Vietnam gets reminder of difficult past

[Kagom]

Vietnam gets reminder of difficult past

By TRAN VAN MINH, Associated Press Writer
Sun Jan 28, 11:41 AM ET

HANOI, Vietnam - A bowl of noodle soup for breakfast was beyond the dreams of most people back in the days before Vietnam's economic reforms.

Once a month my mother would take my three sisters and me to a noodle restaurant. We could only afford one small bowl each, with boiled rice we brought from home to make it more filling.

These memories pour back at an exhibit at Hanoi's Museum of Ethnology titled "Thoi Bao Cap" — the Subsidized Period.

Coming at a time when free-market reforms are taking root and the gap between rich and poor is becoming evident, the exhibit is a reminder to the public of how hard life was before Vietnam began injecting capitalism into its communist system.

Vietnam's postwar generation, more than half the population, lives in one of the world's fastest-growing economies and has no first-hand memories of the hard times.

The show has drawn record crowds and earned praise for its frank depiction of the shortcomings of the past, when the government micromanaged even the smallest economic transactions, consumer goods were scarce, and people lined up for hours for meager rations.

Introduced following the defeat of the French colonialists at Dien Bien Phu in 1954, the system was extended to the whole of the country after the Vietnam War ended in 1975. Then, in the mid-1980s, the government began a gradual program of market-oriented reforms known as Doi Moi, or renovation.

Now Vietnam's economy is booming, and a middle-class is emerging. Fancy restaurants are proliferating in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, and supermarkets are competing with street vendors balancing baskets of fruit and vegetables over their shoulders.

In the subsidized period, everything from fish sauce to bicycles was rationed.

The exhibit displays copies of old rationing coupons and charts listing the privileges of high-ranking officials — about 9 pounds of meat a month, 9 pounds of fish, four pints of fish sauce, 4 1/2 pounds of sugar.

Ordinary people received one-fourth to one-tenth as much.

As a boy of 12 when the Vietnam War ended, I stood in long lines to pick up meager, low-quality food rations, while my family improvised at home.

In place of cooking oil, we used imported Mongolian sheep fat to fry rice, with a few drops of water added to ease the stench.

The exhibit has a life-size model of queues at state-owned shops, and displays of what were regarded as luxuries: a French-made bicycle, an electric fan, a bar of scented Camay soap. In those days, Soviet laundry detergent sometimes served for bath suds.

The exhibit shows a model of what was then considered a luxurious apartment — about 25 feet by 10 feet with one bed and most of the occupants sleeping on the floor.

Almost everyone had to do extra work to make ends meet. My mother baked cakes. My college classmate's family raised pigs in the bathroom of their Hanoi apartment and even trained them to use the toilet — a hole in the floor.

"I just cannot believe that a bar of Camay soap was a luxury at that time," said Dinh Thi Dinh, 20, a Hanoi university student. "This exhibit has inspired me to study harder to deserve the sacrifices of my parents and my grandparents."

Another visitor, 71-year-old Nguyen Thi Tho, remembered queuing for food from 2 a.m.

"Sometimes I had to go back two to three times because the rice or meat was sold out before my turn came," she said.

Nguyen Van Huy, the museum director, said the crowds turning out for the exhibit have been so big that the museum decided to extend its run for another six months.

The museum is government-owned, but the message of hardship and privilege under communism is unadorned.

Huy, however, couched the exhibit's purpose in positive terms — to highlight the benefits of Doi Moi.

Visitors come away understanding that the change was essential, he said. In the past, people dreamed of having a bicycle like the one on display, he said. "Now some people have cars."

And my sisters and I can afford a big bowl of soup each day for breakfast.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070128/ap_on_re_la_am_ca/vietnam_hard_times

It can't rain every day.

 

[Psychoblues]

Was the gist of this pre, post or during the American occupation?

 

[Gunny]

It can't rain every day.

Ever read about how Southern families lived in the CSA during the War of Northern Agression where the South was used as a battlefield; especially between Washington DC and Richmond?

War sucks. It destroys people and property and makes life almost unbearable for the living.

 

[doniston]

Ever read about how Southern families lived in the CSA during the War of Northern Agression where the South was used as a battlefield; especially between Washington DC and Richmond?

War sucks. It destroys people and property and makes life almost unbearable for the living.

Oh come on now, are you now going to rehash the Civil war? (The war of northern agression?) Really.

 

[Gunny]

Oh come on now, are you now going to rehash the Civil war? (The war of northern agression?) Really.

Does my statement imply rehashing the US Civil War in any way? No it doesn't. Looks like an example to me.

 

[Doug]

Psychoblues wonders if the period of deep poverty experienced by the Vietnamese people (the average people) was before, during, or after the American presence there.

The poverty being referred to by the exhibition was after we left, and therefore after the triumph of the Communist forces, who proceded to communize all of Vietnam as they unified it, contrary to various hints and promises they had given to certain gullible Leftist idiots during the war.

But there is nothing particularly surprising about it. It has been the same story where ever communism triumphed -- Russia, China, Cuba, Korea, and Vietnam: political repression along with deep poverty.

Where ever what Psychoblues calls the "American occupation" was successful in holding back communism -- South Korea, Taiwan -- you got rapid economic growth and, finally, a democratic society. This would almost certainly have been the case in Vietnam, had we prevailed there.