Well, then answer the goddamn question!!!
I don't know if membership in the church has increased or decreased. I don't care. I'm not discussing that. I'm discussing the spurious and wholly unsupported claim you made.
ONCE AGAIN I will ask you, in the fleeting hope that you might actually be able to answer it intelligently, and not by talking about something which has no bearing on your claim.
AGAIN, you said THIS:
"There’s the claim from the atheist Left that the Catholic Church is dying."
Now, what I would like you to do is show us where/when/by whom this claim you think is coming from the "Atheist left" was made. Where is it??
Let me help you get started:
The sentence "I showed where membership has increased every year in both America and the world" is not an answer to that question. Every time you say that, you only further solidify the belief that no such claim was ever made, and that it's just some figment of your imagination.
If the "Atheist left" has made that claim, show us where, or be labeled a liar. Those are your choices.
And it won't surprise me an iota if, instead of actually responding intelligently, that you put me on ignore. But everyone knows it'll be because you're afraid of being challenged...