Westwall writing a rebuttal paper? LOL For years he has claimed membership in the AGU, and then claimed that all the scientists that publish the videos from their annual meetings concerning AGW are liars. I have repeatedly challenged him to schedule a speaking appearance there, and prove all those scientists wrong. However, he knows he has no evidence to prove them wrong, and they have all the evidence needed to prover AGW beyond a reasonable doubt. In fact, why doesn't he just post articles from the journals of the AGU or GSA presenting overwhelming evidence that AGW is wrong? Because there are no such articles in existence. How about from the Royal Society? Again, nothing. Some PhD geologist.