USS Liberty

[JoeB131]

Did you talk to these Jews after you attended one of your Students for Blaming the Holocaust on the Jews meetings?

Now, funny thing. Going into College, I was kind of sympathetic to Israel. After four years of dealing with these people, I was a lot less sympathetic. Of course, the Shatilla Massacre didn't help matters much.

Ouch. I'm a former signal intelligence analyst. 21 years of service. No, in the 1960s a SIGINT ship like the Liberty could not pick up tactical and HQ voice communications from thousands of miles away.

Sure you are... sure you are.

Of course they did, just as the neo-Nazis, Hamas, ISIS, and Hezbollah claim.

Again, the Zionists are the ones out there killing women and Children... They don't have the high ground.

So once again you claim that the Jews provoked Hitler's animosity! And here I thought you were going to try to back-pedal and weasel-word your way out of your neo-Nazi statement, but you've doubled-down on it!

No, the animosity was ingrained mainly in Christian culture, from Passion Plays to Martin Luther.

But let's not pretend they were totally innocent. SOME of them did some pretty shitty stuff. Like overthrowing the Kaiser in 1918. That lead to a humiliating peace treaty and years of economic hardship. I should know, my grandparents lived it. Or engaging in rampant currency speculation that wiped out the life savings of many Germans.

Your Hero Trump does the same thing Hitler did, except his victims are Hispanic and Muslim. YOu are fine with it.

Okay, yes, we are clear: You believe that Hitler did something terrible because those lousy vermin Jews provoked his animosity by screwing Germany and most of the rest of Europe after WWI. Got it. Duly noted.

No, Hitler did something terrible because he was an evil person.

It didn't mean that the average German wasn't damned mad and had every right to be.

 

[PeterPilot]

mikegriffith1

Have you ever read Albert Einstein's thoughts on statehood for Jewish Zionists? He and Hannah Arendt talked about that and other matters in a letter to the editor to NYT in December 1948. A quick summary is that while he certainly favored a homeland for his Jewish brethren, he very strongly opposed statehood for the same. He pointed out that the Zionists in the Jewish community were very much like the Nazis in "methods and philosophy". He was right.