Zone1 Does Egypt Owe Israel Clear Title to Gaza?

[Votto]

Israel doesn't welcome Muslims? Then you know nothing about Israel.

I would say a great many people don't know anything about Israel, other than what the media tells them, which is that they are all Nazis conducting an open air apartheid mass genocide.

Sad.

 

[ozro]

Yes, get them out of NYC!

If the UN has to provide security for themselves in Gaza.......

 

[Lisa558]

Keep your friends close, and enemies closer.

Israel would not agree with that. The U.N. has been infiltrated by Islamic terrorists, and we’d be back to the same problem.

 

[ozro]

Israel would not agree with that. The U.N. has been infiltrated by Islamic terrorists, and we’d be back to the same problem.

I think the government of Israel would consider it.

 

[Lisa558]

I think the government of Israel would consider it.

No way. They know the U.N. Is anti-Israel.

 

[ozro]

No way. They know the U.N. Is anti-Israel.

We can disagree, and we are two Jews.
Put it to 120 jews in knesset.

 

[rosends]

I would say a great many people don't know anything about Israel, other than what the media tells them, which is that they are all Nazis conducting an open air apartheid mass genocide.

Sad.

yup

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.

Jews of Egypt

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org

What a load of Zionist propaganda. Just despicable. You’re making Jews look bad. You’re making Israel look bad. You would think that you’re like a Hamas operative.

“The Jews”

Kind of an odd thing to say. Egypt’s treatment of the Jews. It reminds me of the Jewish racists who go around complaining constantly about how Jews were treated in the Christian middle ages or something like that. Just stop. What you people are doing is extremely offensive and it must not be normalized. Well, the fact is, it’s not normalized. It’s not normal to talk like that. Because the idea that any group of people were treated horribly for thousands of years is an insult to entire groups of people. It just doesn’t hold up ….. you know we’re all human beings in the first place. And every group of people has experienced bigotry at one point, not just Jews……white people, Black people other groups have experience discrimination.

I think you’re like the 10% of Jews, who think that Jews have been mistreated by everybody.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

I’m a proud Catholic so proud of the love that Catholics have shown to Jews over history. Yeah that’s right.

I ain’t some weak self hating white man. Not a weak self heating Christian. Proud Christian. Proud American with Irish and Italian ancestry. I Reject the victim mentality. I Reject the BLM stupid attitude.

The original poster does not represent the Goodwill of the Jewish people. She represents herself And yeah, maybe like 10% of all of the Israeli people. Probably less actually.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.

Jews of Egypt

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org

Oh 2500 years ago people who you have basically no connection to whatsoever controlled Israel. Your argument is the same thing as saying that Spain belongs to Muslims because 700 years ago it was a Muslim country ….heck Actually that would be a much more stronger argument to say that southern Spain should be a Muslim country today because it was 700 years ago as opposed to 2500 years ago, which is what you’re trying to do you’re trying to connect European Jews to Israel. What in God’s name?


Wow

 

[Lisa558]

We can disagree, and we are two Jews.
Put it to 120 jews in knesset.

Yes, the Knesset could vote. No way would they yield control to an anti-Israel body.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

“ Egyptians are now called Gazans”

Well I be darned…. So somebody who comes from Germany from Poland from Spain, who is Jewish all of a sudden calls himself an Israeli. Yes they are Jewish but they are European. The name Israel when it is used this way is a total invention. It’s like basically calling somebody an American.

Arab Jews have been indigenous to what is called Israel or Palestine today for hundreds of years. This is true. And yes, they’re languages Arabic. Their culture is Arabic. All through the centuries there love their brothers their culture. Their sisters were Arabs. This was really an incredible thing. It was the Arab spirit.



Isn’t that incredible you know. So what about the fact that Palestine has been used for 2000 years as an identifier of a country. It goes back to the Roman times the great and glorious Roman Empire. That’s something to be proud of by the way the Roman Empire, which built the civilized world.

Well Isreal did ethic cleanse 750,000 them out Isreal(with the support of the Allies)... Would you want to be talking with them either...
Would be very awkward...

View attachment 1078541
They area wasn't majority Jewish until the 5th century... That is 900 years before Columbus landed in America...

The Area has not been a Jewish homeland but a place shared by multiple cultures and religions...

Don’t forget, forget about Christian rule of the holy land. A time of honor, love and peace and that’s according to the historians. Rene Grousett and other historians have written about how under crusader rule the Muslims, Jews and Christians got along fine. And so that was a Christian entity. That is the Christian belief that it should be like that by the way. Not this fake evangelical nonsense, which probably by the way only 20% of all protestants or evangelicals are extreme Zionists.

 

[Lisa558]

What a load of Zionist propaganda. Just despicable. You’re making Jews look bad. You’re making Israel look bad. You would think that you’re like a Hamas operative.

“The Jews”

Kind of an odd thing to say. Egypt’s treatment of the Jews. It reminds me of the Jewish racists who go around complaining constantly about how Jews were treated in the Christian middle ages or something like that. Just stop. What you people are doing is extremely offensive and it must not be normalized. Well, the fact is, it’s not normalized. It’s not normal to talk like that. Because the idea that any group of people were treated horribly for thousands of years is an insult to entire groups of people. It just doesn’t hold up ….. you know we’re all human beings in the first place. And every group of people has experienced bigotry at one point, not just Jews……white people, Black people other groups have experience discrimination.

I think you’re like the 10% of Jews, who think that Jews have been mistreated by everybody.

You brought in all sorts of past stuff from thousands of years ago.

I said that Egypt confiscated the land and property of Jews, and expelled them, just 60 years ago. Seems like they owe Israel something in the current conflict since a) Egypt started the war in ‘67, and b) the grandchildren of of the people who unfairly stole the assets of 75,000 Jews owe them something.

The problem of course is that the Gazans are such hateful Muslims that even other Arab countries don’t want them.

Save your rage against Jews, and your irrelevant comments about BLM and whatever, for another forum. This is in Clean Debates. One more off-topic, antagonistic post and I’ll report.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

yup

Call out racist Jews like the original poster and other racist Jews, who believe every Palestinian Christian and Muslim should be removed from Gaza. So it’s incumbent upon you to call these people out.

That’s an ideology that permeates among a section of Jewish people you know it I know what we all know it, ….if You claim to stand for equal rights call it out. Just as I will call out any White Christian who believes that the kkk is right and all blacks and Jews should be removed from America.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

You brought in all sorts of past stuff from thousands of years ago.

I said that Egypt confiscated the land and property of Jews, and expelled them, just 60 years ago. Seems like they owe Israel something in the current conflict since a) Egypt started the war in ‘67, and b) the grandchildren of of the people who unfairly stole the assets of 75,000 Jews owe them something.

The problem of course is that the Gazans are such hateful Muslims that even other Arab countries don’t want them.

Save your rage against Jews, and your irrelevant comments about BLM and whatever, for another forum. This is in Clean Debates. One more off-topic, antagonistic post and I’ll report.

You are providing historical nonsense. There are 20,000 Jews living in Turkey, perhaps 20,000 Jews living in Iran. And there has been a thriving history of Jews in Muslim countries throughout the ages. Throughout history in the recent times there have been plenty of Israeli politicians and political movements who openly hate Muslims and Christians. So your little point about Egypt in the grand scheme of things doesn’t amount too much. You need to look at the whole picture

As always, tell us all what you think about Muslims in general. You are out of your mind totally diluted. Selfish self-centered. And you just lie about people all the time telling them that they’re anti-Semitic.

This is a pure act of evil to continue to call people anti-Jewish even after they say they respect Jews. As you think I am anti-Semitic you are breaking the clean forum rules. For you to say I’m raging against Jews is breaking this form policy. Unbelievable just totally unbelievable.

Have you ever said you respect Muslims? Just total insanity from you on this topic.

 

[Lisa558]

You are providing historical nonsense. There are 20,000 Jews living in Turkey, perhaps 20,000 Jews living in Iran. And there has been a thriving history of Jews in Muslim countries throughout the ages. Throughout history in the recent times there have been plenty of Israeli politicians and political movements who openly hate Muslims and Christians. So your little point about Egypt in the grand scheme of things doesn’t amount too much. You need to look at the whole picture

As always, tell us all what you think about Muslims in general. You are out of your mind totally diluted. Selfish self-centered. And you just lie about people all the time telling them that they’re anti-Semitic.

This is a pure act of evil to continue to call people anti-Jewish even after they say they respect Jews. As you think I am anti-Semitic you are breaking the clean forum rules. For you to say I’m raging against Jews is breaking this form policy. Unbelievable just totally unbelievable.

Have you ever said you respect Muslims? Just total insanity from you on this topic.

I told you that your hostile lies, talk about “racist Jews,” name-calling me “evil,” and your other smears are inappropriate in a Clean Debate, Zone 1 thread.

Once a mod comes online, you will be reported. There is plenty of space in the I/P thread to vent your venom against Jews and Israel. THIE thread is not the place for it.

I know you can’t control your venom, but I will not be responding to any more of your hateful posts.

 

[Andrew_Jackson_FTW]

I told you that your hostile lies, talk about “racist Jews,” name-calling me “evil,” and your other smears are inappropriate in a Clean Debate, Zone 1 thread.

Once a mod comes online, you will be reported. There is plenty of space in the I/P thread to vent your venom against Jews and Israel. THIE thread is not the place for it.

I know you can’t control your venom, but I will not be responding to any more of your hateful posts.

You broke your thread rules. Calling people anti-Semitic claiming that I am anti-Jewish. You lie constantly about posters, including in this thread.

Also the logic of your original post makes no sense at all. Is it a distraction from the 50,000 dead Palestinians mostly women and children. You’re talking about what Egypt did 60 years ago. How about what Nazi Germany did 75 years ago. Huh that wasn’t committed by Muslims or Arabs.

Or what some other country did 500 years ago. Every country every ethnicity has people who committed controversial or bad acts throughout history. Including Israel and Jews. What in the world are you trying to do here connecting that to modern Israel?. Who are you trying to convince. Your argument just doesn’t make any sense.

so by your logic should Germany be ceded to Jews because what Nazis did to Jews was 1000 times worse than whatever kind of point you’re attempting to make about a government in Egypt….Because of course you cannot claim all Egyptians are against Jews as there are millions of Arab Jews.

BTW when it comes to this point about Egypt and Israel, you are presenting a vehemently extremist Zionist narrative. And obviously there’s another side to that story.

BTW What are you doing…Remember Anwar Sadat? All that good will between Egyptians and Israelis and you’re just doing whatever you’re doing.

 

[MarcATL]

Biden first cued it up w/allowing the genocide to almost full completion, then Trump sweeps in w/the ethnic cleansing to get the "savages" out of there.

The classic one/two punch by the American UniParty.

Well done!

 

[PeterPilot]

Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.

Jews of Egypt

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org

With the foundational myth of the Torah/Old Testament, as demonstrated by Deuteronomy 7, the Jews have advanced the specious notion of "Greater Israel" for decades if not centuries. Pure sophistry that the Jews are "God's Chosen People". Operating under that sophistry they have killed all manner of other races (inferior races they say) for centuries. They do the work of Satan or Moloch, but they are not doing the work of God.

 

[Lisa558]

With the foundational myth of the Torah/Old Testament, as demonstrated by Deuteronomy 7, the Jews have advanced the specious notion of "Greater Israel" for decades if not centuries. Pure sophistry that the Jews are "God's Chosen People". Operating under that sophistry they have killed all manner of other races (inferior races they say) for centuries. They do the work of Satan or Moloch, but they are not doing the work of God.

^^^ I stopped reading when this antisemite mocked the Torah, but I bet he went on to diss the Jews.

Must be another Brit.