Formula shortage reveals GOP’s compassion for American babies, anger over nourished immigrant ones

We can’t avoid consequences for everyone
The federal gov't is to blame for all of this. Two massive forced recalls on Abbott formulas and the FDA never did actually prove any linkage between the formulas and sick babies.

You can't intentionally short the supply of anything while increasing demand without creating shortages.
 
Duhhh, the shortage of formula is under the Dem administration.

Wonder who provided formula to the migrant babies, before they illegally crossed our borders????

When Trump was President they didn't cross our borders thanks to his Stay in Mexico policy. But even for the ones that did, we didn't take the formula from the mouths of American babies to give to them.
 
Duhhh, the shortage of formula is under the Dem administration.

Wonder who provided formula to the migrant babies, before they illegally crossed our borders????
We have some idiot leftists locally trying to blame it on Governor Abbott on the basis they believe he somehow controls Abbott Laboratories and engineered this shortage for his own political purposes.

Election year insanity at it's finest.
smiley_ROFLMAO.gif
 
When Trump was President they didn't cross our borders thanks to his Stay in Mexico policy. But even for the ones that did, we didn't take the formula from the mouths of American babies to give to them.
Our treaty says that they are supposed to stay in the first "Safe country" they enter which would be Mexico and there's no evidence to suggest that they are not safe there.

You are supposed to apply for asylum in the US from your home country or the first "safe country" you enter, not by illegally entering the US.

Trump was absolutely right and it forced Mexico to start enforcing it's own southern border because they could not deal with the humanitarian problems the surge was creating in their own country.
 
Our treaty says that they are supposed to stay in the first "Safe country" they enter which would be Mexico and there's no evidence to suggest that they are not safe there.

You are supposed to apply for asylum in the US from your home country or the first "safe country" you enter, not by illegally entering the US.

Trump was absolutely right and it forced Mexico to start enforcing it's own southern border because they could not deal with the humanitarian problems the surge was creating in their own country.

The problem is (to my knowledge) that Dementia removed the stay in Mexico policy and went back to catch and release, or as they call it now, catch and process. It was also a Trump policy that asylum claims be made at their US embassy which Dementia also removed. If you could not apply at a US embassy in your country and had to flee in emergency, you were automatically disqualified from asylum if you were offered it by any other country along the way.

These great policies kept people from making the trip to the US, and of course, bringing their babies with them thus making them our responsibility. If people were smart enough to vote for Trump over Dementia, our mothers would have more supply in which to feed their babies than today.

The left feels that since they created this problem, we the taxpayers should bring a solution to it. I agree The solution is to keep Democrats out of power for eternity.
 
The problem is (to my knowledge) that Dementia removed the stay in Mexico policy and went back to catch and release, or as they call it now, catch and process. It was also a Trump policy that asylum claims be made at their US embassy which Dementia also removed. If you could not apply at a US embassy in your country and had to flee in emergency, you were automatically disqualified from asylum if you were offered it by any other country along the way.

These great policies kept people from making the trip to the US, and of course, bringing their babies with them thus making them our responsibility. If people were smart enough to vote for Trump over Dementia, our mothers would have more supply in which to feed their babies than today.

The left feels that since they created this problem, we the taxpayers should bring a solution to it. I agree The solution is to keep Democrats out of power for eternity.
Sadly, we even have leftists NGO/NPO's based in the US sending millions of dollars down to Mexico to provide for them on their journeys across MX to the US border.

They should be prosecuted under RICO for abetting criminal enterprises and conspiring to aid illegals to enter the US but they never will be.
 
Starving babies is a logical progression for GOP policy making.
Tommy socialism always leads to starving babies, pets, children, and adults. ALWAYS.

it is not americas responsibility to feed the welfare hos overbreeding from around the world. They should stay in their own nations, fix their own nations and their own lives, before having kids and demanding others take care of them.
 
Starving babies is a logical progression for GOP policy making.
You are insane, this shortage was created by the Biden Administration, not anything the GOP has done.

There was no shortage of formula during either of the last two GOP administrations and under the most recent, Real Median Income was positive for the first time in three decades while welfare rolls were dropping precipitously.

You are out of you mind, completely.
 
Come on Westwall - what choice do those children have? Why punish them?
Why punish American kids?

Their kids made it 1,300 miles or more without formula and arrived in the US just fine so what is the logic in giving them formula that is in extremely short supply?

Send them home with their parents and let their home nations deal with it if there's a problem with a lack of formula.
 
:dunno:

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

That is the only place where birth is mentioned. Nowhere does the Constitution mention rights given prior to birth or whether one is considered a person for Constitutional reasons prior to birth.

What I deny is that a fetus has a right to another person's body against that person's will.
That conferred citizenship for the freed slaves, try again.

American Indians weren't even granted citizenship until 1924.

 
Illegal babies grow up to be Democrat voters.

American babies may or may not.

There's all the explanation anyone needs.
At least that is what they are counting on.

Legal Hispanics are moving more and more towards the Republican party.

That's why democrats are going to take such a beating in Texas this year, particularly in the previously almost solid Blue S. Texas.
 
Well...this hits the nail on the head, as indeed, for some, compassion is totally partisan and quite negotiable.


The baby formula shortage has led a number of Republicans to demonstrate their deep and abiding concern for the smallest among us, unless the "smallest" in question are ones Republicans don't want among us.
Texas Rep. Troy Nehls, for example, tenderly tweeted Thursday: "Baby formula should go to Americans before illegals. This should not have to be said."
Also not having to be said, apparently, is that undocumented children in U.S. care, by law, have to be fed. That and the whole "not feeding a baby is kind of wrong" thing, which in Nehls' mind must be morally negotiable.
Florida Rep. Kat Cammack, in a video posted on Facebook, said she is “so angry about this” fact that the government is giving food to infants in its care along the border. (I assume her anger is a form of love for all God’s children.)
“These are your tax dollars going to buy formula” for the immigrant babies, she said, before claiming without evidence that the babies she would like to see starve are also tragic victims of “violence and trafficking,” and calling President Joe Biden the “trafficker in chief.”
I mean, clearly it breaks Cammack’s heart to see these innocent infants harmed in any way, shape or form, and all she wants is for the government to immediately take away their food so they go hungry.
So clearly these Republicans are addressing the baby-formula shortage through the scriptural philosophy of: “All lives are precious, except these little immigrant whiners over here. They can pound sand.”

On Thursday, Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, the patron saint of logical consistency, said: “Food security is national security, and right now we have a food security crisis for the most vulnerable of Americans, the ones that we cherish the most, and that’s our babies.”
Yes. Our babies. But not other people’s babies, I guess.
I know some are going to see Greene’s concern about food insecurity as strange given that she and her Republican colleagues helped bring an end to the extended child-tax credit, which had lifted 3.7 million U.S. children out of poverty.

But were those really our children? Who's to say. Let’s assume they weren’t.
The current law says most of the aliens arriving in our nation by crossing the Mexican border are illegal. Illegal means they should not be here.

If they were not here theere would be more baby formula available for the babies of people who are legally in our nation. There most likely would still be a shortage.

If I was a mother desperate for baby formula I might consider going into Mexico and acting like an illegal alien on the way back. That way my baby would get formula.

It does seem that often illegal aliens get better treatment that citizens in our nation.


Conclusion
Using the term “alien” is not sinister or xenophobic. It is the correct legal term to describe a foreigner in the United States. Therefore, an “illegal alien” is simply a foreigner who is in the country illegally. Both of these terms have an established history in Anglo-American legal parlance and were never intended to be derogatory terms. Open-borders proponents are attempting to manufacture outrage over what we call illegal aliens so they can push a false narrative that minimizes the threats to national security and public safety that accompany massive illegal migration.
 
If an infant is going to be punished one way or another, it should be an infant that shouldn't be here in the first place--not one of our own infants.
That’s the fallacy, it isn’t zero sum. Deciding that an infant within our country is worth less solely on the basis of nationality is abhorrent. Instead, if the situation was truly so bad that some infants had to be denied due it based on other criteria in consultation with pediatricians. For example those 12 mos and older can be safely transitioned to solid foods.
 
Top baby formula makers Reckitt Benckiser and Nestle have ramped up supplies to the United States to resolve a shortage that has emptied shelves and caused panic among parents.

Baby formula aisles at U.S. supermarkets have been decimated since top U.S. manufacturer Abbott Laboratories in February recalled formulas after complaints of bacterial infections.

Abbott said on Monday it had reached an agreement with the U.S. health regulator to resume production of baby formula at its Michigan plant, marking a major step towards resolving the nationwide shortage.

Nestle is flying baby formula supplies to the United States from the Netherlands and Switzerland, the company said in an emailed statement to Reuters on Tuesday.

Prior to the Abbott recall, Reckitt supplied just over a third of the U.S. infant formula market compared with Abbott's roughly 44%. Britain-based Reckitt told Reuters it now accounts for more than 50% of total baby formula supply in the country.

So, this is what happens when people rely on one US manufacturer.
 
The current law says most of the aliens arriving in our nation by crossing the Mexican border are illegal. Illegal means they should not be here.
The current law doesn’t say that. The current law says people have a legal right to seek asylum. If they are asylum seekers, they are legal until they have their status determined by a hearing. At that point other laws determine what is done.

If they were not here theere would be more baby formula available for the babies of people who are legally in our nation. There most likely would still be a shortage.

If I was a mother desperate for baby formula I might consider going into Mexico and acting like an illegal alien on the way back. That way my baby would get formula.

If you were a mother, free to make choices, in this country, you would consult with your pediatrician, look for alternatives such as different brands etc. Those in detention are not free to do so but but entirely dependent on those who detained them.


It does seem that often illegal aliens get better treatment that citizens in our nation.
That’s silly.



Conclusion
Using the term “alien” is not sinister or xenophobic. It is the correct legal term to describe a foreigner in the United States. Therefore, an “illegal alien” is simply a foreigner who is in the country illegally. Both of these terms have an established history in Anglo-American legal parlance and were never intended to be derogatory terms. Open-borders proponents are attempting to manufacture outrage over what we call illegal aliens so they can push a false narrative that minimizes the threats to national security and public safety that accompany massive illegal migration.

No argument there.
 

Forum List

Back
Top