gallantwarrior
Gold Member
People are not equal.Ayn Rand saw that government control of ideas and creativity results in destruction of innovation. Why would anyone want to create new things if only government profited from their work?Ayn Rand is one of my literary heroes! I actually buy her books and give them away to people who might be interested in her writing. I've read most of her writings, but especially value "Atlas Shrugged" and " The Fountainhead". Both are so appropriate to even this time.What about "Island of Treasure" by Stevenson? AN awesome book for several generations in Russia. Have you seen Russian animated movie on this book?
No I haven't. I read the book as a youth--did a book report on it once--but so long ago I probably should read it again.
But on your other mention, we have "Doctor Zhivago" in our home movie collection and watched it again recently. An absolutely beautiful and well done movie but also disturbing and depressing. It isn't a movie I would watch when I want to lift my spirits.
It's a famous book and Pasternak, previously, a talented poet
But. There are a lot of books, films, opinions and so on about "Russia, which we lost", means before-revolution Russia. Both Pasternak and his hero, Dr. Zhivago - from "Intelligentsia", quite rich and educated people with a "free" profession... like Ayn Rand and so on... Offcourse, they had reason to be in depression, because Soviet Authorities made their life more poor, for make better life of another 200 million people in former Russian Empire... But as for me, I share the point of view of another Russian poet Nickolay Gumilev: "Me? I'm not intelligentsia! I have a profession!" So, I prefer positive mood to work and build own life, than depressive "searches of soul" of "intelligentsia" ) Now they usually call men like me a "cotton jacket" ))
She's a talented writer, asking many true questions, but I don't agree with her answers She propagated individualism - it's good, but her individualism based on default non-equality of people... I consider, non-equality between people might be only in target reaching process, not by rights of the birth or who are your friends or someone else. I agree with ideas of Fountainhead only because they building houses for people - and there are no meanings what they have in their heads, only result... But if heroes of Fountainhead weren't built houses, but were gathering postage-stamps or something else - it would be different situation. But how do you think - would it seriously change Ayn Rand ideas?