What if neither monism nor dualism is true, but rather there are three subuniverses, each having a different set/cluster of dimensions? I will call this possibility "trinism".
The three subuniverses would interact because, while they are all quite different, they are all part of a more comprehensive universe.
The physical world would comprise a cluster of structural dimensions, which would be able to change in certain ways. Our brain would be in this structural subuniverse.
Our subjective experience would combine two subuniverses, a perceptual cluster and an action cluster. We don't perceive ourselves acting as clearly as we perceive colors, sounds, etc. However, we feel ourselves acting in a subtle way.
The first cluster would be comprised of subjective quality dimensions, such as colors, meanings, sounds, emotions, and so forth. Similar to the physical dimensions, there would be various ways in which this would change, independent of what we try to do.
The other subuniverse would comprise a cluster of actor/coordinator dimensions, which would cause various parts of the perceptual subuniverse to coordinate with various parts of the physical subuniverse.
Hopefully. I will be able to expand on this in my thinking before I die. I am ill enough that my death could come at any time, but with luck I might be able to get in a little more work on trinism. I doubt that I will be able to get far enough to be able to say if trinism is true or false, however. That will have to be done by others who follow me, if they become interested.
Jim
The three subuniverses would interact because, while they are all quite different, they are all part of a more comprehensive universe.
The physical world would comprise a cluster of structural dimensions, which would be able to change in certain ways. Our brain would be in this structural subuniverse.
Our subjective experience would combine two subuniverses, a perceptual cluster and an action cluster. We don't perceive ourselves acting as clearly as we perceive colors, sounds, etc. However, we feel ourselves acting in a subtle way.
The first cluster would be comprised of subjective quality dimensions, such as colors, meanings, sounds, emotions, and so forth. Similar to the physical dimensions, there would be various ways in which this would change, independent of what we try to do.
The other subuniverse would comprise a cluster of actor/coordinator dimensions, which would cause various parts of the perceptual subuniverse to coordinate with various parts of the physical subuniverse.
Hopefully. I will be able to expand on this in my thinking before I die. I am ill enough that my death could come at any time, but with luck I might be able to get in a little more work on trinism. I doubt that I will be able to get far enough to be able to say if trinism is true or false, however. That will have to be done by others who follow me, if they become interested.
Jim