Zone1 Does Egypt Owe Israel Clear Title to Gaza?

[Lisa558]

Interesting theory. For sure relocating the so-called 'Palestinians' elsewhere and not having that threat on their southern border would make life much more pleasant and secure for the Israelis. If we had a competent and ethical U.N. that would already have been done.

The U.N. did the right thing years ago and allowed Israel to keep the Golan Heights. But now we have a U.N. so corrupt that it made Iran chair of the special Human Rights Council in 2023.

And now with Hezbollah also making war on Israel, the U.N. should move the 'Palestinians' out of the West Bank and relocate them so Israel can deal appropriately with that vicious enemy.

Agree with you on all counts. Thx.

 

[rosends]

Facts that threaten your worldview your mind sees as wrong.

since you have yet to present facts, there is no way you can come to this conclusion. Well, except for the fact that you enjoy ignorance and being wrong.

 

[PeterPilot]

since you have yet to present facts, there is no way you can come to this conclusion. Well, except for the fact that you enjoy ignorance and being wrong.

The facts I have presented here are rejected by you. You deny the existence of unpleasant facts. People like you, dishonest posters, cannot carry on an adult conversation. You're great at pushing religious dogma, but poor at rational public dialogue.

 

[Blaster]

Israel should obliterate Hamas and take control of Gaza.

 

[rosends]

The facts I have presented here are rejected by you. You deny the existence of unpleasant facts. People like you, dishonest posters, cannot carry on an adult conversation. You're great at pushing religious dogma, but poor at rational public dialogue.

claiming to have presented facts doesn't change the reality that you simply haven't presented any. People like you who try to gaslight the masses instead of engaging in a mature way are an embarrassment to sites like this. You are fine at making silly statements, but fail when it comes to engaging in meaningful discourse.

 

[jwoodie]

Given Egypt’s history of treatment of the Jews, I’d say Egypt should take back the Egyptians (now called Gazans) into the country, and acknowledge the region belongs to the Land of Isrsel.

1) Egypt’s aggression in the six-day war, in which it attempted to wipe Israel off the map, was a humiliating loss, and Israel won that land. (Some would say won the land back.)

2) Egypt expelled all its Jews about 60 years ago, upon 24 hours notice, and forced the Jews to deed over all their land, houses, and other assets. This land now belongs to the descendants of those who stole it, and Jews were driven to Israel penniless. To be fair, Gaza should be deeded over to a) the descendants of those who had their land stolen, which would be their grandparents, and 2) Israel in general upon which to build a thriving Jewish community.

Jews of Egypt

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org

nee

Does Egypt lay claim to Gaza right now? If so, it should be held responsible for Hamas. If not, is it part of "Palestine?"
If so, Palestine should be held responsible. Otherwise, Israel does not need "clear title" to do what it must in Gaza.

 

[CowboyTed]

So you started with two mistakes. Now, you can also consider this

Myths & Facts Refugees

Encyclopedia of Jewish and Israeli history, politics and culture, with biographies, statistics, articles and documents on topics from anti-Semitism to Zionism.

www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org

All I read from that...

Israel ethnic cleanse 750,000 Palestinians from Israel...

Other unrelated Muslim countries, after that Jews living there decided it was best to move to Israel...

 

[rosends]

All I read from that...

Israel ethnic cleanse 750,000 Palestinians from Israel...

Other unrelated Muslim countries, after that Jews living there decided it was best to move to Israel...

then your reading skills are deficient.

 

[CowboyTed]

then your reading skills are deficient.

Look at the timeline....

Jews weren't expelled but they didn't feel wanted...

And hey Israel has just got all this land from somewhere and they can move there..

 

[rosends]

Look at the timeline....

Jews weren't expelled but they didn't feel wanted...

And hey Israel has just got all this land from somewhere and they can move there..

so you don't study history either. OK.

 

[jwoodie]

Historical analysis is relevant only if it provides guidance for future actions.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

Call out racist Jews like the original poster and other racist Jews, who believe every Palestinian Christian and Muslim should be removed from Gaza. So it’s incumbent upon you to call these people out.

That’s an ideology that permeates among a section of Jewish people you know it I know what we all know it, ….if You claim to stand for equal rights call it out. Just as I will call out any White Christian who believes that the kkk is right and all blacks and Jews should be removed from America.

And what about you inbred Muslims who follow and evil doctrine that calls for you to wage war upon the world until only your cult remains?

 

[PeterPilot]

Historical analysis is relevant only if it provides guidance for future actions.

Those who ignore history and the lessons learned are doomed to repeat them.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

Those who ignore history and the lessons learned are doomed to repeat them.

The history that places Jewish settlements in Gaza a couple thousand years before the phony group "Palestinian" was invented as a propaganda device, that sort of history?

 

[PeterPilot]

The history that places Jewish settlements in Gaza a couple thousand years before the phony group "Palestinian" was invented as a propaganda device, that sort of history?

No, the sort of history showing the Jews to be horrible neighbors, always coveting their neighbors' lands, taking the Sinai and then having to leave back when Ike was in office. History shows the Zionists to be murderous and deceptive people. Einstein was right when he said the Jews absolutely need a homeland, but they cannot be given statehood because they act just as the Nazis act.

 

[Concerned American]

Well, naturally. The point is: since Egypt stole all the Jews’ land and assets, shouldn’t they be held responsible for a solution? As it stands, the anti-Israel contingent puts the onus on the Jews.

Can you blame them?

Sounds like it is ready to become the world's newest beach side resort.

 

[Lisa558]

Sounds like it is ready to become the world's newest beach side resort.

It does indeed! And I will be among the guests one day, Gd-willing.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

No, the sort of history showing the Jews to be horrible neighbors, always coveting their neighbors' lands, taking the Sinai and then having to leave back when Ike was in office. History shows the Zionists to be murderous and deceptive people. Einstein was right when he said the Jews absolutely need a homeland, but they cannot be given statehood because they act just as the Nazis act.

My goodness, such antisemitic nonsense.


Did your parents teach you that, child?

 

[PeterPilot]

My goodness, such antisemitic nonsense.


Did your parents teach you that, child?

It's not antisemitism you poor man, it is simply a brief statement regarding historical facts. I have always had good Jewish friends. Jewish lawyers have saved my bacon a few times. Jewish men and women like Greenwald, Sachs, Wolf are modern day heroes who speak the truth about the criminality of the Zionist state.

When you invoke the term "antisemitism" you reveal all you have is a cry-baby appeal to emotions and nothing logical or truthful to say.

 

[rosends]

It's not antisemitism you poor man, it is simply a brief statement regarding historical facts. I have always had good Jewish friends. Jewish lawyers have saved my bacon a few times. Jewish men and women like Greenwald, Sachs, Wolf are modern day heroes who speak the truth about the criminality of the Zionist state.

When you invoke the term "antisemitism" you reveal all you have is a cry-baby appeal to emotions and nothing logical or truthful to say.

Sure it is. Not only do you make sweeping generalizations, and not only do you ignore history, but you villify Jews as a whole. That's anti-Semitism.