Zone1 do you believe in a god?

do you believe in a god?

  • yes

  • i am not sure

  • no

  • i am a member of a church

  • i am no member of a church

  • i am a member of some other religious movement


Results are only viewable after voting.
Until I know why I've changed, how can I know how I'll change? I can't just change my core beliefs any more than I could just change my sexuality and decide to become gay.
As a child, you never once played a game of, Let's pretend that....? You do not possess one iota of imagination?

You cannot even imagine having knowledge or a brief experience of God that would change anything about how you now perceive life, your own being, and others?
 
As a child, you never once played a game of, Let's pretend that....? You do not possess one iota of imagination?

You cannot even imagine having knowledge or a brief experience of God that would change anything about how you now perceive life, your own being, and others?
Sorry, I can't imagine being anyone but who I am.
 
Sorry, I can't imagine being anyone but who I am.
That's nothing to mourn. What is worth feeling a bit sorry about is not being able to imagine there is more to know and experience when it comes to God.
 
Sort of what people used to tell me about LSD.
LSD is a hallucinogen that alters one's sense of reality. God draws one deeper into actual reality. Have you considered you want neither a hallucinogen or reality--that both/either are too much? I chose reality.
 
Equating a possible universe creator with the improbable God of the Christian Bible is, IMHO, a leap I'm unable to make.
I wasn't asking you to make that leap. I was telling you that I use creator and God interchangeably. You said, that is literally a leap of faith. I asked how so. You then tried to make it about the God of Abraham instead which has nothing to do with my using those terms interchangeably. You lack of objectivity when it comes to God and you are argumentative. This isn't you being curious. This is you being argumentative. It's more like militant atheist lite. So much for live and let live, eh. SMH.
 
Until I know why I've changed, how can I know how I'll change? I can't just change my core beliefs any more than I could just change my sexuality and decide to become gay.
Why not? Do you believe what you prefer never changes?
 
LSD is a hallucinogen that alters one's sense of reality. God draws one deeper into actual reality. Have you considered you want neither a hallucinogen or reality--that both/either are too much? I chose reality.
That belief in God draws one deeper into actual reality is not something I can accept. One is no more real than the other, IMHO.
 
I wasn't asking you to make that leap. I was telling you that I use creator and God interchangeably.
And I was telling you that, to me at least, they are very different.

You said, that is literally a leap of faith. I asked how so. You then tried to make it about the God of Abraham instead which has nothing to do with my using those terms interchangeably. You lack of objectivity when it comes to God and you are argumentative. This isn't you being curious. This is you being argumentative. It's more like militant atheist lite. So much for live and let live, eh. SMH.
I have no doubt that you believe in the God of Abraham (or you would not be a Catholic) and that you believe He is the creator. I find it disingenuous of you to complain I make it about the God of Abraham when that is exactly how you see the creator. Am I wrong? Is there a difference between the two?
 
Why not? Do you believe what you prefer never changes?
My preferences change, especially as I get older. I used to love staying up late, now I love getting up early, but I'm still heterosexual and will likely be so until I die. Do you think you might try the homosexual lifestyle (assuming you are not already there) just to find out what it would be like?
 
How do I make it a sacred act? What are the rules?
Do you really want to hear the rules from a Christian who has accepted his bible as just allegory and not literally true?

Ask a Christian who still has faith enough to accept stories such as 'Jonah and the big fish' or the 'Noah's ark story' as still being literally true!
 
Do you really want to hear the rules from a Christian who has accepted his bible as just allegory and not literally true?

Ask a Christian who still has faith enough to accept stories such as 'Jonah and the big fish' or the 'Noah's ark story' as still being literally true!
I know the literalist answer, ding is more interesting.
 
15th post
And I was telling you that, to me at least, they are very different.
Maybe so but that's not how it was intended in post #143. In that post you were responding to MY use of God and creator interchangeably. In that post you were questioning MY leap of faith. It's no leap at all. I see God and the creator as one and the same.
I have no doubt that you believe in the God of Abraham (or you would not be a Catholic) and that you believe He is the creator. I find it disingenuous of you to complain I make it about the God of Abraham when that is exactly how you see the creator. Am I wrong? Is there a difference between the two?
Yes, you are wrong. First and foremost I don't confuse religion or dogma for God. And I never place religious dogma above God as many do. Secondly, it can't be that you were telling me it was YOUR leap of faith and then switch to explaining how it must have been my leap of faith because I am a Catholic. It can't be both. So I wasn't being disingenuous at all by calling out your disingenuousness. You are putting YOUR bias against the God of Abraham onto my using God and creator interchangeably and seeing MY perception as a leap of faith. When in reality it is merely convention. You are literally making an argument of semantics when none is needed.

My preferences change, especially as I get older. I used to love staying up late, now I love getting up early, but I'm still heterosexual and will likely be so until I die. Do you think you might try the homosexual lifestyle (assuming you are not already there) just to find out what it would be like?
Why would I? My preference is women. Besides I take my vow to my wife quite seriously. I'm not even sure why we are discussing this because my comment wasn't directed at changing one's sexuality. My comment was directed at you saying, "Until I know why I've changed, how can I know how I'll change? I can't just change my core beliefs..." So why can't you do that? Do you believe what you prefer never changes? It's not like you believe in absolute right and wrong, right? Besides I don't believe people consciously make core belief changes. I believe it is more of a subconscious thing that occurs over a long period of time and experiences. So many times you won't know why you changed until after you have changed. Sure, you can try to effect change and when you do that you are consciously aware of what you are trying to do. But that doesn't mean you will be successful at doing it. I'm afraid in the end the only absolute here is that you will know you changed after the fact. And that is probably when you will figure out why you changed... after the fact.
 
Maybe so but that's not how it was intended in post #143. In that post you were responding to MY use of God and creator interchangeably. In that post you were questioning MY leap of faith. It's no leap at all. I see God and the creator as one and the same.
So what is the relationship between God/creator and the God of Abraham?

Why would I? My preference is women. Besides I take my vow to my wife quite seriously. I'm not even sure why we are discussing this because my comment wasn't directed at changing one's sexuality. My comment was directed at you saying, "Until I know why I've changed, how can I know how I'll change? I can't just change my core beliefs..." So why can't you do that? Do you believe what you prefer never changes?
Do you believe what you prefer never changes? So like Meriweather asked me, imagine your belief changed and you didn't believe in God, how would that change your life?
 
So what is the relationship between God/creator and the God of Abraham?
Semantics. I use God and creator interchangeably.

Do you believe what you prefer never changes? So like @Meriweather asked me, imagine your belief changed and you didn't believe in God, how would that change your life?
I believe change is the only constant but it is so slow it is almost imperceptible. I won't get into your and Meri's conversation.

Do you really need to rationalize your belief that the only thing that exists is the material by asking me that question? How do you know that the only thing that exists is the material? The material world is quite strange in and of itself. How do you know everything isn't just information which is incorporeal? What is your answer for why an intelligent person such as myself believes the incorporeal is the source or matrix of the corporeal?
 
Back
Top Bottom