flack
Diamond Member
interesting
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
The poor, and those just getting by, were not taxed....true, they did not pay tithes, but many of them received the benefits of the tithe...Voluntary generosity at the time of those in Jesus's time, occurred AFTER they paid their tithe... much like today... And I suppose capitalism made those wealthy enough to pay tithes, and give generously on a voluntary basis as well...Who cares?" It is not derived from a mandatory percentage; It must flow from the heart"
Topical - Tithing or Voluntary Giving?
Now a question for you: what is the proper percentage of one's income that taxation should demand?
It is not part of the thread topic....
Because you are both ignorant, and a coward....you know the correct answer indicts the party you support.....I'll answer for you:
Today, with taxes, fees, fines, etc. government steals more than half of one's income.....socialism.
It is the single greatest bar to wealth accumulation, and prevents the voluntary generosity that the Bible endorses.
You're dismissed.
I have nothing against capitalism, it's crony capitalism and greed that can be harmful.
I just don't think your trying to now change the subject, after being shown taxes or thrithing took place back then, by law, to a
"Yeah, but look at their 10% tax rate compared to today" was relevant to your op' s initial contention...
The subject, simply, is that Jesus encouraged free markets, capitalism, and individualism. Generosity is based on prosperity, and this is an attribute of capitalism, not the socialism you vote for.
Your attempt to change the subject will not occur.....I will not allow it.
No, he did not promote free for all markets...He promoted regulated capitalism, with Mark ups limited to a maximum of only 10% above costs, that prevented capitalists from taking advantage of people who earned little. Was that socialism? Or a mixed capitalism and socialism, or just a well regulated capitalistic economy?
I think Christ relied on capitalists, those in business, to fund the poor's needs and that without them, the poor would not be fed, minus a miracle from him, like when he fed 5000
and he would not always be around... So yes, I agree that he relied on those in business to make money to take care of the needy, and this is why he supported regulated capitalism.
The Law, was what their Theocratic govt used to regulate the profit earned by the capitalists, and taxation of the capitalist.... this was not talking about secular gov't law, but Theocratic law, God's Law.....The poor, and those just getting by, were not taxed....true, they did not pay tithes, but many of them received the benefits of the tithe...Voluntary generosity at the time of those in Jesus's time, occurred AFTER they paid their tithe... much like today... And I suppose capitalism made those wealthy enough to pay tithes, and give generously on a voluntary basis as well...Who cares?
It is not part of the thread topic....
Because you are both ignorant, and a coward....you know the correct answer indicts the party you support.....I'll answer for you:
Today, with taxes, fees, fines, etc. government steals more than half of one's income.....socialism.
It is the single greatest bar to wealth accumulation, and prevents the voluntary generosity that the Bible endorses.
You're dismissed.
I have nothing against capitalism, it's crony capitalism and greed that can be harmful.
I just don't think your trying to now change the subject, after being shown taxes or thrithing took place back then, by law, to a
"Yeah, but look at their 10% tax rate compared to today" was relevant to your op' s initial contention...
The subject, simply, is that Jesus encouraged free markets, capitalism, and individualism. Generosity is based on prosperity, and this is an attribute of capitalism, not the socialism you vote for.
Your attempt to change the subject will not occur.....I will not allow it.
No, he did not promote free for all markets...He promoted regulated capitalism, with Mark ups limited to a maximum of only 10% above costs, that prevented capitalists from taking advantage of people who earned little. Was that socialism? Or a mixed capitalism and socialism, or just a well regulated capitalistic economy?
I think Christ relied on capitalists, those in business, to fund the poor's needs and that without them, the poor would not be fed, minus a miracle from him, like when he fed 5000
and he would not always be around... So yes, I agree that he relied on those in business to make money to take care of the needy, and this is why he supported regulated capitalism.
"...he (sic) did not promote free for all markets..."
What does that even mean?
"He promoted regulated capitalism..."
Regulated by government? Are you suggesting that Jesus favored redistribution, confiscation, limits on wealth and earnings????
"...with Mark ups limited to a maximum of only 10% above costs..."
You made that up, huh?
"I think Christ relied on capitalists"
Pretty much the theme of this thread.
"...that without them, the poor would not be fed, minus a miracle from him, like when he fed 5000.."
No miracle needed.....the Bible endorses work....unlike the Democrats who endorse 'financial security for those who don't care to work."
For able-bodied people, God’s welfare system is—work. How different from modern social welfare programs!
In fact, the Bible is clear that people should be rewarded by what they contribute to society.
The Bible is specific about what God expects of able-bodied members of society. In 2 Thessalonians 3:10, Paul said, “If anyone will not work, neither shall he eat”
The Law, was what their Theocratic govt used to regulate the profit earned by the capitalists, and taxation of the capitalist.... this was not talking about secular gov't law, but Theocratic law, God's Law.....The poor, and those just getting by, were not taxed....true, they did not pay tithes, but many of them received the benefits of the tithe...Voluntary generosity at the time of those in Jesus's time, occurred AFTER they paid their tithe... much like today... And I suppose capitalism made those wealthy enough to pay tithes, and give generously on a voluntary basis as well...Because you are both ignorant, and a coward....you know the correct answer indicts the party you support.....I'll answer for you:
Today, with taxes, fees, fines, etc. government steals more than half of one's income.....socialism.
It is the single greatest bar to wealth accumulation, and prevents the voluntary generosity that the Bible endorses.
You're dismissed.
I have nothing against capitalism, it's crony capitalism and greed that can be harmful.
I just don't think your trying to now change the subject, after being shown taxes or thrithing took place back then, by law, to a
"Yeah, but look at their 10% tax rate compared to today" was relevant to your op' s initial contention...
The subject, simply, is that Jesus encouraged free markets, capitalism, and individualism. Generosity is based on prosperity, and this is an attribute of capitalism, not the socialism you vote for.
Your attempt to change the subject will not occur.....I will not allow it.
No, he did not promote free for all markets...He promoted regulated capitalism, with Mark ups limited to a maximum of only 10% above costs, that prevented capitalists from taking advantage of people who earned little. Was that socialism? Or a mixed capitalism and socialism, or just a well regulated capitalistic economy?
I think Christ relied on capitalists, those in business, to fund the poor's needs and that without them, the poor would not be fed, minus a miracle from him, like when he fed 5000
and he would not always be around... So yes, I agree that he relied on those in business to make money to take care of the needy, and this is why he supported regulated capitalism.
"...he (sic) did not promote free for all markets..."
What does that even mean?
"He promoted regulated capitalism..."
Regulated by government? Are you suggesting that Jesus favored redistribution, confiscation, limits on wealth and earnings????
"...with Mark ups limited to a maximum of only 10% above costs..."
You made that up, huh?
"I think Christ relied on capitalists"
Pretty much the theme of this thread.
"...that without them, the poor would not be fed, minus a miracle from him, like when he fed 5000.."
No miracle needed.....the Bible endorses work....unlike the Democrats who endorse 'financial security for those who don't care to work."
For able-bodied people, God’s welfare system is—work. How different from modern social welfare programs!
In fact, the Bible is clear that people should be rewarded by what they contribute to society.
The Bible is specific about what God expects of able-bodied members of society. In 2 Thessalonians 3:10, Paul said, “If anyone will not work, neither shall he eat”
It's actually what the parable of the coin with Caesar's head on it is about.... Jews were upset that not only were they taxed by their Theocratic laws of tithing, the Roman gvt was taxing them too...
Thus Jesus's reply of : Give to God what is God's, and give unto Caesar, what is his....
Chic, I could only read your reply "So you can't answer the question?" because playtime is on my Ignore List for obvious reasons.
As to the atheist *cartoon* about Christians not practicing what they preach, atheists have been lying about everything since time immemorial. I read the book Who Really Cares: Who Gives and Why It Matters by Arthur C. Brooks. Very enlightening.
1. People of faith give more to EVERYONE than atheists do. They give more money, more time, more blood and are happier as a result.
2. Conservatives give more than liberals, on average. Yes there are exceptions but consider a recent poll at Dartmouth. A journalist asked kiddies how much they thought Bernie Sanders donated of his own money to charity. The estimates ranged from "10%" to ""75%."
The actual figure: LESS THAN 1%. But he "cares." Just ask anyone. He just wants to donate YOUR money, not his.
Chic, I could only read your reply "So you can't answer the question?" because playtime is on my Ignore List for obvious reasons.
As to the atheist *cartoon* about Christians not practicing what they preach, atheists have been lying about everything since time immemorial. I read the book Who Really Cares: Who Gives and Why It Matters by Arthur C. Brooks. Very enlightening.
1. People of faith give more to EVERYONE than atheists do. They give more money, more time, more blood and are happier as a result.
2. Conservatives give more than liberals, on average. Yes there are exceptions but consider a recent poll at Dartmouth. A journalist asked kiddies how much they thought Bernie Sanders donated of his own money to charity. The estimates ranged from "10%" to ""75%."
The actual figure: LESS THAN 1%. But he "cares." Just ask anyone. He just wants to donate YOUR money, not his.
Maybe he didn't, but I did!Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth,
You didn't.
You can't, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
Excellent point......bet you've read this book:
i counterpointed di-rectly to the topic of yer thread there chicky poo.
Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth, of supporting those unwilling to work, confiscatory taxation, or the end of private property....the agenda of socialism/communism?????
You didn't.
You can't, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
quote me where he is. i mean exact quotes - not some pablum spun to fit yer agenda.
Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth, of supporting those unwilling to work, confiscatory taxation, or the end of private property....the agenda of socialism/communism?????
You didn't.
Jesus' message is in support of freedom, not compulsion.
Compulsion, coercion, is indivisible from Liberalism, communism, Progressivism, socialism, Nazism, and Fascism.
You can't find any quotes that refuse my posts, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
so jesus wanted payment & thought payment due or no laying on of the hands 'eh?
So you can't answer the question?
Shocking.
Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth, of supporting those unwilling to work, confiscatory taxation, or the end of private property....the agenda of socialism/communism?????
You didn't.
You can't, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
quote me where he is. i mean exact quotes - not some pablum spun to fit yer agenda.
Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth, of supporting those unwilling to work, confiscatory taxation, or the end of private property....the agenda of socialism/communism?????
You didn't.
Jesus' message is in support of freedom, not compulsion.
Compulsion, coercion, is indivisible from Liberalism, communism, Progressivism, socialism, Nazism, and Fascism.
You can't find any quotes that refuse my posts, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
so jesus wanted payment & thought payment due or no laying on of the hands 'eh?
So you can't answer the question?
Shocking.
you can't refudiate what i said. did jesus believe in free market capitalistic for profit healthcare?
Chic, I could only read your reply "So you can't answer the question?" because playtime is on my Ignore List for obvious reasons.
As to the atheist *cartoon* about Christians not practicing what they preach, atheists have been lying about everything since time immemorial. I read the book Who Really Cares: Who Gives and Why It Matters by Arthur C. Brooks. Very enlightening.
1. People of faith give more to EVERYONE than atheists do. They give more money, more time, more blood and are happier as a result.
2. Conservatives give more than liberals, on average. Yes there are exceptions but consider a recent poll at Dartmouth. A journalist asked kiddies how much they thought Bernie Sanders donated of his own money to charity. The estimates ranged from "10%" to ""75%."
The actual figure: LESS THAN 1%. But he "cares." Just ask anyone. He just wants to donate YOUR money, not his.
Excellent point......bet you've read this book:
Chic, I could only read your reply "So you can't answer the question?" because playtime is on my Ignore List for obvious reasons.
As to the atheist *cartoon* about Christians not practicing what they preach, atheists have been lying about everything since time immemorial. I read the book Who Really Cares: Who Gives and Why It Matters by Arthur C. Brooks. Very enlightening.
1. People of faith give more to EVERYONE than atheists do. They give more money, more time, more blood and are happier as a result.
2. Conservatives give more than liberals, on average. Yes there are exceptions but consider a recent poll at Dartmouth. A journalist asked kiddies how much they thought Bernie Sanders donated of his own money to charity. The estimates ranged from "10%" to ""75%."
The actual figure: LESS THAN 1%. But he "cares." Just ask anyone. He just wants to donate YOUR money, not his.
Excellent point......bet you've read this book:
you can tell chemengineer thanx for the iggy but he is ig-nor-ant.
i am not an atheist. i am a christian.
maybe he & you should try a little matthew 6: 5-11.
Chic, I could only read your reply "So you can't answer the question?" because playtime is on my Ignore List for obvious reasons.
As to the atheist *cartoon* about Christians not practicing what they preach, atheists have been lying about everything since time immemorial. I read the book Who Really Cares: Who Gives and Why It Matters by Arthur C. Brooks. Very enlightening.
1. People of faith give more to EVERYONE than atheists do. They give more money, more time, more blood and are happier as a result.
2. Conservatives give more than liberals, on average. Yes there are exceptions but consider a recent poll at Dartmouth. A journalist asked kiddies how much they thought Bernie Sanders donated of his own money to charity. The estimates ranged from "10%" to ""75%."
The actual figure: LESS THAN 1%. But he "cares." Just ask anyone. He just wants to donate YOUR money, not his.
Excellent point......bet you've read this book:
you can tell chemengineer thanx for the iggy but he is ig-nor-ant.
i am not an atheist. i am a christian.
maybe he & you should try a little matthew 6: 5-11.
I can't begin to tell you how deeply interested I am in your life details.....
...but back to the point:
Where did you quote Jesus declaring for redistribution of wealth, of supporting those unwilling to work, confiscatory taxation, or the end of private property....the agenda of socialism/communism?????
You didn't.
You can't, because, as always, I am 100% accurate, correct and true.
Governments keep people poor and enslaved.....capitalism frees them and makes them prosperous.
View attachment 309613Jesus will remember who had abortions, and who allowed abortions, and who tried to stop abortions...
are you saying that the bible never condoned abortion?
The Law, was what their Theocratic govt used to regulate the profit earned by the capitalists, and taxation of the capitalist.... this was not talking about secular gov't law, but Theocratic law, God's Law.....
It's actually what the parable of the coin with Caesar's head on it is about.... Jews were upset that not only were they taxed by their Theocratic laws of tithing, the Roman gvt was taxing them too...
Thus Jesus's reply of : Give to God what is God's, and give unto Caesar, what is his....
View attachment 309613Jesus will remember who had abortions, and who allowed abortions, and who tried to stop abortions...
are you saying that the bible never condoned abortion?
I don't remember anywhere in the bible there being a discussion
of legal abortion
Governments keep people poor and enslaved.....capitalism frees them and makes them prosperous.
Capitalism is the banks, not the government.
What caused the great depression?
Let me end my talk by abusing slightly my status as an official representative of the Federal Reserve. I would like to say to Milton and Anna: Regarding the Great Depression, you're right. We did it. We're very sorry. But thanks to you, we won't do it again.
— Ben S. Bernanke
Who did it? Surely wasn't the government but CAPITALISM.
What were the consequences?
CRIME.
Like today's third world countries. here in the US, while the great depression was in progress, the rising of gangsters and the daily robbery was in increment because people were in need of the basic supplies for living.
Here is when you see the emerging of the social services from the government helping the needed. Here is when socialist methods were applied to avoid chaos in society. Just check it in your history books.
I can tell you this, you end social services in the US and this country will have an increase in crime like a third world country. No because drugs but because the need for food at home. Capitalism alone won't survive and rich people will be exposed to crime not because the people turns bad but because people will become desperate for survival.
Do you remember Katrina? Poor people, who didn't receive government help on time, went to the rich people areas and even killed the owners for food plus to steal goods. Just check the reports from those days.
Perhaps you have the impression that capitalism alone works great and that is the solution for all kind of economical situations, but history is against your ideology. And history is the last word.
View attachment 309613Jesus will remember who had abortions, and who allowed abortions, and who tried to stop abortions...
are you saying that the bible never condoned abortion?
I don't remember anywhere in the bible there being a discussion
of legal abortion