're really begging us to reform Islam.

And we beyond what they'll ever realize.

 

[irosie91]

God's plan ? Pretty awful, isn't it?

Why do you say Christians don't follow the teachings of Jesus? How are they different from Jewish people?

your question is spiteful and idiotic----in the islamo nazi style

 

[rupol2000]

Grasping at straws?

I've presented all relevant data,
Arabs cluster with Syrian Muslims and Saudis,
Jews on the other hand - with Lebanese predating Islam.

Can't be clearer than that -
Muslims foreigners can't even pronounce the name of the place.

Just in the region of Palestine and Israel, there are not many Semitic genes, much less than in Arabia. At least half of the men there are not Semites

 

[rylah]

Let's do it differently. Who is Jewish and who is Balto-Slavic?

Above is a Jew,
below is a Russian.

Clearly you don't know much Jews...
we know our folk, without even looking.

Who's Ashkenazi Jew and who's the Yemenite?

 

[Mindful]

Just in the region of Palestine and Israel, there are not many Semitic genes, much less than in Arabia. At least half of the men there are not Semites

This again......

 

[Mindful]

Let's do it differently. Who is Jewish and who is Balto-Slavic?

Unhealthy preoccupations.

 

[rupol2000]

Above is a Jew,
below is a Russian.

Clearly you don't know much Jews...
we know our folk, without even looking.

No, not because of this, but because they are famous artists, and you know them specifically. But the bottom line is that there are no significant external differences, and most Ashkenazi are of the same type as in Belarus and in the northwest of Russia.

As for the concept of "Russian", there is no identity, modern Russians are a fusion of three main peoples: the Huns, the Balto-Slavs and the Sami. Therefore, there can be no standard Russian appearance at all, even in theory. Actually this is nation and not nationality

 

[rylah]

No, not because of this, but because they are famous artists, and you know them specifically. But the bottom line is that there are no significant external differences, and most Ashkenazi are of the same type as in Belarus and in the northwest of Russia.

As for the concept of "Russian", there is no identity, modern Russians are a fusion of three main peoples: the Huns, the Balto-Slavs and the Sami. Therefore, there can be no standard Russian appearance at all, even in theory. Actually this is nation and not nationality

I know them specifically?
Really not, simply I'm a Jew with Jewish soul.

 

[rupol2000]

This is the same as the fake concept of "German". Compare the appearance of Thomas Anders with how the stupid adherents of the "white race" draw us the image of "German"

 

[Mindful]

This is the same as the fake concept of "German". Compare the appearance of Thomas Anders with how the stupid adherents of the "white race" draw us the image of "German"

The doctors and the police look like movie stars.

 

[rupol2000]

I know them specifically?
No, I'm a Jew with a Jewish soul and Jewish eyes.

In this case, you can name the signs by which you determine this and explain how this is combined with the fact that halakha does not prohibit Jewish women from marrying non-Jews, and therefore they can still inherit the appearance of a non-Jew.

And I remind you that the controversy began with the fact that you argued that the Ashkenazim have a Middle Eastern appearance.

 

[rupol2000]

The doctors and the police look like movie stars.

Do you think that most Germans have a "Nordic" appearance? This was not even in the administration of the Wehrmacht

 

[rupol2000]

Who's Ashkenazi Jew and who's the Yemenite?

It is easy to tell by his clothes, besides, I know that this is Trotsky. What are you trying to say? I know that most Ashkenazi are indistinguishable from an ordinary European, many of them, or even most, have the appearance of northern Germans or Balto-Slavs. There are blond among them and so on

 

[Mindful]

Do you think that most Germans have a "Nordic" appearance? This was not even in the administration of the Wehrmacht

Some do.

I live amongst them. The issue doesn't interest me.

 

[rupol2000]

Some do.

I live amongst them. The issue doesn't interest me.

And what do the Bavarians, for example, whose land was part of the Avar Kaganate before the Franks, think about this? Their dialect is still different, why do they need this "Nordic" image, which is imposed by propaganda? Is it really pleasant for them?

 

[Mindful]

And what do the Bavarians, for example, whose land was part of the Avar Kaganate before the Franks, think about this? Their dialect is still different, why do they need this "Nordic" image, which is imposed by propaganda? Is it really pleasant for them?

No idea.