You're flag is racist- just an FYI- but, sfw- I love the Stars and Stripes myself- especially on top of the General Lee-
Actually, the flag is history.
So is this:
View attachment 477815
German history.
World history.
You are right. History is history. Good or bad.
I agree with, as far as history goes. But there were a lot of years in which domestic terrorists used the symbol to keep a segment of the population in line. Both the overt terrorist acts and the threat of more of those acts created a legacy for that piece of history.
We are supposed to learn from history, not pay for it.
When a symbol is used to terrify a specific segment of the population, and many people of authority ignored the issues, it changes the way the symbol is perceived.
You are not having to pay for it. But how many think that flag that has caused so much trouble is the flag of the Confederate States?
Yes, the Confederacy is history. But to wave the Battle Flag of the Army of Northern Virginia around like it means something, when that meaning has been co-opted by a couple of generations of domestic terrorists is insanity.
View attachment 477877
Yes and No
WinterBorn
This is not an exclusive monopoly.
We do have to be careful and considerate but that does not mean judging and punishing people for our differences in cultural meaning and perspective.
The WAP video upset a lot of people, but not everyone agreed. Dissenters can turn off the Grammy's and not support that sector of the music industry.
You can wave your own flag and teach your interpretation of these symbols.
But you cannot expect to impose your interpretation as the "dominant mandate everyone must follow" without becoming the thought police you are fighting against.
I am not imposing my interpretation on anyone. Just explaining why the waving of the battle flag of the army of Northern Virginia is prone to incite hostile feelings in some.
In the old days? 30, 40 years ago. . . the left liked to offend folks, they were never worried about folks feelings. This is America, grow up and be responsible for your own damn feelings.
If you can't control your feelings? You are a child and had lousy parenting and schooling.
I am all grown up, thanks. I am also responsible for my own damn feelings. No problem.
I have control over my feelings. I am not a child. And I had excellent parents and good schooling.
But thanks for your concern.
Great. . . so stop white knighting for folks, and let anyone say anything they want, and wave any flag they want.
Freedom, what a concept?
I am only responsible for what I say. I am not responsible for your misinterpretation of what I say.
Can you please point out where I said people should not be allowed to wave any flag they want?
You are telling the forum, when others use a flag, what their intentions are. . . by the reactions on-lookers have.
"But to wave the Battle Flag of the Army of Northern Virginia around like it means something, when that meaning has been co-opted by a couple of generations of domestic terrorists is insanity."
This, of course, is wrong.
The intentions of those using the symbol, belong to the person using the symbol.
Just the same as. . . If I made the claim that you are calling every person that waves the American Flag a white supremacist, even though this is clearly something you have never written? That would be false. So I have no right to impute upon you something you have never said or written. . . yet you are in this thread imputing motive on folks by the way their use of a symbol makes others feel.
That is ridiculous.
How others feel about the use of a symbol? That is on them.
The only thing that matters is what a person says about the use of that symbol.
All of the times folks in various states demanded that the Battle flag of Virginia be taken out of the State Capitol flags? All of those instances were patently ridiculous. . . as none of those instances had anything at all to do with slavery, nothing. It was purely a political move by the left and the federalists grasp for more power.
That had to do with depressing Southern Heritage.