Is counter-protesting hate groups an extremist view?
Nope.
Can you be putting yourself in danger by doing so?
Yep.
Is it going to accomplish anything of substance?
Nope.
Would it be better to ignore them, as they deserve?
Yep.
Would all that protesting energy be put to better use by taking someone we disagree with out to lunch and sincerely communicating with them?
Yep.
.
you don't think publicly standing up to Nazis is an effective tool?
hmmmm... i do. it might make them crawl back into their holes where they belong.
and at a minimum it sends a message to those in power that the orange one can't be allowed to legitimize these freaks.
I'm going out with my sign this week. i feel like I'm obligated to and if i don't then I'm complicit.
"All it takes for evil to prevail is for good men to do nothing".
Standing up to them is one thing, confronting them where violence is bound to happen is a whole different ball of wax. If the anti-racists had not shown up the racist rally would have been nothing more than a postscript on the national news, by confronting them it gives them the self validation they're looking for and creates the national attention they crave.
there is always violence when Nazis and their satellites are not around. the protesters did nothing wrong.
a terrorists drove a car into them and killed a young woman who stood up to hate. remember her name, my friend. it was heather hyer. and she was very brave.
the scum defending the Nazis, (not you) are an insult to her memory.
this war was fought already. they don't get better when left to their own devices.
You bring up the young girl who lost her life because some scumbag thought it was a good idea to kill...... To me? Maybe if you read my other posts you'd have not done that. I'm not comparing degrees of violence I'm simply stating that violence should always be condemned no matter who commits it and that by confronting the racists instead of ignoring them gives them national attention and self validation. They're a minority fringe group, treat them as a minority fringe group, don't give them the attention they crave thus marginalizing them even further.
and Wilson, cheney and schwermer were murdered for helping their fellow citizens register to vote.
and countless people were beaten down for marching for civil rights.
civil rights never would have happened if protesters didn't stand up noisily and publicly.
nothing good happens when good people cower in the face of evil. just like my mother's father fought in WWI and was a German POW. Just like my dad put on a uniform and was an MP after the Korean war...just like my uncles all wore uniforms.
sometimes we have to do what we have to do, even if it's standing and showing scum that they're opposed.