The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[rylah]

How can you tell? Did you meet him, speak to him? Did you bother to read the article at all? Everything he writes is correct based on what?

What do you expect from Arab supremacists
marching into Jihad under a British invented flag...

 

[Sixties Fan]

I practically know if by heart. You found sanctuary in Palestine when no one else would take you in and then proceeded to demonize and abuse the natives.

The Arabs are not Natives to Palestine, and the abuse was from Colonizing Arabs towards the Indigenous Jews, from everywhere outside Arabia to North Africa.

Change it all you want. European Jews are bad. Nobody wanted them.
(You are confusing when ZIonism started with post Holocaust as most do )

Yes, you devoured that nonsense a Jew hater wrote in 1920, because he did not agree with Jews having the right to their own nation, and believed that the Arabs, not the Jews, had Native calling rights.

And never mind the Native Mizrahi and Sephardic Jews who lived on the land. And all the Jews from Europe and elsewhere who migrated back to their homeland in the previous decades, actually centuries.

Not ONE group of Jews had the right to rebuild their Nation ON their ancient homeland.

If one Brit says it, it must be true.

 

[rylah]

I practically know if by heart. You found sanctuary in Palestine when no one else would take you in and then proceeded to demonize and abuse the natives.

Was it 'giving a sanctuary' when Arabs who can't even pronounce P - alestine,
expelled all the local Jewish communities from their holy cities?

Arabs should thank Israelis for no doing to them
what Arabs would do to other Arabs
in response to that.

 

[surada]

The Arabs are not Natives to Palestine, and the abuse was from Colonizing Arabs towards the Indigenous Jews, from everywhere outside Arabia to North Africa.

Change it all you want. European Jews are bad. Nobody wanted them.
(You are confusing when ZIonism started with post Holocaust as most do )

Yes, you devoured that nonsense a Jew hater wrote in 1920, because he did not agree with Jews having the right to their own nation, and believed that the Arabs, not the Jews, had Native calling rights.

And never mind the Native Mizrahi and Sephardic Jews who lived on the land. And all the Jews from Europe and elsewhere who migrated back to their homeland in the previous decades, actually centuries.

Not ONE group of Jews had the right to rebuild their Nation ON their ancient homeland.

If one Brit says it, it must be true.

Oh yes poor Herzl. What a tragic family. The Jewish population of Palestine was tiny in 1870 according to the Ottoman census... And they didn't bother counting the Bedouin.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Oh yes poor Herzl. What a tragic family. The Jewish population of Palestine was tiny in 1870 according to the Ottoman census... And they didn't bother counting the Bedouin.

You are bulldozing the conversation with this nonsense.

Nothing to do with Herzl's family.
Nothing to do with the number of Jews.

It was about the Right, as the indigenous people of the land, the Jews had to legally acquire the rights to rebuild THEIR nation, ON their ancient homeland.

And many Arab clans were for it. But were defeated by the Al Huseini clan.

A peaceful co existence would have happened, if only those Arab clans had prevailed over the Al Husseinis.

Keep counting sheep, if that makes you happy, but it has never been about numbers.

 

[surada]

Was it 'giving a sanctuary' when Arabs who can't even pronounce P - alestine
expelled all the local Jewish communities from their holy cities?

The Arab Jews left in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973. They weren't exactly expelled... There were some Zionists agitators. Jews were still in Libya in 73. Too bad really. Bad for everyone.

 

[Sixties Fan]

The Arab Jews left in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973. They weren't exactly expelled... There were some Zionists agitators. Jews were still in Libya in 73. Too bad really. Bad for everyone.

There is no such thing as an Arab Jew, unless they were ethically Arabs who converted to Judaism .

And you keep changing the conversation.

Let us go back to WHO is indigenous to the land of Israel/Palestine.

 

[surada]

You are bulldozing the conversation with this nonsense.

Nothing to do with Herzl's family.
Nothing to do with the number of Jews.

It was about the Right, as the indigenous people of the land, the Jews had to legally acquire the rights to rebuild THEIR nation, ON their ancient homeland.

And many Arab clans were for it. But were defeated by the Al Huseini clan.

A peaceful co existence would have happened, if only those Arab clans had prevailed over the Al Husseinis.

Keep counting sheep, if that makes you happy, but it has never been about numbers.

You guys have changed tactics. Now you blame the Mufti instead of Hitler for the Holocaust.

 

[Sixties Fan]

You guys have changed tactics. Now you blame the Mufti instead of Hitler for the Holocaust.

Who the heck is discussing the Holocaust here?

 

[rylah]

The Arab Jews left in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973. They weren't exactly expelled... There were some Zionists agitators. Jews were still in Libya in 73. Too bad really. Bad for everyone.

Those whom Arab supremacists call now 'Arab Jews',
were never enough 'Arab' for them, and they were the ones
who's plight during Arab pogroms initiated the Zionist movement.

Loss to Arab supremacist ambitions,
and a gain for progress of civilization.

 

[surada]

There is no such thing as an Arab Jew, unless they were ethically Arabs who converted to Judaism .

And you keep changing the conversation.

Let us go back to WHO is indigenous to the land of Israel/Palestine.

Lol so now you're an ethnicity?

 

[Sixties Fan]

The Arab Jews left in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973. They weren't exactly expelled... There were some Zionists agitators. Jews were still in Libya in 73. Too bad really. Bad for everyone.

No, some were not expelled. They ran for their lives, as well as they could, in operations especially created to save Jews who did not have how to get out of those Arab conquered lands.

Jews who had lived on those lands longer than any Arab, or the Arab invasion of the 7th Century.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Lol so now you're an ethnicity?

You really know nothing.

You do not know the difference between a Race and an Ethnicity.
You do not know what Jews are.

Wait, you continue to know nothing. How does that happen? Why?

 

[rylah]

Lol so now you're an ethnicity?

And earth is a sphere...

Of course, by definition, an ethnic minority.
Simply shows you know zilch about the subject.

 

[Sixties Fan]

You guys have changed tactics. Now you blame the Mufti instead of Hitler for the Holocaust.

And your definition of tactics is .....?

 

[Roudy]

I practically know if by heart. You found sanctuary in Palestine when no one else would take you in and then proceeded to demonize and abuse the natives.

Hah? Palestine was controlled by the Ottoman Muslims, who invited the Jews back to what they considered as their ancestral and religious homeland, and then then by the Brits, who then agreed to create a Jewish homeland, and then another one called Transjordan for the fake Palestinians who were really Arab nomads and squatters. So nobody “took us in”. Speaking of demonizing, there was a Mufti who was Nazi and on Hitler’s payroll who wanted to do a second Holocaust on the Jews in their religious, cultural and ancestral homeland. He then instigated riots and genocides by demonizing the Jews using Nazi blood libel techniques. Of course your Islaminazi Mufti was also a murderer of Christians in the region, and he did pronounce that once they were done killing all the Saturday people, they would continue with the Sunday people, aka Christians. You really need to stop repeating Islamonazi prpoganda rooted in antisemitism.

 

[Roudy]

Oh yes poor Herzl. What a tragic family. The Jewish population of Palestine was tiny in 1870 according to the Ottoman census... And they didn't bother counting the Bedouin.

I proved to you that Jews enjoyed a majority in Jerusalem during the Ottoman era, and you keep repeating the same lie. The Ottomans weren't necessarily fans of the Arabs until very late since they considered them competition and did fight with them.

 

[Open Bolt]

I practically know if by heart. You found sanctuary in Palestine when no one else would take you in and then proceeded to demonize and abuse the natives.

That is exactly backwards. The only natives of the West Bank area are the Jews.

The Arab Jews left

No such thing.

 

[MartyNYC]

Oh yes poor Herzl. What a tragic family. The Jewish population of Palestine was tiny in 1870 according to the Ottoman census... And they didn't bother counting the Bedouin.

There was no place Palestine in the Ottoman Empire. There were no Palestinians. Jewish population was indigenous.

 

[surada]

There was no place Palestine in the Ottoman Empire. There were no Palestinians. Jewish population was indigenous.

In the 12th century BC it was called P.alashu .

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/05/28/dueling-histories-debate-over-historic-palestine/