Kalam
Senior Member
- Mar 5, 2009
- 8,866
- 785
- 48
Abrogation is not as complicated as you would like to think Ibn Hazm the author of an-Nasikh wal-Mansukh,states that there are 114 verses that speak of tolerance in early Islam, but all were abrogated by one verse, "Slay the idolaters wherever you find them" (Q. 9:5)You stated that this came from the "first surah," which I found funny. And thank you for demonstrating that the concept of nasikh and mansukh is above your level of comprehension.Abrogation does not apply to anything but the Qur'an? Does that mean that Allah is the only person that is ever wrong?
Can you show me the hadith in which he (SAWS) indicates that this has been "abrogated"?It still comes down to when Muhammad said this, and what he said after. Even if it is not the Qur'an, it can still be abrogated by something he said later.
Ibn Hazm jurist and theologian.
Addressed by as-Suyuti, who demonstrated that no more than 21 ayat are nasikh and mansukh; and subsequently by Shah Waliullah, who posited that as-Suyuti's 21 could be reduced to 5.