The2ndAmendment
Gold Member
If they forced their way into a house without a warrant and without permission, they broke the law.
Would you, if you were on a Jury, convict the Law Enforcement officers of violating the Fourth Amendment (in this scenario)? No. So the point is moot.
The Jury is the ultimate Arbiter of the Constitution, that's why the Jury itself is protected by the Bill of Rights.
Yes I would.
Here's the second problem then.
Someone would actually have to sue the government. Do you think anyone would sue the government under those circumstances?
Do you think the other Jurors would go along with your decision once you were in Court?
Hint: Even I would not support your decision. I even think they (the government) knew about the Boston Bombing attacks before it happened, and decided to LET IT happen, so they could pass more arbitrary liberty stripping bills, yet in this particular scenario, I would not convict the Government.
Last edited: