U.S. Marines To Investigate Video of Soldiers Urinating on Corpses

[OohPooPahDoo]

Corpse pissing is also a cultural taboo in some societies.

I think those Marines showed a decided lack of discipline.

Somebody should give them a time out. I hate to be unduly harsh, but I think they might even be in line for a loss of a day's pay.

They should be punished and sentenced according to the law, not according to you.

 

[SFC Ollie]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

If you want to piss on corpses, renounce your citizenship and join the ******* Taliban or go fight for mercenaries in Africa.

Otherwise, pay the consequences for your actions.

Yes we do, and more cases than not those standards are upheld and excelled. But how many combat tours had these guys been on? How many have you been on?

Renounce your own citizenship and leave the military to take care of the military...........

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

If you want to piss on corpses, renounce your citizenship and join the ******* Taliban or go fight for mercenaries in Africa.

Otherwise, pay the consequences for your actions.

Yes we do, and more cases than not those standards are upheld and excelled. But how many combat tours had these guys been on? How many have you been on?

Renounce your own citizenship and leave the military to take care of the military...........

Are you saying that everyone who has been on as many combat tours as they have just can't resist pissing on corpses? This should be accepted behavior? Is that what you are saying?


I would bet good money that at least 99% of those who have seen as much combat as them have never pissed on a corpse.

 

[Warrior102]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

Yes we do

You served when/where?

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

Yes we do

You served when/where?

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

 

[Sunshine]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

Yes we do

You served when/where?

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

The overwhelming majority of people who have served the US in combat have not been killed. What does that fly in the face of. Oh. Right. Our enemies!

 

[Sunshine]

Corpse pissing is also a cultural taboo in some societies.

I think those Marines showed a decided lack of discipline.

Somebody should give them a time out. I hate to be unduly harsh, but I think they might even be in line for a loss of a day's pay.

Well, I do know a therapist who assigned one of her patients the task of pouring a jar of piss on the grave of the patients abusive husband who killed himself. He managed to abuse her for most of her life, then he gave her the ultimate '**** you' - suicide. She did it and it helped her to attain closure.

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

Yes we do

You served when/where?

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

The overwhelming majority of people who have served the US in combat have not been killed. What does that fly in the face of. Oh. Right. Our enemies!

Nonsensical response of the day.

 

[Zoom]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

If you want to piss on corpses, renounce your citizenship and join the ******* Taliban or go fight for mercenaries in Africa.

Otherwise, pay the consequences for your actions.

Well, that pretty much sums it all up nicely.

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

Corpse pissing is also a cultural taboo in some societies.

I think those Marines showed a decided lack of discipline.

Somebody should give them a time out. I hate to be unduly harsh, but I think they might even be in line for a loss of a day's pay.

Well, I do know a therapist who assigned one of her patients the task of pouring a jar of piss on the grave of the patients abusive husband who killed himself. He managed to abuse her for most of her life, then he gave her the ultimate '**** you' - suicide. She did it and it helped her to attain closure.

Good for her.


BTW, I'm happy we hold our military to higher standards than we hold our licensed therapists.

 

[SFC Ollie]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

Yes we do

You served when/where?

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

You will never understand then will you? So leave the military to police it's own and go back to your warm fireplace. All is right with the world...........

 

[Liability]

Corpse pissing is also a cultural taboo in some societies.

I think those Marines showed a decided lack of discipline.

Somebody should give them a time out. I hate to be unduly harsh, but I think they might even be in line for a loss of a day's pay.

They should be punished and sentenced according to the law, not according to you.

Interesting how you jump to punishment before a conviction.

In any event, you also seem utterly unfamiliar with the notion of prosecutorial discretiion.

Let's say that pissing on the recently dead body of the enemy is desecrating a corpse. Let's agree that the U.C.M.J. forbids desecrating corpses. Then let's assume that the Marines were indeed urinating on dead Taliban fighters.

Is that absolutely and unquestionably the same thing as desecrating a corpse?

Are there no mitigation factors to be considered?

Also, let's say that the maximum possible sentence for the UCMJ violation of descrating a corpse could be 20 years. Are you one of those who would call for maximum time in the event of a conviction at a Court Martial?

I am inclined to stick with what I said before. I realize it's harsh: but dock them a day's pay!

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

Yes we do

You served when/where?

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

You will never understand then will you? So leave the military to police it's own and go back to your warm fireplace. All is right with the world...........

How many corpses did you piss on?

 

[OohPooPahDoo]

Corpse pissing is also a cultural taboo in some societies.

I think those Marines showed a decided lack of discipline.

Somebody should give them a time out. I hate to be unduly harsh, but I think they might even be in line for a loss of a day's pay.

They should be punished and sentenced according to the law, not according to you.

Interesting how you jump to punishment before a conviction.

I said they should be punished according to the law. The law does not allow for people to be punished without conviction. I figure since you're so smart you already knew that. My bad.

In any event, you also seem utterly unfamiliar with the notion of prosecutorial discretiion.

I'm familiar with it. Its also a decision left up to the prosecutor.

Let's say that pissing on the recently dead body of the enemy is desecrating a corpse. Let's agree that the U.C.M.J. forbids desecrating corpses. Then let's assume that the Marines were indeed urinating on dead Taliban fighters.

Is that absolutely and unquestionably the same thing as desecrating a corpse?

Are there no mitigation factors to be considered?

If there are mitigating factors their defense can bring that up.

Also, let's say that the maximum possible sentence for the UCMJ violation of descrating a corpse could be 20 years. Are you one of those who would call for maximum time in the event of a conviction at a Court Martial?

Which particular sentence is given out of the range of available sentences is a decision for the court to make. Not you, me or the media.

 

[SFC Ollie]

I never did.

I presume you have. How many corpses did you piss on? Was it zero? I'm betting it was.

Did you know even one fellow soldier that had pissed on a corpse? I bet not.

The idea that one cannot help but to piss on corpses once one has seen enough combat flies in the face of the fact that the overwhelming majority of people who have served in combat have never pissed on a corpse, wouldn't you say?

You will never understand then will you? So leave the military to police it's own and go back to your warm fireplace. All is right with the world...........

How many corpses did you piss on?

If that were any of your business I might answer that.
Now go stoke your fire and calm down. The professionals will handle it........

 

[9thIDdoc]

We have high standards of conduct in our military.

If you want to piss on corpses, renounce your citizenship and join the ******* Taliban or go fight for mercenaries in Africa.

Otherwise, pay the consequences for your actions.

And one of those standards for both civilians and military is the right to be judged by our peers. The last thing America needs is one more idiotic armchair general. Maybe you should move to France; their military is probably already beyond help anyway.

We have civilians who publicly dishonor our flag and spit on our soldiers but believe they know the moral high ground when it comes to killing in a civilized manner. Cute but silly.

 

[Liability]

BTW: I believe that the action of photographing (videoing) the dead bodies of the enemy was a separate violation of a Marine General Order.

So, although I still cannot get overly worked up over the admittedly improper behavior of pissing on the dead body of a Taliban scumbag, I do recognize that the Marines are probably headed for more serious disciplinary actions.

 

[Liability]

* * * *
I said they should be punished according to the law. The law does not allow for people to be punished without conviction. I figure since you're so smart you already knew that. My bad.

Nice effort to extricate yourself from what you wrote. But since it's on record, you fail.

You STARTED off with "punishment."

You don't GET there without a conviction.

So, you remain an objective fail.

Thanks for playing, though.

 

[Cowman]

You will never understand then will you? So leave the military to police it's own and go back to your warm fireplace. All is right with the world...........

How many corpses did you piss on?

If that were any of your business I might answer that.
Now go stoke your fire and calm down. The professionals will handle it........

United States Military professionals don't urinate on corpses.

 

[Cowman]

Nope..........sorry.........Cowman is right........StuntShit is an idiot.

I mean, c'mon Infidel, have I ever lied about being in the military? You as well as many others know that I've served.

******* ***** even called me on it, and decided to skip over salient points before calling me a liar.

Do I sound a bit miffed? Yeah..........because the dumb ******* whore didn't read the whole thing before going on her ***** tirade.

I think the vets here understand you served, ABS. I have many times expressed the wish that we vets here not quarrel with each other over our service. I hate to see that, maybe because I am one of a generation of vets who learned we had to be there for each other, because for quite a few years, there were damned few other people who gave a damn what happened to any of us.

Yeah, and if you all stuck together our fighting men and women would have at least a semblence of support. This thread has made it perfectly clear the extent to which some of our so called retired soldiers sympathize with the enemies of America. I stand my ground that this is a military matter and civilians just need to suck it up. And that includes those who claim to be retired military.

Unless the army decides to publicize names, this will not result in the demise of any future careers. The video to date has only had about 500k views and that doesn't even come close to equating with everyone having seen it. Like everything else, this will fade away, and there will even be plenty out there who do not see them as dirty rotten curs even if their names are publicized. I would likely hire them. My experience with veterans during my time in academia was largely a positive one. Their work ethic, their respect for authority, their empathy with patients is stellar. There was only one exception and that guy didn't give himself enough time to decompress before he took on a difficult course of study. He behaved about like ABS on here only in person, abusing, threatening, etc. No one held it against him in the long run, but he still left the course of study for something else.

Wow... so now you're attacking retired veterans saying that they sympathize with the enemies of America, the enemies that their brethren are currently fighting.

Not wanting them to urinate on corpses has NOTHING to do with sympathy. It has EVERYTHING to do with understanding the need for a professional military who does not engage in such antics.

How disgusting can you get?

Pot meet kettle...





Comic Sans

Oh yes... my wanting social programs for the poor, jobs for the unemployed, food and clothing for the homeless and needy in this country around the world, my desire for a free internet, desire for us to be involved in no wars, my fight for equality for women and minorities and so much more. So shady. So unscrupulous. Humanitarians are dastardly fellows yes?

You are a crock. You stand for nothing. You claim to fight for 'equality for women' but you encounter one who has the type of education a man gets, and all you can do is insult it. You are full of more shit than a bubbly fart!

What are you talking about? In my profession I work with women all the time who have college education. bachelor degrees, master degrees, postgraduate degrees... you name it. So what are you talking about? What you say makes no sense. The type of education a 'man' gets? What does that even mean? You know that women participate in the educational system in this country too right, without having to have any special privileges? Education has no bearing at all in my opinion of a man or a woman unless it's simply something for job qualification which is not my job description.. It's their character that counts. And yours is tarnished.