Most of my life I've been indifferent as far as following any belief. My goal was to stay neutral. lol
Then 3 yrs or so of living "only with nature", trying to find my inner God, new age, pagan ect.... Im a Christian/ I follow Christ.
...it was more what I was clearly shown, than any decision on my part.
Though I took a somewhat different path to get there, that was pretty much my experience too. As a young adult out in the world and exposed to the cynicism and arguments of the Atheists, I entertained doubts but was also filled with a great curiosity. I embarked on a journey of well over a decade to learn all I could learn about religion. I took courses, I did a lot of independent study, I talked with 'holy men' of many different traditions, and experienced their traditions up close and personal whenever I could.
And finally when it was all said and done I could see the appeal of all religious beliefs and could find the truths that exist in every religion. But the one truth I could not explain away or deny is that the Christ is real, the Christ is God, and I am a Christian.