Zone1 Well regulated militia

[progressive hunter]

View attachment 1053712

I did address the question. Reread the OP and the requirements I'm placing on the government to have a "well regulated militia". Otherwise my 2nd Amendment rights are being infringed upon by any gun law that restricts me from owning what civil agencies and organizations are allowed to have and that any law that requires my getting a license, training, or anything else to own or purchase a firearm is a tax on my rights.

That last point happens to be against the law at any level of government because it's a tax on my rights, otherwise having voter ID, a voting fee at the ballet booth, and anything else isn't against the law either.

SMILE

a well regulated militia clause is just whats needed to justify the reason the people need to be armed,,
not that the government needs to always have an active militia,,

like I said,, if the people are not armed calling up the militia is like having a picnic without food,,

 

[Delldude]

The definition of who is in the militia was not repealed.

Where did I say it was?

 

[ThunderKiss1965]

I'll forward your post to the FBI. I'm sure they'll be getting back to you very soon.

I bet you SWAT people to. Nothing in the OP was a threat or threatening. Hopefully after the FBI gets back with the OP you will be next for filing a false report.

 

[Delldude]

a well regulated militia clause is just whats needed to justify the reason the people need to be armed,,
not that the government needs to always have an active militia,,

Don't think so.......the keep and bear arms is the winner.
Shall not be infringed

 

[progressive hunter]

Don't think so.......the keep and bear arms is the winner.
Shall not be infringed

youre leaving out a key word there bud,,


and why did you edit my comment out of context??

 

[Delldude]

and why did you edit my comment out of context??

Permitted

 

[progressive hunter]

Permitted

if you cant even be honest why should we waste out time with you??

youve claimed laws have repealed the 2nd A and we all know thats not how its done,,

the rest is just mindless drivel,,

 

[Damaged Eagle]

a well regulated militia clause is just whats needed to justify the reason the people need to be armed,,
not that the government needs to always have an active militia,,

like I said,, if the people are not armed calling up the militia is like having a picnic without food,,

Specifying that they can only be called up to serve on United States soil, preferably in their county or state.

SMILE

 

[Delldude]

if you cant even be honest why should we waste out time with you??

It is you who hasn't been honest and your previous posts support that.

youve claimed laws have repealed the 2nd A and we all know thats not how its done,,

Please show me where I said that..... I dare you.

 

[progressive hunter]

It is you who hasn't been honest and your previous posts support that.

Please show me where I said that..... I dare you.

then when was the 2nd A repealed to match your claims??

 

[Delldude]

then when was the 2nd A repealed to match your claims??

Prove I said 2A was......

You can't.

 

[progressive hunter]

Prove I said 2A was......

You can't.

that means everything youve claimed is wrong,,

youre dismissed,,

 

[Delldude]

that means everything youve claimed is wrong,,

youre dismissed,,

Can't show where I said 2A was repealed.

So who's the liar now?

 

[progressive hunter]

Don't float your ire at me, I've pointed out how we are here today.

are you saying the 2nd A is no longer the law of the land and has been repealed??

sure sounds like thats what youre saying when you say "how we are today"

 

[progressive hunter]

It really doesn't matter today does it?

why is today different??
the 2nd A is still the law of the land,,

 

[AZrailwhale]

Prove I said 2A was......

You can't.

You made an ambiguous statement about something being repealed. You might want to clear up the ambiguity.

 

[Rigby5]

View attachment 1053606

The enlightened progressive liberals say that firearms should only be held by a well regulated militia and other people have no need of them. Well... My military ID card for retirement says INDEF (meaning indefinitely) on it. So I'm taking it that means I'm part of the well regulated militia. Therefore any requirement for my having to obtain a license, training, or anything else about a firearm should be provided to me for free and that the government should have to pay for my time in obtaining those items. Also since I'm part of the well regulated militia I want to know when they're going to provide me with a standard issue machine gun, 10,000 rounds for said weapon, body armor, and any other item they want their well regulated militia to have. Those items they require me to have are provided to me for by the government at their expense. This also means that any state or city laws regarding firearms are rescinded and that castle law and concealed carry is allowed in any state due to our being part of the well regulated militia.

Also I want made available to purchase on the open market to all members of the well regulated militia any weapon, body armor, or other accessory (That's not standard issue for the well regulated militia) that civil law enforcement, secret service, private security, or any other organization or agency is allowed to purchase. If you want an item to be under the sole jurisdiction of the military that's where it remains and those agencies and organizations don't qualify as being part of the military therefore they can't have them either.

Additionally I think anyone that has signed up for selective service is to be considered part of the well regulated militia and they need to attend training for a minimum of one to two weeks and pick up their gear also. We can make signing up for selective service a requirement for voting and kill two birds with one stone at the ballot box by having their selective service card also being their voter ID card. Before you say anything about women in the military they are the shield maidens of Rohan and with equal rights comes equal responsibilities. Besides to change a quote slightly, "Samuel Colt made all people equal."

SMILE

That is ridiculous since the "well regulated militia" is everyone in a republic.
And the fact a "well regulated militia" needs firearm access without federal interference is not the ONLY reason why the feds were banned any firearm jurisdiction by the 2nd amendment.
It is just ONE of the many reasons.
But the 2nd amendment only listed 1 because you only need 1.

 

[progressive hunter]

That is ridiculous since the "well regulated militia" is everyone in a republic.
And the fact a "well regulated militia" needs firearm access without federal interference is not the ONLY reason why the feds were banned any firearm jurisdiction by the 2nd amendment.
It is just ONE of the many reasons.
But the 2nd amendment only listed 1 because you only need 1.

where did it list only one??

"arms" is plural,,

 

[Delldude]

are you saying the 2nd A is no longer the law of the land and has been repealed??

Then show me where I made that claim.......

You made an ambiguous statement about something being repealed. You might want to clear up the ambiguity.

Tell me of this ambiguous statement........

 

[Rigby5]

"Organized militia'

It does not say "organized militia" but "well regulated militia".
And back then, the wording "well regulated" means practiced and fully functioning.
Like in a "well regulated" clock.