Supreme Court Oral Arguments in the Birthright Citizenship Case

[The Sage of Main Street]

MisterBeale.... Let me ask you a logical question that should clear up your confusion.

If all foreigner and alien, (which are synonymous,) born on this soil are not citizens at birth as you claim the Howard statement meant, (which it does not), then why would he even need to describe the children of foreign ambassadors and ministry diplomats, when they would already be included in the group of foreigners you claim are excluded from their child's birthright citizenship?

This is why you, and others, are wrong on Howard's argument/statement.

Not All Xenos Need to Be Phobed

Senator Howard wanted to avoid calling diplomats "foreigners and aliens," which are pejorative terms, which is also why he made those two terms redundant, reinforcing his patriotism without insulting the honored guests.

 

[The Sage of Main Street]

They cant be charged with a crime.




You said something but I dont know what.

Imbecile Minds Controlled by Ambition

There's no need to go into legalese to avoid the undeniable truth that no one can get a legal right through illegal means. Therefore, the Amendment can't be interpreted so illogically. Subsequent decisions of the despicable SCROTUS junta revealed a hubris that its supremacy covered the right to violate rational interpretation.

 

[pknopp]

Imbecile Minds Controlled by Ambition

There's no need to go into legalese to avoid the undeniable truth that no one can get a legal right through illegal means. Therefore, the Amendment can't be interpreted so illogically. Subsequent decisions of the despicable SCROTUS junta revealed a hubris that its supremacy covered the right to violate rational interpretation.

Still no clue what you are rambling about.

 

[The Sage of Main Street]

Subject to the Jurisdiction there of, has a defined meaning that was argued and settled, no??

Patriots Need to Stare Down Stare Decisis

Conservatives who are not activists are afraid to overturn previous interpretations by Liberals. Such low-energy weaklings should be rejected by Populists.

An ideology that puts the desires of gate-crashing foreigners first will obliterate American independence from within, so it has the same effect as treason. The Nine Nasty Nerds feel alienated from the American people and decide laws out of a bitter resentment of and sense of superiority over those who don't cross-dress in robes and use gavels as brass knuckles.

 

[The Sage of Main Street]

Still no clue what you are rambling about.

What Makes Parrots Speechless

You know exactly what I am talking about. Pretending ignorance is a Netrix trick used for avoiding debates where you have no case, such as gaining legal rights through illegal means. The innocence of the anchor baby is irrelevant.