Report: Israel Stole $2B from Palestinian Workers

[Modbert]

Report: Israel Stole $2B from Palestinian Workers by Jonathan Cook -- Antiwar.com

Over the past four decades Israel has defrauded Palestinians working inside Israel of more than $2 billion by deducting from their salaries contributions for welfare benefits to which they were never entitled, Israeli economists have revealed.

A new report, “State Robbery”, to be published later this month, says the “theft” continued even after the Palestinian Authority was established in 1994 and part of the money was supposed to be transferred to a special fund on behalf of the workers

According to information supplied by Israeli officials, most of the deductions from the workers’ pay were invested in infrastructure projects in the Palestinian territories — a presumed reference to the massive state subsidies accorded to the settlements.

Nearly 50,000 Palestinians from the West Bank are working in Israel — following the easing of restrictions on entering Israel under the “economic peace” promised by Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister — and continue to have such contributions docked from their pay.

Complicit in the deception, the report adds, is the Histadrut, the Israeli labor federation, which levies a monthly fee on Palestinian workers, even though they are not entitled to membership and are not represented in labor disputes.

“This is a clear-cut case of theft from Palestinian workers on a grand scale,” said Shir Hever, a Jerusalem-based economist and one of the authors of the report. “There are no reasons for Israel to delay in returning this money either to the workers or to their beneficiaries.”

The deductions started being made in 1970, three years after the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories began, when Palestinian workers started to enter Israel in significant numbers, most of them employed as manual laborers in the agriculture and construction industries.

Typically, the workers lose a fifth of their salary in deductions that are supposed to cover old age payments, unemployment allowance, disability insurance, child benefits, trade union fees, pension fund, holiday and sick pay, and health insurance. In practice, however, the workers are entitled only to disability payments in case of work accidents and are insured against loss of work if their employer goes bankrupt.

According to the report, compiled by two human rights groups, the Alternative Information Center and Kav La’Oved, only a fraction of the total contributions — less than eight per cent — was used to award benefits to Palestinian workers. The rest was secretly transferred to the finance ministry.

The Israeli organizations assess that the workers were defrauded of at least $2.25bn in today’s prices, in what they describe as a minimum and “very conservative” estimate of the misappropriation of the funds. Such a sum represents about 10 per cent of the PA’s annual budget.

The authors also note that they excluded from their calculations two substantial groups of Palestinian workers — those employed in the Jewish settlements and those working in Israel’s black economy — because figures were too hard to obtain.

Mr Hever said the question of whether the bulk of the deductions — those for national insurance — had been illegally taken from the workers was settled by the Israeli High Court back in 1991. The judges accepted a petition from the flower growers’ union that the government should return about $1.5 million in contributions from Palestinian workers in the industry.
“The legal precedent was set then and could be used to reclaim the rest of these excessive deductions,” he said.

However, the report notes that such practices were supposed to have been curbed by the Oslo process. Israel agreed to levy an “equalization tax” — equivalent to the excessive contributions paid by Palestinians — a third of which would be invested in a fund that would later be available to the workers.

In fact, however, the Israeli State Comptroller, a government watchdog official, reported in 2003 that only about a tenth of the money levied on the workers had actually been placed in the fund.

Talk about awkward. Thoughts USMB?

 

[Jos]

A similer problem occerred in Gibralter where Morrocan contract workers paid into the national health care fund, they ended up getting UK pensions paid to them in Morrocco

 

[Marc39]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

 

[elvis]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

so nothing Jonathan cook says can possibly be true?

 

[Modbert]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

Except the post is only talking about the study that's being released by Israel economists. But nice try.

 

[Modbert]

so nothing Jonathan cook says can possibly be true?

Careful Elvis, you may get that Scarlet A as Shogun calls it thrown at you next.

 

[Jos]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

Nah jonathan cook is a good bloke, I have shared a few EMails with him

 

[Marc39]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

so nothing Jonathan cook says can possibly be true?

Hard to say, since Cook is an anti-Israel propagandist and not considered a first-rate journalist. You need to really upgrade your bogus sources. I may have been born at night, but, not last night.

 

[Marc39]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

Nah jonathan cook is a good bloke, I have shared a few EMails with him

Good blokes are not necessarily credible. Cook is a crackpot.

 

[elvis]

Jonathan Cook is a bogus source.

Thus, your post is self-demolished.

so nothing Jonathan cook says can possibly be true?

Hard to say, since Cook is an anti-Israel propagandist and not considered a first-rate journalist. You need to really upgrade your bogus sources. I may have been born at night, but, not last night.

Uh, it wasn't my source.

 

[Shogun]

i'm not sure which is more predictable... the story in the OP or the reaction by marc39

 

[Marc39]

i'm not sure which is more predictable... the story in the OP or the reaction by marc39

I'm predictably...correct.

 

[RadiomanATL]

Ad hominem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Modbert]

Ad hominem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Shogun]

i'm not sure which is more predictable... the story in the OP or the reaction by marc39

I'm predictably...correct.

and I'm SURE that the jewish virtual library says so too! You ARE jewish, after all. Lord knows that jews, especially opinion editorials, are infallible.

 

[Marc39]

i'm not sure which is more predictable... the story in the OP or the reaction by marc39

I'm predictably...correct.

and I'm SURE that the jewish virtual library says so too! You ARE jewish, after all. Lord knows that jews, especially opinion editorials, are infallible.

You have a chip on your shoulder about Jews. Too bad. You'll probably end up committing suicide from your self-loathing.

 

[Shogun]

I'm predictably...correct.

and I'm SURE that the jewish virtual library says so too! You ARE jewish, after all. Lord knows that jews, especially opinion editorials, are infallible.

You have a chip on your shoulder about Jews. Too bad. You'll probably end up committing suicide from your self-loathing.

oh, so NOW your little matzo crystal ball says i'm unemployed AND suicidal!





don't worry, lil guy.. if history has anything to say about predictions you'll be in a camp sometime within the next decade. See how that prediction thing works?

 

[Marc39]

and I'm SURE that the jewish virtual library says so too! You ARE jewish, after all. Lord knows that jews, especially opinion editorials, are infallible.

You have a chip on your shoulder about Jews. Too bad. You'll probably end up committing suicide from your self-loathing.

oh, so NOW your little matzo crystal ball says i'm unemployed AND suicidal!





don't worry, lil guy.. if history has anything to say about predictions you'll be in a camp sometime within the next decade. See how that prediction thing works?

I predict you'll off yourself within acouple years, if not sooner. Your self-hatred is more than you can deal with. Did a Jew kick sand in your face, faggot?

 

[Shogun]

You have a chip on your shoulder about Jews. Too bad. You'll probably end up committing suicide from your self-loathing.

oh, so NOW your little matzo crystal ball says i'm unemployed AND suicidal!





don't worry, lil guy.. if history has anything to say about predictions you'll be in a camp sometime within the next decade. See how that prediction thing works?

I predict you'll off yourself within acouple years, if not sooner. Your self-hatred is more than you can deal with. Did a Jew kick sand in your face, faggot?

well, again, we see how masterful your ability to predict is. Hell, if only jews in germany during the run up to ww2 had the same insight you do!

Who KNEW that Miss Cleo was JEWISH?!?!?!




maybe you should go cry on your mommy's shoulder now, lil guy. I'm sure you'll feel better after someone tells you that you are superior to goyim and that your precognitive skillz are the best on the block.

 

[Marc39]

oh, so NOW your little matzo crystal ball says i'm unemployed AND suicidal!





don't worry, lil guy.. if history has anything to say about predictions you'll be in a camp sometime within the next decade. See how that prediction thing works?

I predict you'll off yourself within acouple years, if not sooner. Your self-hatred is more than you can deal with. Did a Jew kick sand in your face, faggot?

well, again, we see how masterful your ability to predict is. Hell, if only jews in germany during the run up to ww2 had the same insight you do!

Who KNEW that Miss Cleo was JEWISH?!?!?!




maybe you should go cry on your mommy's shoulder now, lil guy. I'm sure you'll feel better after someone tells you that you are superior to goyim and that your precognitive skillz are the best on the block.

Jews have long moved on since World War II, loser. Time for you to move on, too, loser. Maybe if you converted to Judaism, you'd be more successful in life and would feel better about yourself. LOL.

Warren Buffett...

Israel is now a major factor in commerce and in the world, and, is a smaller replica of what has been accomplished in the US and I think Americans admire that. They feel good about a society that is on the move