Maxdeath
Diamond Member
- Jun 12, 2018
- 7,615
- 6,338
- 2,050
So you are in agreement that not only was it just Japanese there were others. So you are in agreement that anyone that did not agree with the internment would have been labeled as seditionist, treasonist, or worse.I think you missed the fact that Germans and Italians were included. German and Italian organizations were also watched closely.I agree, but we also have to houses of congress that have oversight. We also have a population that is supposed to be over sight of all. So to think that FDR did it without anyones approval is not understanding of the U.S. or people.No but we had people that were upset, scared, mad you name the emotion. He could have tried not to but you have to realize there were probably all kinds of congress people and other heads of government agencies talking about sedition, spies etc.I know you don't really understand the constitution nor history. But if it had only been FDR it would never have been done.What happened during WWII wasn't "the people," it was the scumbag fdr who threw innocent Americans into his concentration camps. Regardless, that really has nothing to do with this topic.While I think that causing anyone unnecessary harm is bad I do not feel that calling out China on its hiding of information on the virus is wrong.
But we could also look back at world war 2 and the way Japanese were rounded up and placed in interment camps. Their property sold off at pennies on the dollar or given away.
When people are scared by the media 24/7 it is not to be unexpected that some will lash out.
What we're talking about here is Chinese Americans (any Asian Americans, really) being assaulted here, and the corrupt, obvious CCP encouraging similar attitudes there.
We are talking about the same hysteria. They are very similar in the fact you are talking humans and human nature
Well, FDR signed it, and he didn't have to.
Look at people that were complaining that Trump had too much power. Now you see those same ones complaining that he did not act with an iron fist and close the borders. That he is not forcing every company to make ventilators and ppe. That he is not stopping all movement in cities, states. In that you see some of the things that were being pushed on FDR.
People tend to act irrationally when they are mad, fearful or any human emotion.
As you know, we have that "thing" called the Constitution that protect minorities from tyranny of majority, and what fascist wannabe FDR did (among many other things) was unconstitutional.
He signed executive order first, without anyone's approval. He wanted it, he signed it, than asked for approval and funding that he get from Democrat ruled Senate and House thru Public Law 503.
The problem with that law was that Republicans had no muscle to fight it, and anyone who would vote against it would be labeled by Democrats as traitor. Who could have guess that would happen? Second, there were two Republicans who fought it despite of threats, Governor Ralph Carr of Colorado and Senator Robert Taft of Ohio. Oh, and FBI director Hoover was against it, because there was no proof for Japanese American disloyalty.
Tell me something, if FDR could do it to Japanese Americans, why he hasn't done it to Italian Americans, or German Americans, with the same premise of national security, and loyalty? The only difference was that Japanese Americans look different, and that would be pure racism. Of course, coming from a party that was always racist... the left, Democrats.
While I have no love for the democrats since the last true democrat died with JFK I think you are attempting to put way too much political spin on things.
As you stated if he or anyone would have refused they would have been labeled as treasonous. But by who? The general populace.
There were significantly fewer Italian and German detainees. The camps weren't officially characterized as "Japanese" camps, they just held almost exclusively Japanese Americans, and very few of other ethnicities. This is primarily because of civilian racism spawned by military suspicions that Japan was gearing up to attack the West Coast. In fact, really only Japanese residents on the West Coast were detained and relocated. The number of Italian Americans and German Americans in internment camps was about 11,000 and unlike Japanese Americans and Aleuts, they did not get reparations, although they did sue for it.
So you are agreeing that congress and the American population obviously agreed with the camps.
So in essence you are agreeing with exactly what I have said.
Thank you.