- Apr 23, 2017
- Reaction score
- New Mexico
There has not been a true communist nation on this planet. A true state of communism is a stateless state...As do socialists and communistsThey did coopt the name but were nothing like socialist, Marxist, etc, they never promised anyone anything for free, you had to work and were required to work...We've explained this to you little children repeatedly, Moon. The nazis were the German SOCIALIST PARTY---its in their name. They rose to power promising free chit and using street thugs to terrorize the citizens while burning down cities too.The Nazis were not socialist nor were they liberals, nor were they communist nor were they Republicans..
Stateless state is a bit idealistic and one could say it was just that it takes more steps to reach.
I prefer to look at the steps themselves to evaluate if they are socialist or Marxist by how collective, cooperative, and communal they are.
And nothing Stalin did was collective, cooperative, or communal.
When you have a distant, central organization take over a farming community by force, that is not collective, cooperative, or communal.
That is uber capitalism.
It is controlled by and benefitting the wealthy elite.
That is the most anti socialist and anti Marxism as one can get.