The Greater Israel Theory is an Antisemitic Myth

[rosends]

Today, about 90% of Palestinian citizens of Israel live in 139 densely populated towns and villages in the Galilee and Triangle regions in northern Israel and the Negev/Naqab region in the south. The remaining 10% live in “mixed cities”, including Haifa, Ramla, Lod, Jaffa and Acre. As will be seen below, this has been the result of deliberate policies by the government of Israel to segregate Palestinian citizens of Israel into enclaves as part of the wider goal of ensuring the Jewish settlement and control of as much of Israel’s territory as possible.

Israel’s apartheid against Palestinians: Cruel system of domination and crime against humanity - Amnesty International

Amnesty International has analysed Israel’s intent to create and maintain a system of oppression and domination over Palestinians and examined its key components: territorial fragmentation; segregation and control; dispossession of land and property; and denial of economic and social rights. It...

www.amnesty.org

What are "Palestinian citizens of Israel"?

Amnesty International’s Cruel Assault on Israel: Systematic Lies, Errors, Omissions & Double Standards - ngomonitor

In February 2022, Amnesty released a 280-page report on Apartheid. As detailed in this report, the publication is fundamentally flawed, using lies, distortions, omissions, and egregious double standards to construct a fraudulent and libelous narrative of Israeli cruelty

ngo-monitor.org

 

[rosends]

Yes, in Israel.

So you will intentionally ignore apartheid in Iran. Interesting.

 

[JoeB131]

I'm following all your dodges. Hezbollah has fired over 14,000 rockets into Israel. Hezbollah has built tunnels and other military infrastructure along the border with Israel and has used that military infrastructure to invade Israel and otherwise violate Israel's territorial integrity, political independence, and sovereignty.

Do you deny that these acts are violations of international law?

The Zionist Entity's existence violates international law.

 

[JoeB131]

So you will intentionally ignore apartheid in Iran. Interesting.

Not really. Persians are the majority, but other minorities are represented. For instance, Solomani (sp) was a member of the Lurs minority, but was a major representative of the regime.

 

[Lisa558]

Ok, so you're saying you are a slow learner as well as a racist. By law in Muslim lands Jews were second class citizens subject to persecutions and humiliation, but in Israel all Jews and Arab citizens have the same rights. Apparently that is a difficult concept for you to comprehend but try.

The Arabs always refused to live in peace with the Jews since the 6th century. The Jews in the ME were a conquered people who were held in contempt by their Arab conquerors and made to suffer persecution and humiliations for centuries until western values arrived in the ME after WWI and the Jews in the ME were able to free themselves.

The problems with the Palestinians all come from their refusal to live in peace with Jews, from the 6th century right down to today.

Obviously, this whole subject is too difficult for you to comprehend.

Winston, the ignorant antisemite you responded to, is a leftist who has BRAGGED that he raised all six of his children on welfare. He’s a selfish, entitled Jew-hating leftist.

 

[Lisa558]

So you will intentionally ignore apartheid in Iran. Interesting.

Those are the double standards that antisemites apply to Israel. It’s the most obvious “tell.”

 

[JoeB131]

Those are the double standards that antisemites apply to Israel. It’s the most obvious “tell.”

Actually, the only "double standard" is the one that favors the Zionist Entity.

Any other country that commits genocide and wages constant wars against its neighbors would be treated as an international pariah, subject to sanctions and perhaps invasion.

 

[rosends]

Not really. Persians are the majority, but other minorities are represented. For instance, Solomani (sp) was a member of the Lurs minority, but was a major representative of the regime.

the poster agreed that in Iran, there are different laws and limitations for minorities based on their ethnic identity. That's apartheid. You can try to ignore it also if you want.

 

[JoeB131]

the poster agreed that in Iran, there are different laws and limitations for minorities based on their ethnic identity. That's apartheid. You can try to ignore it also if you want.

I didn't agree to anything, so there's that.

Iran is a majority Persian Nation, but other minorities are represented in their elected parliament.

Unlike the Occupied Territories of the Zionist Entity.

 

[rosends]

I didn't agree to anything, so there's that.

I know -- I was responding to someone else (Winston) and you replied with a statement which ignored the conversation's progress.

Iran is a majority Persian Nation, but other minorities are represented in their elected parliament.

Unlike the Occupied Territories of the Zionist Entity.

So there are no Muslim or Christians in Israel's government? Really?

 

[Lisa558]

Actually, the only "double standard" is the one that favors the Zionist Entity.

Any other country that commits genocide and wages constant wars against its neighbors would be treated as an international pariah, subject to sanctions and perhaps invasion.

^^^ Other tells is when a poster:

1) uses the phrase “Zionist Entity”
2) Lies and says Israel is committing genocide
3) Lies and says Israel would be treated like an international pariah when it is IRAN that, justifiably so, has become the pariah

(Joe is such a Jew-hater that he actually said Jews brought the Holocaust on themselves by the way they behaved.)

 

[JoeB131]

^^^ Other tells is when a poster:

1) uses the phrase “Zionist Entity”
2) Lies and says Israel is committing genocide
3) Lies and says Israel would be treated like an international pariah when it is IRAN that, justifiably so, has become the pariah

1) Calling it the Zionist Entity defines the fact it is an apartheid state.
2) What the Zionist Entity is doing in Gaza qualifies as Genocide under the UN charter. It was the same standard that was used in Yugoslavia and Rwanda.
3) The Zionist Entity WOULD be treated as an international pariah if the US didn't use its veto power in the UN to protect it.

Iran, on the other hand, is being treated like a pariah because its people rose up and deposed the Western-approved despot.

We've been at war in the Middle East in some shape or form since the 1980s. When does it end?

 

[gipper]

To counteract the lie being pushed by antisemites on this thread, I bring up the reasons why the Greater Israel project is being twisted to drive more hostility toward Jews:

1) Israel has always offered land for peace, thus willing to reduce its area, but the Jew-hating Palestinians have always rejected the offers.

2) Any increase in land mass (now currently 0.4% with Arabs taking 99.6%) has been a fraction of a percent and driven by security concerns - not expansion.

3) Those who are claiming Israel’s war on Iran is driven by this “expansion” myth ignore that Israel never had any plans to take any part of Iran.

4) In 1979, Israel returned the entire Sinai Peninsula to Egypt.

5) In 2005, Israel vacated Gaza. (And look at the thanks they got.)


View attachment 1234991

Why the “Greater Israel” theory is false - IsraelFAQs

This post is also available in: English Español (Spanish) Italiano (Italian) Português (Portuguese (Brazil)) Русский (Russian)Short answer Anti-Israel voices often accuse the country of pursuing a so-called “Greater Israel” agenda—claiming it is driven by a religiously motivated, systematic...

israelfaqs.com

Can you believe the nerve of this antisemitic American Jew?

MIGA!!!!!!

 

[Winston]

Wow. Now, THAT is a statement.

So, you are complaining that Arabs don't have access to Israeli citizenship, while proudly declaring that no JEW will ever live in Palestine (let alone obtain citizenship) and proclaim Israel the apartheid State? Rich.

I do also wonder if this means that any territory containing a Jew will be excluded from being part of the State of Palestine.

You are a flipping moron. No Jew lives in Gaza now you fawkin dope, they have not since 2005. Now, I am quite sure you could move there if you like. Doubt there are any barriers. And yes, if Palestine is created there will certainly be a place for Judaism, just as in the past.

 

[Winston]

So you will intentionally ignore apartheid in Iran. Interesting.

What Apartheid? Are Jews confined to certain communities? Is their travel restricted? Because Palestinians are confined to certain communities in Israel, their travel is restricted, and they have limited job opportunities.

 

[gipper]

To counteract the lie being pushed by antisemites on this thread, I bring up the reasons why the Greater Israel project is being twisted to drive more hostility toward Jews:

1) Israel has always offered land for peace, thus willing to reduce its area, but the Jew-hating Palestinians have always rejected the offers.

2) Any increase in land mass (now currently 0.4% with Arabs taking 99.6%) has been a fraction of a percent and driven by security concerns - not expansion.

3) Those who are claiming Israel’s war on Iran is driven by this “expansion” myth ignore that Israel never had any plans to take any part of Iran.

4) In 1979, Israel returned the entire Sinai Peninsula to Egypt.

5) In 2005, Israel vacated Gaza. (And look at the thanks they got.)


View attachment 1234991

Why the “Greater Israel” theory is false - IsraelFAQs

This post is also available in: English Español (Spanish) Italiano (Italian) Português (Portuguese (Brazil)) Русский (Russian)Short answer Anti-Israel voices often accuse the country of pursuing a so-called “Greater Israel” agenda—claiming it is driven by a religiously motivated, systematic...

israelfaqs.com

Wow! Another antisemitic American Jew!

MIGA!!!!

 

[Winston]

What are "Palestinian citizens of Israel"?

Amnesty International’s Cruel Assault on Israel: Systematic Lies, Errors, Omissions & Double Standards - ngomonitor

In February 2022, Amnesty released a 280-page report on Apartheid. As detailed in this report, the publication is fundamentally flawed, using lies, distortions, omissions, and egregious double standards to construct a fraudulent and libelous narrative of Israeli cruelty

ngo-monitor.org

Take that Jewish propaganda shit the hell out of here.

 

[rosends]

What Apartheid? Are Jews confined to certain communities? Is their travel restricted? Because Palestinians are confined to certain communities in Israel, their travel is restricted, and they have limited job opportunities.

Let's try this again -- you acknowledge that in Iran, non-Muslims are blocked from holding certain jobs or positions in politics.

"Like other religious minorities in Iran, Jews face certain restrictions, including limitations on holding some senior government or military positions. "

This is apartheid. But you don't want to address that. Why?

 

[gipper]

To counteract the lie being pushed by antisemites on this thread, I bring up the reasons why the Greater Israel project is being twisted to drive more hostility toward Jews:

1) Israel has always offered land for peace, thus willing to reduce its area, but the Jew-hating Palestinians have always rejected the offers.

2) Any increase in land mass (now currently 0.4% with Arabs taking 99.6%) has been a fraction of a percent and driven by security concerns - not expansion.

3) Those who are claiming Israel’s war on Iran is driven by this “expansion” myth ignore that Israel never had any plans to take any part of Iran.

4) In 1979, Israel returned the entire Sinai Peninsula to Egypt.

5) In 2005, Israel vacated Gaza. (And look at the thanks they got.)


View attachment 1234991

Why the “Greater Israel” theory is false - IsraelFAQs

This post is also available in: English Español (Spanish) Italiano (Italian) Português (Portuguese (Brazil)) Русский (Russian)Short answer Anti-Israel voices often accuse the country of pursuing a so-called “Greater Israel” agenda—claiming it is driven by a religiously motivated, systematic...

israelfaqs.com

Yet another antisemitic American Jew. WTF!

MIGA!!!

 

[rosends]

Take that Jewish propaganda shit the hell out of here.

can't answer the question I notice. Your anger makes you weak.