The "Hillary Rosen" Standard

[NYcarbineer]

She was just gruging up what Obama and the DNC told her to say.

When it backfired, they left her to hang.

That is just plain dumb. She is a political analyst on CNN. Obama is not responsible for every comment made by a pundit.

However she has been in to visit the obama administration in the white house over a dozen times according to visitor logs...............which is why people are attaching her to him.

No, which is why people are wrongly attaching her to him.

 

[NYcarbineer]

Hence me calling it the "Rosen Standard"

Its not all that deep of a concept

Why don't you show how silly Romney's premise was by suggesting that his wife had some unique talent for discussing the economic problems of American women?

Start at the beginning because that is what Rosen was actually, in fact and in context, responding to.

NYCaribeener is not qualified to comment about Anne Romney because he isn't a woman. you aren't qualified to talk about Mitt either as your not a mormon (well maybe you are, if so then i'll find another thing that works under the "Rosen" stnadard )

I have no idea what your point is at this point.

When people said Obama wasn't qualified to be president because he didn't have executive experience, people like myself said they were idiots.

Were they idiots or not?

 

[PLYMCO_PILGRIM]

.

A few more...

Poor people can't talk about rich people because they don't know what it's like to be rich.
White people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be black.
Black people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be white.
Conservatives can't talk about liberals because they don't know what it's like to be liberal.
Liberals can't talk about conservatives because they don't know what it's like to be conservative.

This is fun! Imagine all the bullshit rhetoric we can eliminate!

.

NYCaribeener, see this post if you still don't get it


Also remember who made the thread, its not like I run around laying personal attacks against obama or his wife, I only attack his policies and decisions WHEN i don't like said policies and decisions........are you starting to understand the thread yet?

 

[PLYMCO_PILGRIM]

Why are people making stuff up about republicans and democrats warring against women?

fixed.

double fixed, its a USMB violation to directly alter quotes, which is why i deleted the author's name from my quote

 

[nitroz]

Why are people making stuff up about republicans and democrats warring against women?

fixed.

double fixed, its a USMB violation to directly alter quotes, which is why i deleted the author's name from my quote

it is? awww

 

[PLYMCO_PILGRIM]

fixed.

double fixed, its a USMB violation to directly alter quotes, which is why i deleted the author's name from my quote

it is? awww

which one are you awwing LOL

 

[chanel]

I love the Rosen rule! Now will lesbians be permitted to discuss women's issues because - well - let's face it - they don't have to worry about abortion? And isn't that the only thing women really care about according to the faux revolutionaries battling the War on Women? Lol

 

[NYcarbineer]

.

A few more...

Poor people can't talk about rich people because they don't know what it's like to be rich.
White people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be black.
Black people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be white.
Conservatives can't talk about liberals because they don't know what it's like to be liberal.
Liberals can't talk about conservatives because they don't know what it's like to be conservative.

This is fun! Imagine all the bullshit rhetoric we can eliminate!

.

NYCaribeener, see this post if you still don't get it


Also remember who made the thread, its not like I run around laying personal attacks against obama or his wife, I only attack his policies and decisions WHEN i don't like said policies and decisions........are you starting to understand the thread yet?

Why would you name it the Rosen rule in view of the fact that it's been around forever?

That's stupid.

 

[PLYMCO_PILGRIM]

.

A few more...

Poor people can't talk about rich people because they don't know what it's like to be rich.
White people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be black.
Black people can't talk about racism because they don't know what it's like to be white.
Conservatives can't talk about liberals because they don't know what it's like to be liberal.
Liberals can't talk about conservatives because they don't know what it's like to be conservative.

This is fun! Imagine all the bullshit rhetoric we can eliminate!

.

NYCaribeener, see this post if you still don't get it


Also remember who made the thread, its not like I run around laying personal attacks against obama or his wife, I only attack his policies and decisions WHEN i don't like said policies and decisions........are you starting to understand the thread yet?

Why would you name it the Rosen rule in view of the fact that it's been around forever?

That's stupid.

Wow you have NO SENSE of current events.

I'm sorry this thread has you distraught and confused.

 

[The T]

She was just gruging up what Obama and the DNC told her to say.

When it backfired, they left her to hang.

35X Visitor to the Oval Oraface to talk to Obama.

Obama had to say something today...He had to save face.


Obama sticks up for Ann Romney in working mom flap

Another minion under the bus...another speed bump created...

 

[saveliberty]

Not very surprising, the Obama Adminstration has never lived in reality.

 

[jgarden]

... Which led me to the "Hillary Rosen" standard. Basically she is saying that those with "no experience have no business advising" on issues they have no experience in.

So who is unqualified to do their current job under Hillary Rosen's standard. I'll provide 3, you guys provide some more.....they don't have to be party specific as there are plenty of politicians, in fact almost all of them, on both sides that do not qualify under her "standards"

1) Obama is NOT QUALIFIED to talk about the conservatives because he has been a liberal his whole life.
2) Nancy Pelosi is NOT QUALIFIED to talk about issues affecting the poor/middle class because she has lived the rich lifestyle her whole life
3) Harry Reid is NOT QUALIFIED to talk about christian issues because he has been a mormon his whole life

Taking 2) to its logical conclusion, the OP should also agree that Mitt Romney (and his wife) are also NOT QUALIFIED to talk about issues affecting the poor/middle class as a presidental candidate because he has lived the rich lifestyle his whole life.

In fact, Romney is NOT QUALIFIED to talk to about 99.999% of the American electorate - but he is QUALIFIED to talk to the ones who have $180 - $250 million in assets, have given another $70 - $100 million to their children/grandchildren, own 3 mansions (homes) and earn about $21 million a year from investment income.

 

[Sallow]

Man you guys are something. Romney's said some extremely idiotic things..and Bush was the master of idiocy.

Ms. Rosen makes one quip that at it's base is pretty valid. Mrs. Romney has never been in the workforce and has basically been rich most of her life. She hasn't the slightest idea what most people face nor does she care. And neither does Mitt. He's 65, got more money then some 400 or 500 Americans would ever need in a lifetime, combined..and got a lot of time on his hands. So he's bored.

Hence the run for President.

 

[Sallow]

Not very surprising, the Obama Adminstration has never lived in reality.

That's patently ridiculous.

Maybe you don't consider being a lawyer a "job" but going to school, passing the bar and getting involved in an actual practice..is very difficult. And he did so well he was able to lecture. As well as make money writing a couple of books.

That's without a father who had megabucks..and was governor.

 

[skookerasbil]

Why are Democrats warring on women?

Its called distraction with bogus issues. And nobody does it better than liberals, I must admit. There are the throngs of the hopelessly duped out there and they know it. Pretty schrewd.

I gotta applaud Rosen............this'll be the soundbite that keeps on giving!!!

 

[uscitizen]

What is a Hillary Rosen? And why should we listen to her?

 

[editec]

People who were to the manor born don't have a freaking clue what life is like for most people.

Most people who were not the manor born don't have a breaking clue what life is like for those to the manor born.

I mean, seriously...this isn't rocket science.

 

[Mac1958]

What is a Hillary Rosen?

Influential democrat activist. Frequent White House visitor.

And why should we listen to her?

One person's opinion is one thing. But she has received much support and agreement from the Left during this episode, and that does mean something, especially the way the Left has been using this "War On Women" schtick to such extent. They made their bed.


.

 

[uscitizen]

What is a Hillary Rosen?

Influential democrat activist. Frequent White House visitor.

And why should we listen to her?

One person's opinion is one thing. But she has received much support and agreement from the Left during this episode, and that does mean something, especially the way the Left has been using this "War On Women" schtick to such extent. They made their bed.


.

Ohh like the gay massage spiritual advisor to Bush? Or Gannon who ran a gay escort service?

Yes I suppose you are right...

 

[Mac1958]

What is a Hillary Rosen?

Influential democrat activist. Frequent White House visitor.

And why should we listen to her?

One person's opinion is one thing. But she has received much support and agreement from the Left during this episode, and that does mean something, especially the way the Left has been using this "War On Women" schtick to such extent. They made their bed.


.

Ohh like the gay massage spiritual advisor to Bush? Or Gannon who ran a gay escort service?

Yes I suppose you are right...

Sure. Since I have no allegiance to either silly side, I think that could be a fair comparison.

Of course, I don't recall seeing a bunch of well-known Republicans publicly supporting that stuff, but what the hell, if that's the best diversionary comparison we're gonna get, I'll run with it for now.

Glad we agree! That was easy!

.