Is the best QB in this NFL Draft Spencer Rattler of the Chickens?

[EMH]

I highly doubt he’ll have to demand it.

The Sam Darnold issue is going to make Malik Willis very rich this offseason, and will open minds about acquiring existing NFL talent as opposed to the Draft, and already two of the top QBs are staying, Duke and USC.

 

[Couchpotato]

The Sam Darnold issue is going to make Malik Willis very rich this offseason, and will open minds about acquiring existing NFL talent as opposed to the Draft, and already two of the top QBs are staying, Duke and USC.

Cool story. What does that have to with Rattler? As terrible as Darnold was early he was way better than Rattler ever was.

 

[EMH]

Cool story. What does that have to with Rattler? As terrible as Darnold was early he was way better than Rattler ever was.

Bullshit. Darnold really was horrible with NYJ.

Rattler has a stronger more accurate arm and a quicker release.

 

[Couchpotato]

Bullshit. Darnold really was horrible with NYJ.

Rattler has a stronger more accurate arm and a quicker release.

You are seriously delusional about Rattler. It's odd. Statistically they were essentially the same though Darnold was a bit better. The biggest difference being that once they left/were benched the person who came in after them had wildly different results.

When Darnold left the team didnt fare any better with his replacement.

Rattler playing the Saints are 1-7, after he's benched for Shough they go 4-6.

Rattler is just not an NFL caliber QB. Just look at the difference between what he's done, and Sanders did this year in CLE.

 

[EMH]

Statistically

ALL of "your" analysis is STAT PARROTING...

You don't seem to notice strong arm vs weak arm etc.

 

[Couchpotato]

ALL of "your" analysis is STAT PARROTING...

You don't seem to notice strong arm vs weak arm etc.

And you make no analysis.

Sam Darnold is alot of things. Weak armed isnt one of them.

 

[EMH]

And you make no analysis.

Sam Darnold is alot of things. Weak armed isnt one of them.

Sam doesn't have a weak arm but it is hardly a "rocket" arm, and he has a big wind up and a slow release. Sam needs a quality supporting cast. He's had that in MN and SEA the past two years.

 

[Couchpotato]

Sam doesn't have a weak arm but it is hardly a "rocket" arm, and he has a big wind up and a slow release. Sam needs a quality supporting cast. He's had that in MN and SEA the past two years.

TS won again. It apparently wasn’t the roster or the coaching in NO it was the guy under center….. “The best QB in his draft class”.

 

[EMH]

TS won again

There you go, the QB won, the team had nothing to do with it... nice...

Tyler is better than I expected, but he will never be an elite QB talent.

 

[EMH]

LOL!!!

Analysis: Should the Saints explore the idea of trading QB Spencer Rattler this offseason?

Spencer Rattler impressed many in his audition as a starting quarterback for the Saints in 2025. Could that make him a potential trade candidate?

www.nola.com

Saints May Not Trade QB Spencer Rattler After All

The New Orleans Saints had a heated quarterback battle between Spencer Rattler and rookie Tyler Shough last offseason. After the longest quarterback battle in t

www.si.com

 

[Couchpotato]

LOL!!!

Analysis: Should the Saints explore the idea of trading QB Spencer Rattler this offseason?

Spencer Rattler impressed many in his audition as a starting quarterback for the Saints in 2025. Could that make him a potential trade candidate?

www.nola.com

Saints May Not Trade QB Spencer Rattler After All

The New Orleans Saints had a heated quarterback battle between Spencer Rattler and rookie Tyler Shough last offseason. After the longest quarterback battle in t

www.si.com

So Rattler is worth a 3rd day draft pick or they can keep him as a cheap back up on a shitty team. Sounds like the best QB in his draft class to me……

 

[EMH]

So Rattler is worth a 3rd day draft pick or they can keep him as a cheap back up on a shitty team. Sounds like the best QB in his draft class to me……

LOL!!!

That's not actually the trade yet, that's the babble.

NFL teams are desperate for QBs and the Draft has one answer for the Raiders and that's pretty much it.

NO would/will get more, much more, than a Saturday pick for Rattler.

 

[Couchpotato]

EMH

LOL!!!

That's not actually the trade yet, that's the babble.

NFL teams are desperate for QBs and the Draft has one answer for the Raiders and that's pretty much it.

NO would/will get more, much more, than a Saturday pick for Rattler.

Will it be more or less than you'd have to ship to New England, Washington, Chicago, or Denver to get their QB's? You know because Rattler was the best QB in that bunch....

 

[EMH]

EMH


Will it be more or less than you'd have to ship to New England, Washington, Chicago, or Denver to get their QB's? You know because Rattler was the best QB in that bunch....

Washington and Denver QBs have real issues.

The second half of the season saw a lot of gloss come off Drake Maye, who clearly made a big jump.

Caleb Williams looks like the best right now after 2 years. Last year it was Daniels. End of Year 3....


We'll see...

 

[Failzero]

Raiders should trade the # 1 Pick straight across for Lamar ( it’s the Raider Way )

 

[Couchpotato]

Washington and Denver QBs have real issues.

The second half of the season saw a lot of gloss come off Drake Maye, who clearly made a big jump.

Caleb Williams looks like the best right now after 2 years. Last year it was Daniels. End of Year 3....


We'll see...

Rattler cant buy a win in the regular season, was benched for a rookie and you still wont admit he's not as good as QB's who are entrenched starters, have wins in the post season, one going to the SB and a vote away from being named league MVP.

DELU LU

 

[Couchpotato]

Raiders should trade the # 1 Pick straight across for Lamar ( it’s the Raider Way )

Why would Baltimore do that? They could get multiple 1st for him.

 

[EMH]

Rattler cant buy a win in the regular season,

A win is a team thing. That's why Troy Aikman started out 0-11 or something like that. Good thing Jimmy Johnson paid attention to what Aikman actually looked like on the field instead of parroting stats...

Spencer Rattler is no lower than #3 in this offseason at the position behind only Mendoza and Willis.

and Pavia is QB2 in this Draft.

 

[Couchpotato]

A win is a team thing. That's why Troy Aikman started out 0-11 or something like that. Good thing Jimmy Johnson paid attention to what Aikman actually looked like on the field instead of parroting stats...

Spencer Rattler is no lower than #3 in this offseason at the position behind only Mendoza and Willis.

and Pavia is QB2 in this Draft.

 

[Failzero]

Why would Baltimore do that? They could get multiple 1st for him.

That is your opinion , like some think the Raiders could get multiple 1st for Maxx Crosby