Illegal to blame Jews for what Jews do if bill passes

[ESay]

I assume your native tongue isn’t English.

Of course not. I think it is obvious.

 

[BackAgain]

Of course not. I think it is obvious.

Your lack of comprehensible grammar was a clue.

 

[ESay]

Your lack of comprehensible grammar was a clue.

Without a doubt. But I am okay with that. I am not going to be proficient in English.

 

[AHZ]

Jews have done nothing as a group for which they deserve to be criticized. Sure, there have been a few Jewish criminals over the years. Nevertheless, as a group Jews behave and perform well.

which individual has done anything as a group?

 

[rosends]

FROM the IHRA, which the bill explicitly incorporates:

"Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews."

In other words, blaming Jews for what Jews do.

What is antisemitism?

With the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, the IHRA built international consensus around an answer to the question, what does antisemitism mean?

holocaustremembrance.com

No, blaming an entire group based on the incidental identity of a single person. Or do you think that one should accuse all Christians and hold Christianity responsible because one serial killer happened to be Christian?

 

[rosends]

There are already plenty of laws on the books which compromise the notion of an absolute freedom of speech. There are hate-crime statutes on the books and we have codified speech which is subject to prior restraint. But if we make sure that the existing laws apply to Jews, that becomes a problem for people. One wonders why.

 

[BackAgain]

Without a doubt. But I am okay with that. I am not going to be proficient in English.

It’s my native tongue and I am barely fluent.

I don’t judge you for it. In fact, I wish I had an ability to speak as well as you do in a foreign language.

Substantively, I don’t always get what you’re trying to say. Or I just disagree with it a lot.

 

[ESay]

It’s my native tongue and I am barely fluent.

I don’t judge you for it. In fact, I wish I had an ability to speak as well as you do in a foreign language.

Substantively, I don’t always get what you’re trying to say. Or I just disagree with it a lot.

Well, feel free to ask for clarification from me, if you happen to be interested in my point here or there.

 

[BackAgain]

Well, feel free to ask for clarification from me, if you happen to be interested in my point here or there.

Will do.

 

[San Souci]

In about 27 states such laws are already in force, right here in the Land Of The Brave and Home Of The Free. Israel owns the US.

You tell 'em' ,Adolf.

 

[EMH]

Glenn Greenwald and Jill Stein and quite a few others do exactly that.

and Paul Craig Roberts

 

[Street Juice]

No, blaming an entire group based on the incidental identity of a single person. Or do you think that one should accuse all Christians and hold Christianity responsible because one serial killer happened to be Christian?

Oops, you didn't restate the argument honestly. I know that was unintentional. The bill says blaming for the actions of a group"

Do we say the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor in 1941?

Should we be charged with anti-Japanese discrimination if we do?

 

[Street Juice]

Wrong.

Let’s say you’re a retard. And you accuse all Jewish people for something done by just one Jewish person. That’s accusing Jews in general for one Jew’s actions. That is such a gross over-generalization that it is clear to all thinking people that you’re true intentions to simply smear Jewish people.

There’s a word for that. And that’s all the law says.

Hey truth-speaker, lol, the example includes a "grouP of Jews."

 

[Street Juice]

and Paul Craig Roberts

Ron Unz

 

[Street Juice]

Jews have done nothing as a group for which they deserve to be criticized. Sure, there have been a few Jewish criminals over the years. Nevertheless, as a group Jews behave and perform well.

Oh, my God. Ever heard of the Bolsheviks? Jews were the greatest mass murderers of the 20th century. Per capita, no one evn comes close.

Nazis Were Better Humans Than the Bolsheviks. Not. Even. Close.

The Nazis encouraged smart people to have more children. The Bolsheviks murdered the children of smart people.

craignelsen.substack.com

 

[Street Juice]

There are already plenty of laws on the books which compromise the notion of an absolute freedom of speech. There are hate-crime statutes on the books and we have codified speech which is subject to prior restraint. But if we make sure that the existing laws apply to Jews, that becomes a problem for people. One wonders why.

I'm against all "hate" speech laws. And why do Jews ger a special law just forthemselves? No one else is "protected" from being blamed for what they do. No one else insists everybody buy their stupid Jewskin lampshades and poisonous shower heads nonsense or go to jail. Jews are a scourge with this shit.

 

[Street Juice]

You tell 'em' ,Adolf.

OK Bibi.

By the way, curious, does BiBi stand for "baby butcher" or "blood and bombs"

 

[rosends]

Oops, you didn't restate the argument honestly. I know that was unintentional. The bill says blaming for the actions of a group"

Do we say the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor in 1941?

Should we be charged with anti-Japanese discrimination if we do?

And if you then attack a random Japanese person because of association with that group? It is exactly that thinking that led to internment camps. The Japanese imperial navy, under orders from the Japanese government attacked Pearl Harbor. That guy who lives down the street and works at the Japanese restaurant didn't bomb pearl harbor.

I'm not sure what you think I misquoted based on this pull quote

"Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews."

 

[rosends]

I'm against all "hate" speech laws. And why do Jews ger a special law just forthemselves? No one else is "protected" from being blamed for what they do. No one else insists everybody buy their stupid Jewskin lampshades and poisonous shower heads nonsense or go to jail. Jews are a scourge with this shit.

If you are against hatred speech laws then that's great if you are consistent. The thing is, you seem, seperatly to have a problem with Judaism. Your trying to rail against a wording of a bill is undermined by the obvious fact that it would affect you personally.

 

[Hector12]

Oh, my God. Ever heard of the Bolsheviks? Jews were the greatest mass murderers of the 20th century. Per capita, no one evn comes close.

Nazis Were Better Humans Than the Bolsheviks. Not. Even. Close.

The Nazis encouraged smart people to have more children. The Bolsheviks murdered the children of smart people.

craignelsen.substack.com

The vast majority of the Bolsheviks were not Jewish. Virtually none of them were observant Jews.

-----------

According to the 1922 Bolshevik party census, there were 19,564 Jewish Bolsheviks, comprising 5.21% of the total, and in the 1920s of the 417 members of the Central Executive Committee, the party Central Committee, the Presidium of the Executive of the Soviets of the USSR and the Russian Republic, the People's Commissars, 6% were ethnic Jews.[17] Between 1936 and 1940, during the Great Purge, Yezhovshchina and after the rapprochement with Nazi Germany, Stalin had largely eliminated Jews from senior party, government, diplomatic, security and military positions.[18]

Jewish Bolshevism - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org