Zone1 Well regulated militia

[Delldude]

That article also states...

Not an article......part of the COTUS......what you posted was an Act.

Militia Act - law crested by Congress.

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Not an article......part of the COTUS......what you posted was an Act.

Militia Act - law crested by Congress.

You're the one who wanted to bring up Article 1 Section 8 Clause 15.

Live with it and admit that the militia is not the national guard but all able bodied citizens capable of bearing arms are responsible to answer the call of the president of these United States when necessary.

CHUCKLE

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Just looked up and read the Act of 28 February 1795.

Yep! Inactive vets, those signed up for selective service, and all other able bodied persons are considered part of the militia. Nothing about having to be well trained or organized that I noticed in that act so I guess those covered under that definition are all part of the "well regulated militia'.

I guess the American Legion and VFW can expand their membership applications to all those who qualify to be part of the "well regulated militia".

SMILE

 

[d0gbreath]

View attachment 1056819

Just looked up and read the Act of 28 February 1795.

Yep! Inactive vets, those signed up for selective service, and all other able bodied persons are considered part of the militia. Nothing about having to be well trained or organized that I noticed in that act so I guess those covered under that definition are all part of the "well regulated militia'.

I guess the American Legion and VFW can expand their membership applications to all those who qualify to be part of the "well regulated militia".

SMILE

Since I signed up for selective service in '73 I'm in? That's good to know.

 

[Delldude]

You're the one who wanted to bring up Article 1 Section 8 Clause 15.

No, it was you:

No where in the Constitution is it written that the "well regulated militia" has to be well trained and organized.

Live with it and admit that the militia is not the national guard but all able bodied citizens capable of bearing arms are responsible to answer the call of the president of these United States when necessary.

State militias are what eventually became the NG. That left an 'unorganized' component referred to as 'reserve militia', still under state and federal control for training and what not, as defined in COTUS.

The 'well regulated' thing is a leftover of the early days of our country, whether you like it or not, which has pretty much gone away in most cases.


Could you provide a list of the 'reserve militias' in all 50 states?

 

[Damaged Eagle]

No, it was you:

You brought it up in your post #159 of this thread. I'm not going to play childish games with you.

State militias are what eventually became the NG. That left an 'unorganized' component referred to as 'reserve militia', still under state and federal control for training and what not, as defined in COTUS.

The 'well regulated' thing is a leftover of the early days of our country, whether you like it or not, which has pretty much gone away in most cases.


Could you provide a list of the 'reserve militias' in all 50 states?

That's not what Article 1 Section 8 Clause 15 or the Act of 28 February 1795 states.

Thanks for directing me to the info I needed...

CHUCKLE

 

[Delldude]

You brought it up in your post #159 of this thread. I'm not going to play childish games with you.

Well little man, you made the challenge in post #158............

No where in the Constitution is it written that the "well regulated militia" has to be well trained and organized.

That's not what Article 1 Section 8 Clause 15 or the Act of 28 February 1795 states.

It isn't in either, genius.

Try, try again.

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Well little man, you made the challenge in post #158............




It isn't in either, genius.

Try, try again.

If you have some other legislative paper proving otherwise you're free to present it otherwise...

CHUCKLE

 

[Delldude]

If you have some other legislative paper proving otherwise you're free to present it otherwise...

Do like I did, research the subject.....

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Do like I did, research the subject.....

I just did. I read all the info you referred me to and it says the able bodied citizen is considered part of the militia and can be called upon by the president to serve in a time of war or invasion.

I'm sorry if you don't like the sources you've referred me to but...

CHUCKLE

 

[Delldude]

I just did. I read all the info you referred me to and it says the able bodied citizen is considered part of the militia and can be called upon by the president to serve

Never disputed that.

You challenged any wording in the COTUS that said about training and so on.

Now you're jumping all over the place.

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Never disputed that.

You challenged any wording in the COTUS that said about training and so on.

Now you're jumping all over the place.

Then the COTUS has a decision to make. Either the firearm training and firearm license is provided to the citizen or they allow a fee to be charged to be charged when a person chooses to vote and they have to prove they took civics training to exercise that right.

SMILE

 

[Delldude]

Then the COTUS has a decision to make. Either the firearm training and firearm license is provided to the citizen or they allow a fee to be charged to be charged when a person chooses to vote and they have to prove they took civics training to exercise that right.

Maybe work on that when you get a list of the militias in all 50 states.

 

[ThisIsMe]

“Well regulated” does not refer to government regulation. Leftists are just misinformed and don’t desire to do any homework

I understood "well regulated" to mean, well trained and well supplied...right?

 

[Picaro]

Please post this in your front yard.

Please try to read some real history. You can read it under the sheets at night so your fellow shills won;t see you and kick you out of the treehouse club.

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Maybe work on that when you get a list of the militias in all 50 states.

Each of the states should already have that list of names.

SMILE

 

[Damaged Eagle]

Please try to read some real history. You can read it under the sheets at night so your fellow shills won;t see you and kick you out of the treehouse club.

So you're ashamed to proudly proclaim that your home is gun free like a good little liberal and have to rely on real men to protect you when the $hit hits the fan.

CHUCKLE

 

[Damaged Eagle]

I understood "well regulated" to mean, well trained and well supplied...right?

It just says "well regulated" that doesn't mean trained or supplied which means all the government needs to know is who to call, namely you, and you supply your own.

SMILE

 

[Picaro]

View attachment 1057287

So you're ashamed to proudly proclaim that your home is gun free like a good little liberal and have to rely on real men to protect you when the $hit hits the fan.

CHUCKLE

You don't know shit about my home or my take on gun control. It's an historical fact states and even towns could make their own laws and ordinances re guns as they saw fit. They didn't need your permission. Choke on it.

 

[Damaged Eagle]

You don't know shit about my home or my take on gun control. It's an historical fact states and even towns could make their own laws and ordinances re guns as they saw fit. They didn't need your permission. Choke on it.

Shouldn't those states and cities also be able to deny you to vote or pay a fee?

SMILE