Israel spraying toxins over Palestinian crops in Gaza

Status
Not open for further replies.
Lets just focus on reality here and all admit the original OP claim is just another palestinian lie intended to discredit Israel because the truth simply doesn't support the palestinian revisionist narrative.

Its more than obvious that there is no supporting evidence to the racism being expressed against Israel and the only way the bigots can hope to defend themselves is to lie

In the end the truth hurts. Racism is seldom if ever supported in fact.

Yeah, let's focus on reality here....

You cannot provide ANY evidence that the OP is a lie...

Go figure!

THat's not how it works Humanity. As with the "fake" Begin quote in another thread. ASSERTION of a lie doesn't REQUIRE us to prove it wrong. It requires YOU to provide the evidence and the details.

Forgive me, but in the REAL world that is EXACTLY how it works....

I put forward two articles that state that Israel is being naughty and, because you don't like it, call it a lie...

As with the "Begin quote" there are PLENTY of links out there putting forward 'evidence' that the quote is 'fake'....

Yet, you cannot produce a single piece of information to counter my OP....
 
Essentially they are currently "lawless" in terms of International compliance.

Pretty much the same as Israel then!






How about a link proving your fantasy claims then, or will you just ignore this request like you have the hundreds of others ?

No links required...

It is YOU who chooses to wear your zionut blinkers, tighter than most Phoney...

Google is your friend on this one! Though, you already know that Israel is not very internationally compliant!
 
Lets just focus on reality here and all admit the original OP claim is just another palestinian lie intended to discredit Israel because the truth simply doesn't support the palestinian revisionist narrative.

Its more than obvious that there is no supporting evidence to the racism being expressed against Israel and the only way the bigots can hope to defend themselves is to lie

In the end the truth hurts. Racism is seldom if ever supported in fact.

Yeah, let's focus on reality here....

You cannot provide ANY evidence that the OP is a lie...

Go figure!

THat's not how it works Humanity. As with the "fake" Begin quote in another thread. ASSERTION of a lie doesn't REQUIRE us to prove it wrong. It requires YOU to provide the evidence and the details.

Forgive me, but in the REAL world that is EXACTLY how it works....

I put forward two articles that state that Israel is being naughty and, because you don't like it, call it a lie...

As with the "Begin quote" there are PLENTY of links out there putting forward 'evidence' that the quote is 'fake'....

Yet, you cannot produce a single piece of information to counter my OP....

So any ALLEGATION is suddenly TRUTH?? Never been that way in the civilized world pal..

I presented a Pali slanted video interview with the GAZA resident saying that the spraying was on the Israeli side but DRIFTED into Pali farmland. Produce the damaged crops, the lab reports, and the photographic evidence.

There is NO evidence that the material was a PERMANENT herbicide and especially no evidence of any "chemical weapons" like Agent Orange. So what you got here is a gripe. Not an attack..
 
What I will acknowledged is that this buffer zone is not well defined. And has been enlarged and shrunk with every outbreak of violence. Stabilize the Gazan political situation, get some international support for a LEGIT government and NEGOTIATE for better definitions and border access..
 
Your sources ASSUME this is intentional. This article was referenced by your sources and is somewhat more objective. Except for the juiced up comparisons to "agent Orange" that have no relevence to the story.

IDF admits spraying herbicides inside the Gaza Strip | +972 Magazine

That TINY dark green strip beyond the farmed land is the crux of the dispute here. OBVIOUSLY not poisoned. And as I said early on -- herbicides such as Round-Up are TOTALLY approved for agricultural use in the USA. So cut the crap about poisons and toxins.

farmer.jpg
 
What you see in the pic above is the Israeli military post in a strip of land that IS KEPT BARREN.. So that killers can't lay IEDs or build tunnels thru it without detection. THAT area is sprayed regularly.. THEN there is about a 100 meter "no go zone" -- which is the dark green SCRUB strip.. Farmers can farm to within 100 yards of the Israeli line.

And if the crop dusting for the ISRAELI side were to "leak" --- it would have to go beyond that 100 m buffer zone to any crop damage at all. OR --- the Palis farmed into that zone..

This is LESS of an issue than my neighbor had with another neighbor about leaving tractor marks on his property in order to mow one of his fields..
 
That post had content -- I'm sure.. About 80 proof !!!! :poke:

So anytime you need to reminded that the deal for an Autonomous Gaza included a buffer zone -- or why Palestinians don't have rights of citizenship in any country -- you just ring me up... I'll also call you a cab if we have to.. :itsok:
I think you should produce evidence of this agreement.


Fisherman being shot at whilst they fish? Then how come so much of the evidence comes from well-camera'd journalists cluttering up the decks on their "fishing expeditions" into excluded zones?
How come there's so much evidence? Because Israel shoots at a lot of fishermen. And there's nothing wrong with journalists on a boat. Furthermore, Israel has no jurisdiction in international waters and therefore, cannot exclude Palestinian fishermen from accessing these waters.

Israel telling the Pals where they can (and cannot) fish, is like you coming over to my house and telling me what's what under my own roof. Do you not see how wrong that is? You have no right telling people what to do on their own property. If you think you do, then come over to my house and try to pull that shit with me.

Until Gaza implements implements an Internationally APPROVED customs and border service --- they have no claim to an "open border" or unfettered smuggling. Essentially they are currently "lawless" in terms of International compliance. And their neighbors can certainly claim security concerns and take steps to PREVENT entrance of items that are forbidden by International agreements. Even if Gaza is not a party to those agreements.

All of this is pretty much off-topic and I can understand why you are BORED with the original flimsy lying ass OP.. Since THAT is such a minor dust-up (punny) compared with the Gaza Sanctions and trade restrictions. Maybe your couch warrior team should concentrate on picking more important topics and OPs..

Billo does not rule the world --- yet. And these security concerns are NOT JUST ISRAELI BS.. The rest of the world recognizes the need to have regular order on the borders of Gaza. Go blame the EU or NATO..

http://www.kyivpost.com/article/con...aza-arms-smuggling-aired-at-meeting-34997.htm

A senior Western diplomat said the countries, all NATO members, broadly agreed on a number of points and hoped to be able to produce a formal document or a programme of action at the next meeting in Britain in early March.

"We are not ready to adopt it yet, but we are going to meet in London in a few weeks' time and I hope that that will produce this agreed document over what it is we want to do," the diplomat said.

Civil servants from a majority of the countries agreed the use of naval force would be necessary to effectively halt the inflow of weapons to Gaza, although several countries opposed the use of military force, the senior diplomat said.

No political decisions were taken at the two-day meeting, which focused more on the routes weapons follow from their origin through the Red Sea towards the Gaza Strip than smuggling from tunnels between Egypt and the Palestinian enclave.

The senior diplomat said the conference had agreed on a number of points, including the need for cooperation in intelligence gathering and diplomatic actions to curb the flow of illicit arms into Gaza.


European Union Offers To Take Charge Of Gaza Borders (Did I miss the thread on THIS news item??? )

BRUSSELS (AP) — The European Union offered Friday to take charge of Gaza's border crossings and work to prevent illegal arms flows, insisting on a durable truce and saying a return to the status quo before the latest war "is not an option."

As EU foreign ministers held an urgent meeting in Brussels about global conflicts, Hamas negotiators met with the Islamic militant group's leadership in Qatar to discuss a proposal for a long-term truce with Israel. An official said the group was inclined to accept the Egyptian-mediated offer.

The Gaza blockade remains the main stumbling block. It has greatly limited the movement of Palestinians in and out of the territory of 1.8 million people, restricted the flow of goods into Gaza and blocked virtually all exports.

The EU is prepared "to play a strong role" in managing the crossings while assuring that Israel's security is guaranteed, said the 28-nation bloc's foreign policy chief, Catherine Ashton.

The EU foreign ministers said the bloc is also prepared to prevent arms smuggling and launch a training program for Palestinian Authority police and customs officers to be deployed in Gaza. (as bro FlaCalTenn just told you)

Stop insisting that this is just an UNJUSTIFIED CONCERN of Israel and start realizing that the Palis need to step up to accepting responsibilities that EVERY nation must live by..
The Israelis will prevent any sea or air access and you know it
Here is a challenge - name one step the Palestinians ever made for their sake.

Can't find any? I know, me neither.

Unfortunately as for now the WHOLE Palestinian and anti-Israeli campaign is established upon making as many holes in the boat while they can, what would be the only step Israel could take when abandoning the ship is not an option?
I have always said Danny the there should be an Israel,I am Pragmatic enough to know that.........Israel are going no where,I just want to see a 2 state solution where there is Peace for both peoples..........Lets hope it happens...despite all that is said,fundamentally the majority on both sides are good people indeed.steve
I'm fully aware of your position, that led me to my previous post of which we are not just focusing on Israel but on the Palestinians because it's always possible to expect Israel to compromise - therefore we face the a crucial issue in the conflict which is the Palestinians.
What did the Palestinians ever did for NOT escalating violence? What did the Palestinians ever did for the sake of peace? What did the Palestinians ever agrees on which can create even the weakest status quo? Have the answers and we found a solution to the conflict.
 
So any ALLEGATION is suddenly TRUTH?? Never been that way in the civilized world pal..

Let's see....

There can be NO allegation "suddenly" becoming the truth... That is given...

However, in real life, a case can be put forward that, upon investigation, can be debated, discussed and, if possible, proven wrong...

When there is NO physical evidence against TWO independent sources being produced one has to question whether the 'facts' presented are, actually a lie OR just something that opponents don't agree with...

In this case....

Two articles, from different sources have been presented, from two different occurrences of what, basically, is a repeat of the first...

Now, I'm not stating that they are 'factual'... I am simply presenting a case....

As it appears that there is ZERO 'evidence' being produced, other than, the typical zionut mantra "Don't speak bad of Israel or I will call you an islamonazi liar", then, in reality, you don't have a leg to stand on!

You never been in a court of law?

You never seen a felon get away scot free because he, not only lied, but also the prosecutor was unable to produce any evidence to the contrary...

THAT'S how it works in the real world...

So, let me start again...

I posted TWO links to TWO separate incidents of crop spraying...

Can you provide a single link to say this DIDN'T happen?

Yes? Great, let's see it....

No? Shut the **** up and, until you prove otherwise, they are 'factual' occurrences!

It's not difficult to understand! Really!

Prove the links wrong and I am happy to be proven wrong... What I am not happy to accept is that not ONE of you pro Israel supporters is able/capable to back up your
"Don't speak bad of Israel" mantra... Wind blowing in one direction or another is NOT evidence!
 
What I will acknowledged is that this buffer zone is not well defined. And has been enlarged and shrunk with every outbreak of violence. Stabilize the Gazan political situation, get some international support for a LEGIT government and NEGOTIATE for better definitions and border access..

Now, THIS comment makes a LOT of sense! Thank you!

The buffer zone is NOT well defined, this is true...

What is also true is that the buffer zone is in the WRONG country!

This is total proof of the CONTINUED occupation of Gaza by Israel... The buffer zone should be IN Israel NOT in Gaza!

Stabilize the political situation in Gaza, get rid of Hamas, get international support into Palestine AND Israel and negotiate for a sensible peace solution...

Off topic, yes, sorry, but just responding to your post!

Perhaps a NEW OP should be made on the issue of the buffer zone... Could be an interesting topic!
 
What I will acknowledged is that this buffer zone is not well defined. And has been enlarged and shrunk with every outbreak of violence. Stabilize the Gazan political situation, get some international support for a LEGIT government and NEGOTIATE for better definitions and border access..

Now, THIS comment makes a LOT of sense! Thank you!

The buffer zone is NOT well defined, this is true...

What is also true is that the buffer zone is in the WRONG country!

This is total proof of the CONTINUED occupation of Gaza by Israel... The buffer zone should be IN Israel NOT in Gaza!

Stabilize the political situation in Gaza, get rid of Hamas, get international support into Palestine AND Israel and negotiate for a sensible peace solution...

Off topic, yes, sorry, but just responding to your post!

Perhaps a NEW OP should be made on the issue of the buffer zone... Could be an interesting topic!
What is also true is that the buffer zone is in the WRONG country!

This is total proof of the CONTINUED occupation of Gaza by Israel... The buffer zone should be IN Israel NOT in Gaza!​

Indeed, if the freeloaders want a buffer zone they should put it on their own side of the fence.
 
That post had content -- I'm sure.. About 80 proof !!!! :poke:

So anytime you need to reminded that the deal for an Autonomous Gaza included a buffer zone -- or why Palestinians don't have rights of citizenship in any country -- you just ring me up... I'll also call you a cab if we have to.. :itsok:
I think you should produce evidence of this agreement.


Fisherman being shot at whilst they fish? Then how come so much of the evidence comes from well-camera'd journalists cluttering up the decks on their "fishing expeditions" into excluded zones?
How come there's so much evidence? Because Israel shoots at a lot of fishermen. And there's nothing wrong with journalists on a boat. Furthermore, Israel has no jurisdiction in international waters and therefore, cannot exclude Palestinian fishermen from accessing these waters.

Israel telling the Pals where they can (and cannot) fish, is like you coming over to my house and telling me what's what under my own roof. Do you not see how wrong that is? You have no right telling people what to do on their own property. If you think you do, then come over to my house and try to pull that shit with me.

Furthermore, Israel has no jurisdiction in international waters and therefore, cannot exclude Palestinian fishermen from accessing these waters.

It appears that they can.
 
Two articles, from different sources have been presented, from two different occurrences of what, basically, is a repeat of the first...

No, you didn't post two articles from two different sources. You posted two articles which both have the same original source (the 972 article). In fact, if you do some research, you will see that ALL of the articles about this topic are sourced in the exact same 972 article. An article, which quotes an anonymous source "in the IDF".

Not a single mainstream news source picks up this topic. Everything sources from 972. I smell bullshit.
 
So any ALLEGATION is suddenly TRUTH?? Never been that way in the civilized world pal..

Let's see....

There can be NO allegation "suddenly" becoming the truth... That is given...

However, in real life, a case can be put forward that, upon investigation, can be debated, discussed and, if possible, proven wrong...

When there is NO physical evidence against TWO independent sources being produced one has to question whether the 'facts' presented are, actually a lie OR just something that opponents don't agree with...

In this case....

Two articles, from different sources have been presented, from two different occurrences of what, basically, is a repeat of the first...

Now, I'm not stating that they are 'factual'... I am simply presenting a case....

As it appears that there is ZERO 'evidence' being produced, other than, the typical zionut mantra "Don't speak bad of Israel or I will call you an islamonazi liar", then, in reality, you don't have a leg to stand on!

You never been in a court of law?

You never seen a felon get away scot free because he, not only lied, but also the prosecutor was unable to produce any evidence to the contrary...

THAT'S how it works in the real world...

So, let me start again...

I posted TWO links to TWO separate incidents of crop spraying...

Can you provide a single link to say this DIDN'T happen?

Yes? Great, let's see it....

No? Shut the **** up and, until you prove otherwise, they are 'factual' occurrences!

It's not difficult to understand! Really!

Prove the links wrong and I am happy to be proven wrong... What I am not happy to accept is that not ONE of you pro Israel supporters is able/capable to back up your
"Don't speak bad of Israel" mantra... Wind blowing in one direction or another is NOT evidence!

I am not obliged to prove NEGATIVES.. Here lemme illustrate.

The postings by the Humanity are motivated by payments from Hamas for disseminating propaganda .
Now prove it never happened.

I told you -- the "legal case" here would be thrown out OF ANY COURT for lack of evidence. No pictures, no lab tests, no exact locations, no identification of WHAT was sprayed or the quantities involved.. Not even a thorough list of plaintiffs and THEIR testimonies.. You got next to nothing here..

You got any links that answer those questions? The most specific FACT I got from this is the total area involved is 3000 sq meters. That's only 30 by 100 meters. And it did not say whether that was CUMULATIVE over multiple incidents or whether that was one incident.
 
Last edited:

Just noticed another thing about this picture of the problem. Just beyond the IDF outpost and the barren border -- you can see what appears to be ISRAELI farms cultivated right down to the border. The fields there are prepared for seed.. So that would be the time that the Israeli farmer might call in a crop duster to dose it with insecticide and maybe even a selective herbicide.

OR perhaps the IDF just tends to allow the herbicide to drift farther towards the Pali side in order not to anger the Israeli farmers right on the other side..
 
That post had content -- I'm sure.. About 80 proof !!!! :poke:

So anytime you need to reminded that the deal for an Autonomous Gaza included a buffer zone -- or why Palestinians don't have rights of citizenship in any country -- you just ring me up... I'll also call you a cab if we have to.. :itsok:
I think you should produce evidence of this agreement.


Fisherman being shot at whilst they fish? Then how come so much of the evidence comes from well-camera'd journalists cluttering up the decks on their "fishing expeditions" into excluded zones?
How come there's so much evidence? Because Israel shoots at a lot of fishermen. And there's nothing wrong with journalists on a boat. Furthermore, Israel has no jurisdiction in international waters and therefore, cannot exclude Palestinian fishermen from accessing these waters.

Israel telling the Pals where they can (and cannot) fish, is like you coming over to my house and telling me what's what under my own roof. Do you not see how wrong that is? You have no right telling people what to do on their own property. If you think you do, then come over to my house and try to pull that shit with me.

Furthermore, Israel has no jurisdiction in international waters and therefore, cannot exclude Palestinian fishermen from accessing these waters.

It appears that they can.

Evidently --- from the articles I posted --- both the EU and NATO agree that policing for smuggling in Gaza is not only LEGAL --- but necessary..
 
15th post
Stabilize the Gazan political situation, .
You keep saying that, but every time they try, Israel attacks.

get some international support for a LEGIT government and NEGOTIATE for better definitions and border access. .
WTF you talking about "LEGIT" government?

Hamas won a fair and democratic election according to international standards.

Spray that in your crop circles.
 
Evidently --- from the articles I posted --- both the EU and NATO agree that policing for smuggling in Gaza is not only LEGAL --- but necessary..
Answer my god-damn question!

"Do Gazan's have a right to defend themselves?"

****!


IF Gaza was being attacked they would have the right to defend themselves. But they are not being attacked.

They are being blockaded in order to prevent them from making indiscriminate, illegal, belligerent attacks on innocent Israeli citizens. The way to end the blockade is to end the attacks. Easy peasy.

Are you really asking if Gaza has the right to try to win land by force? You might even want to phrase it as "win land back by force" but that is an entirely different question than whether or not they have a right to defend themselves. There is nothing to defend themselves FROM as they are not being attacked.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom