Sorry, Kirk is, was and always will be the greatest Star Ship captain in the whole history of time.....
You'll get no argument from me, sir. Kirk was always so much over-the-top fun, he could beat up multiple guys at once using bizarre moves that defy Newtonian physics. Remember that episode when the Enterprise was accidentally sent back to the late '60s and it ended up with Kirk in that Air Force base beating up a room full of guys - by being a human bowling ball and launching himself as a physical missile, knocking them over like bowling pins? It would be hard to pick out a funnier Star Trek fight. Or that ep. when the Andorian traitor stabs Kirk and he still manages to bounce himself off the wall to be a "flying leg kick" projectile and knock the Andorian stabber out.