Are you ashamed of your heritage?

[Quantrill]

The Civil War was the only war where the losers got to dictate the revised history and honor the leaders of the losing side

Lost Cause"
refers to a romanticized, revisionist interpretation of the American Civil War, claiming the Confederacy fought for states' rights, not slavery, and idealizing the antebellum South, downplaying slavery's horrors, and portraying Southerners as noble victims; it also refers to any hopeless endeavor or person unlikely to succeed. This myth, promoted by former Confederates, distorts history and remains influential in Southern culture and monuments, shifting focus from slavery to states' rights and Southern honor.

You're living proof of the lies the victors love to tell. It is the reason you say things but cannot support them. Shame you never got past your elementary education level of the War.

You just breathe and belch back whats been blown up your ass.

Quantrill

 

[rightwinger]

You're living proof of the lies the victors love to tell. It is the reason you say things but cannot support them. Shame you never got past your elementary education level of the War.

You just breathe and belch back whats been blown up your ass.

Quantrill

You are living proof that the Lost Cause is going strong

I have done extensive reading on the Civil War and visited dozens of battlefields and museums

 

[Mr Natural]

Kill them to keep them. Nice motto for a nation founded on individual liberty.

Can’t fix stupid.

You want to talk about stupid?

How about a people who start a war to prove that they are better than the slaves and lose. Bigly!

 

[gipper]

You want to talk about stupid?

How about a people who start a war to prove that they are better than the slaves and lose. Bigly!

Except for the fact they didn’t start it.

Can’t fix stupid.

 

[Quantrill]

You are living proof that the Lost Cause is going strong

I have done extensive reading on the Civil War and visited dozens of battlefields and museums

Thank you.

So you say. Next time you say something that evidences that knowledge, give your reference.

Quantrill

 

[rightwinger]

Except for the fact they didn’t start it.

Can’t fix stupid.

Attacking the United States was not a good idea
Ask the Japanese

 

[gipper]

Indeed, he is Americas idol. Lincoln would throw blacks under the bus whenever necessary. Yet they still view him as the great Moses come down from the mountain with the emancipation in his hands.

When they should be tearing down the Lincoln Memorial as they do our Confederate monuments and flags.

Quantrill

As you likely know but few Americans do, dishonest Abe was discussing plans to forcibly remove all blacks from the country in the last months of his life.

 

[gipper]

Attacking the United States was not a good idea
Ask the Japanese

Oh that’s funny. I’m sure your buddy the fake teacher will not like that response, though he fully supports Lincoln’s destruction of the South.

He’s one very confused MFer.

 

[rightwinger]

As you likely know but few Americans do, dishonest Abe was discussing plans to forcibly remove all blacks from the country in the last months of his life.

No, he had dismissed that idea long before.
It was a common suggestion at the time. Look at Liberia.
But Lincoln realized it was impractical.

History did show it took a century before the U.S. officially accepted equal status of blacks

 

[Quantrill]

As you likely know but few Americans do, dishonest Abe was discussing plans to forcibly remove all blacks from the country in the last months of his life.

That's correct. And Lincoln did so many illegal things during that war. Suspended the writ of Habeas Corpus so he could arrest whoever he pleased.

Quantrill

 

[rightwinger]

That's correct. And Lincoln did so many illegal things during that war. Suspended the writ of Habeas Corpus so he could arrest whoever he pleased.

Quantrill

Desperate times called for desperate measures

 

[Quantrill]

Lincoln suspends Habeas Corpus: (When In The Course Of Human Events, Charles Adams, Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, p. 45)

"A British publication saw Mr. Lincoln's deeds as those of a dictator:" They said, "There is no Parliamentary [congressional] authority whatever for what has been done. It has been done simply on Mr. Lincoln's fiat. At his simple bidding, acting by no authority but his own pleasure, in plain defiance of the provisions of the Constitution, the Habeas Corpus Act has been suspended, the press muzzled, and judges prevented by armed men from enforcing on the citizens behalf the laws to which they and the President alike have sworn."

Quantrill

 

[Quantrill]

Desperate times called for desperate measures

That's why the South seceded.

Quantrill

 

[rightwinger]

Lincoln suspends Habeas Corpus: (When In The Course Of Human Events, Charles Adams, Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, p. 45)

"A British publication saw Mr. Lincoln's deeds as those of a dictator:" They said, "There is no Parliamentary [congressional] authority whatever for what has been done. It has been done simply on Mr. Lincoln's fiat. At his simple bidding, acting by no authority but his own pleasure, in plain defiance of the provisions of the Constitution, the Habeas Corpus Act has been suspended, the press muzzled, and judges prevented by armed men from enforcing on the citizens behalf the laws to which they and the President alike have sworn."

Quantrill

What rights did the Confederacy give to the 40 percent of their population that was kept as slaves?

 

[Quantrill]

What rights did the Confederacy give to the 40 percent of their population that was kept as slaves?

They didn't have any rights. And it wasn't the Confederacy that determined that, it was the U.S. government. "Glory, glory...hallelujah"

Quantrill

 

[rightwinger]

They didn't have any rights. And it wasn't the Confederacy that determined that, it was the U.S. government. "Glory, glory...hallelujah"

Quantrill

So let’s get this straight

Your Confederacy gave slaves no rights as human beings but you condemn Lincoln for suspending habeas corpus?

 

[Mr Natural]

Except for the fact they didn’t start it.

Can’t fix stupid.

Who attacked Ft Sumpter?

 

[gipper]

That's correct. And Lincoln did so many illegal things during that war. Suspended the writ of Habeas Corpus so he could arrest whoever he pleased.

Quantrill

Yes. Just additional actions he took that few Americans know.

He forcibly shuttered numerous newspapers, arrested and exiled Ohio congressman Clement Vallandigham for opposing his war.

After Gettysburg, he sent troops to NYC to forcibly suppress draft riots, killing dozens.

His Emancipation Proclamation was an obvious deception, as it only freed slaves not under Union control.

His Gettysburg Address is entirely lacking in reality. He speaks of a ‘new birth of freedom’ all the while mass murdering southern Americans. He proclaims a government of by and for the people, but apparently this doesn’t apply to southerns.

We could go all day listing his tyrannical unconstitutional actions.

 

[gipper]

Who attacked Ft Sumpter?

So dumb. The typical response of a statist.

Spell it right dummy.

You haven’t progressed beyond 5th grade.

Get informed before posting.

 

[Mr Natural]

So dumb. The typical response of a statist.

Spell it right dummy.

You haven’t progressed beyond 5th grade.

Get informed before posting.

Well, smart guy, who attacked Ft Sumter?