This judge hasn't been paying attention.

[berg80]

The bill of rights is not limited to citizens. I have already quoted the fourth and fifth amendments. "The people", "All persons", show me where it the Constitution those rights are limited to citizens.

MAGAists apparently believe the BoR's and Constitution only apply to those people trump allows them to apply to.

 

[Mac-7]

it seems equally clear, that the individual who considers himself injured, has a right to resort to the laws of his country for a remedy

The 7 men deported are not US citizens

But they are free to appeal to their home country for a remedy

 

[The Duke]

Okay. I've had it.
These shitneck retarded judges have no right to obstruct the president upholding Article IV, Section 4 of The Constitution with his Article II powers. Them doing so, and if it can be proven, means they are violating their oaths of office and can be removed, jailed, and fined.

 

[struth]

Damn but the stupid in this thread is deep. The Constitution did not adequately define the role of the Judicial Branch, especially when it came to the checks and balances Madison and Hamilton spoke of. That was determined by the SCOTUS in Marbury verses Madison. That single ruling, perhaps the most important ruling in American Judicial History, made the Constitution the supreme law of the land. Before, it was just a statement of ideals and principles.

No it wasn’t, the supremacy clause makes it tha supreme law. Malbury established judicial review, which is an inherit part of the judicial power

Damn but the stupid in this thread is deep. The Constitution did not adequately define the role of the Judicial Branch, especially when it came to the checks and balances Madison and Hamilton spoke of. That was determined by the SCOTUS in Marbury verses Madison. That single ruling, perhaps the most important ruling in American Judicial History, made the Constitution the supreme law of the land. Before, it was just a statement of ideals and principles.

 

[80zephyr]

By asking the regime to obey a court order? If members of the regime think the judge has exceeded his authority they have the right to seek judicial relief by appealing the order. What they can't do is blatantly ignore the order.........as they have done repeatedly with a variety of court orders.

Exactly what the left wants. I bet you prefer that everything that Trump does gets tied up in court for about 4 years or so, right?

 

[Mac-7]

By asking the regime to obey a court order? If members of the regime think the judge has exceeded his authority they have the right to seek judicial relief by appealing the order. What they can't do is blatantly ignore the order.........as they have done repeatedly with a variety of court orders.

These unelected partisan democrat judges are overstepping their authority in an effort to override the will of the voters

And trump is bending over backwards to comply since the 7 are still in custody pending repatriation to their home country

 

[80zephyr]

You just answered my question. You support trump violating the Constitution.

How is he doing that?

 

[Dragonlady]

They were criminals, right?

Who, Trump and his gang. These people being deported have not been proven to have committed ANY crimes. Provide proof and THEN ship them back.

Trumps immigration policy is simply to enforce the current federal law.

Trump is not enforcing current immigration law, he's flouting it. Marco Rubio has complained that the Constitution is an impediment to speedy, mass deportations. Well at least SOMETHINIG is an impediment to their lawlessness.

 

[Rawley]

If Trump has the legal right to deport them, then give them due process. The fact that he hasn't, something guaranteed for all people within our borders, citizens, illegals, FUCKING PIRATES, shows that he knows his actions would not be acceptable under the Constitution.

What "due process" were these animals denied?

Enrique Arias-Hierro, a citizen of Cuba. He has convictions for homicide, armed robbery, strongarm robbery, kidnapping, and false impersonation of an official. He was arrested by ICE on May 2, 2025.

Jose Manuel Rodriguez-Quinones, a citizen of Cuba. He has convictions for attempted first degree murder with a weapon, battery, larceny, cocaine possession, and cocaine trafficking. He was arrested by ICE on April 30, 2025.

Thongxay Nilakout, a citizen of Laos. He has convictions for first-degree murder and robbery. He was arrested by ICE on January 26, 2025.

Jesus Munoz-Gutierrez, a citizen of Mexico. He has a conviction for second-degree murder. He was arrested by ICE on May 12, 2025.

Dian Peter Domach, a citizen of South Sudan. He has convictions for robbery, possession of a firearm, possession of burglar’s tools, possession of a defaced firearm, and driving under the influence. He was arrested by ICE on May 8, 2024.

Kyaw Mya, a citizen of Burma. He has a conviction for lascivious acts with a child victim less than 12 years of age. He was arrested by ICE on February 18, 2025.

Nyo Myint, a citizen of Burma. He has a conviction for first-degree sexual assault involving a victim mentally and physically incapable of resisting and has also been charged with aggravated assault (non-family strongarm). He was arrested by ICE on February 19, 2025.

Tuan Thanh Phan, a citizen of Vietnam. He has convictions for first-degree murder and second-degree assault. He was arrested by ICE on May 3, 2025.

 

[Orangecat]

Judge pleads with Trump administration for “reason over rhetoric” in deportation case​

A federal judge said the Trump administration is falsely blaming him for a crisis of its own making: the rushed deportation of seven men to South Sudan in violation of court orders and constitutional due process.

U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy said Monday the hurried deportations were an overt violation of orders he put in place weeks ago, which required the administration to provide “meaningful” notice before deporting people to countries where they could face torture or death. Even after the violation, Murphy said he exercised restraint by not forcing the administration to bring the seven convicted violent criminals back to the United States.

“It continues to be the court’s hope that reason can get the better of rhetoric,” Murphy wrote in his withering Monday night order rejecting the Trump administration’s demand that he reconsider or delay the effect of his ruling. “The orders put in place here are sensible and conservative.”

https://www.politico.com/news/2025/05/27/judge-trump-south-sudan-deportation-case-00369946

Asking the regime for reason is like asking trump to admit he really did molest the 26 women who have accused him of various kinds of sexual assault. It ain't going to happen.

Trump is doing exactly what we elected him to do. Elections have consequences.

 

[80zephyr]

Provide proof and THEN ship them back.

• 1 minute ago

• New
• Add bookmark
• #109

Enrique Arias-Hierro, a citizen of Cuba. He has convictions for homicide, armed robbery, strongarm robbery, kidnapping, and false impersonation of an official. He was arrested by ICE on May 2, 2025.

Jose Manuel Rodriguez-Quinones, a citizen of Cuba. He has convictions for attempted first degree murder with a weapon, battery, larceny, cocaine possession, and cocaine trafficking. He was arrested by ICE on April 30, 2025.

Thongxay Nilakout, a citizen of Laos. He has convictions for first-degree murder and robbery. He was arrested by ICE on January 26, 2025.

Jesus Munoz-Gutierrez, a citizen of Mexico. He has a conviction for second-degree murder. He was arrested by ICE on May 12, 2025.

Dian Peter Domach, a citizen of South Sudan. He has convictions for robbery, possession of a firearm, possession of burglar’s tools, possession of a defaced firearm, and driving under the influence. He was arrested by ICE on May 8, 2024.

Kyaw Mya, a citizen of Burma. He has a conviction for lascivious acts with a child victim less than 12 years of age. He was arrested by ICE on February 18, 2025.

Nyo Myint, a citizen of Burma. He has a conviction for first-degree sexual assault involving a victim mentally and physically incapable of resisting and has also been charged with aggravated assault (non-family strongarm). He was arrested by ICE on February 19, 2025.

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

More ignorance.

Trump supporters might be surprised at how far the Constitution extends toward non-citizens once they're inside the country, however. Cases extending back to the 1800s, including ones brought by Chinese immigrants challenging the arbitrary seizure of their property, have established the rights of non-citizens under the Fourth and Fifth Amendments including due process and the right to a jury.

Does The Constitution Protect Non-Citizens? Judges Say Yes

Non-citizens have rights, too -- even under the U.S. Constitution.

www.forbes.com

Notice, the text of the Fourth and Fifth amendments has already been posted.

.


Rogue "progressive" judges say yes. Those who have been paid or blackmailed into saying something so stupid.



.

 

[Winston]

The president sets foreign policy according to The Constitution.
Fuck these retarded shitneck judges. They will get a Mega Bitchslap soon.

Again, this was all settled in Marbury v. Madison. The president sets foreign policy, he has every right to do so. But, he has to follow the law, and the Constitution is the Supreme Law of the land. It is the job of the courts, to be a "check" on monitoring the president and making sure he abides by that law.

It is fascinating. It all started with the election of 1800. A rematch between Adams and Jefferson, the same two candidates in 1796. It was perhaps, the most bitter election in American history. It ended in a tie and was one of two elections in American History decided by the House of Representatives, after like over 35 votes.

So Adams makes a last minute flurry of appointments to, well what do you know, the courts. Yep, those lower courts. Something like 60 appointments. They were called the Midnight Judges. They were all approved by Congress. Interestingly enough, it was Judge Marshall's brother that was tasked with delivering the commissions, and admirably, he delivered most of them. But Marbury, and a few others, did not receive their commission before Jefferson was sworn in.

Jefferson instructed his Secretary of State to not deliver those commissions. In his eyes, since the commissions were not delivered before Adams left office, they were null and void. The SCOTUS felt otherwise and issued a mandamus--yeah, look that word up, forcing Madison to deliver the commissions to Marbury and the others.

 

[rightwinger]

Hahaa no it’s none of those things

You idiot

You really, really need to read that Bill of Rights thing
There is more in there than the second amendment

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

You really, really need to read that Bill of Rights thing
There is more in there than the second amendment

.


Project harder, shill.




.

 

[Winston]

Don’t see where it says a District court judge has the power to run the Executive Branch.


‘Try again, Simp.

Your just stupid. The courts are not running the executive branch, they are interpreting the law and protecting the rights of "the people". The fourth and fifth amendment clearly extend their protections to non-citizens, even illegals once accepted inside the country. The right to due process has been a fixture within US law for more than 200 years.

Marshall's quote also clearly implies that the lower courts have the same powers as the SCOTUS, although the SCOTUS has the final say. Trump has the right to an appeal of any lower court ruling. Too bad is legal team is a bunch of flippin idiots.

 

[Dorian Mode]

Exactly what the left wants. I bet you prefer that everything that Trump does gets tied up in court for about 4 years or so, right?

That's what they want, but never underestimate the ability of the democraps to shoot themselves in the foot repeated. Look at how much effort they put in to keep Trump from getting reelected and yet all that dirty politics helped him get reelected and now he is able to thwart them more than they are able to thwart him. Now Trump is masterfully getting the American people to hate the democraps and even start to like the GOP. Maybe we should encourage these neo-leftists to go even more batshit insane and destroy any hopes of gaining seats in the midterms.

 

[Winston]

:crickets: from rightwinger

Any if you Lettards want to help the lil fella out?

Maybe you're not getting a response because no one has made the claim that Trump has to inform some pissant district judge about his actions. He doesn't have to inform them of jackshit. And the thing is, if none of the deportees, or other interested parties, had filed a grievance with the court, we wouldn't be talking about any of this.

 

[Winston]

Okay. I've had it.
These shitneck retarded judges have no right to obstruct the president upholding Article IV, Section 4 of The Constitution with his Article II powers. Them doing so, and if it can be proven, means they are violating their oaths of office and can be removed, jailed, and fined.

Damn, the invasion angle, how fucking lame.

 

[80zephyr]

Maybe you're not getting a response because no one has made the claim that Trump has to inform some pissant district judge about his actions. He doesn't have to inform them of jackshit. And the thing is, if none of the deportees, or other interested parties, had filed a grievance with the court, we wouldn't be talking about any of this.

Winston thinks Trump is breaking the law. I think the judges are. Why do we let the judges get the upper hand in this while the president has to wait this bullshit out?