Carrie Underwood or Bo Bice?

[-Cp]

Which one do you think was the most deserving on the recent "American Idol"?

 

[Mr. P]

Which one do you think was the most deserving on the recent "American Idol"?

Both are fantastic, but Carrie carries that country singing twang into almost every song.
I thought Bo was much more versatile. For that reason I thought he should have won.

But hey, they both won we know that.

 

[no1tovote4]

Carrie is much better looking IMO, I enjoy looking at her. Therefore I think she should have won.

 

[Mr. P]

Carrie is much better looking IMO, I enjoy looking at her. Therefore I think she should have won.

She's a FOX (do they still use that term?). But Bo energized the stage every time he walked on,
no one else did that.

 

[5stringJeff]

Carrie is much better looking IMO, I enjoy looking at her. Therefore I think she should have won.

My reasoning exactly!

 

[Jimmyeatworld]

For me personally, Bo sings the kind of music I'm more apt to listen to, and he's damn good at it. But I liked Carrie too, and for those stretchs I lean toward country music she would fit the bill nicely. There was no wrong choice this time around.

 

[Adam's Apple]

Bo had a much better stage presence and seemed to be more comfortable on stage. He also took a lot of chances to exhibit his talent that Carrie did not take. His performance with Led Zeppelin was outstanding. He seemed like he had been performing with them forever. I usually like country music much better than rock, but this time I thought Bo's talent was greater than Carrie's. I am sure he will be another Clay Aiken and do just fine in the music business.

 

[Mr. P]

Bo had a much better stage presence and seemed to be more comfortable on stage. He also took a lot of chances to exhibit his talent that Carrie did not take. His performance with Led Zeppelin was outstanding. He seemed like he had been performing with them forever. I usually like country music much better than rock, but this time I thought Bo's talent was greater than Carrie's. I am sure he will be another Clay Aiken and do just fine in the music business.

I think both of them will rock the charts...

 

[JOKER96BRAVO]

I think both of them will rock the charts...

Carrie can rock my...uh I mean, ya..what Mr P said.

 

[Shattered]

Definitely Bo.. Carrie's so...'typical', and very predictable. Bo had an awesome range of abilities...

(And he's hot to boot!)

 

[Mr. P]

(And he's hot to boot!)

All us Southern boys er HOT!

 

[Shattered]

All us Southern boys er HOT!

Rumor and speculation - no actual proof.

 

[Mr. P]

Rumor and speculation - no actual proof.

Well, that cuz you just haven't been ahhhhhh, lucky!

 

[Shattered]

Well, that cuz you just haven't been ahhhhhh, lucky!

**pats head**

Down, boy!

 

[-Cp]

Bo had a much better stage presence and seemed to be more comfortable on stage. He also took a lot of chances to exhibit his talent that Carrie did not take. His performance with Led Zeppelin was outstanding. He seemed like he had been performing with them forever. I usually like country music much better than rock, but this time I thought Bo's talent was greater than Carrie's. I am sure he will be another Clay Aiken and do just fine in the music business.

Bo didn't sing w/ Led Zeppelin...

 

[Adam's Apple]

Bo didn't sing w/ Led Zeppelin...

I know he didn't sing with Led Zeppelin. I'm not a rock fan, so I can't keep all those rock band's names straight. I threw one out there and knew someone would correct me. Anyway, I can't spell Lynard Skynard. :

 

[maryjstar89]

I really liked Carrie Underwood in that season of AI.