What in the world do you libs mean by proportional basis? In pre-leftist times, it meant the more state a population has, the greater it’s representation in the House. - and we do have that.
PLEASE tell me you don’t mean “proportional” in some artificial way - like 14% are black, so 14% of Congress should be black. Then we are determining slots based in skin color, and that is a racist policy.
What do I mean?
Proportional Representation means one person, one vote, more or less.
Germany has a system whereby everyone votes. Then they take all the votes and dish out the seats accordingly. They do have a 5% cut off, if you get less than 5% you don't get seats. Denmark does it with a 2% cut off.
In the US each seat is contested independently of each other.
Take the Presidential election. The state to vote the most for Trump was California. All the Trump voters in California got NO SAY in the election, because Democrats won easily. They got all the EC votes, regardless of what other people wanted.
In the UK (also with FPTP), one seat in South Belfast was won with less than 25% of the votes. So, 75% of the people said "We don't want this guy to represent us" and he still got in because he got more votes than anyone else.
Proportional isn't based on anything other than choice.
If the US had Proportional Representation with a 2% cut of there'd be at least 10 political parties. That means when you go to vote you have REAL CHOICE of who to represent you.
What do the Republicans stand for? Not much because they need to get 50% of the votes (except where they cheat with gerrymandering). In Germany you have clearly defined parties. Traditional left, traditional right (equivalent to Reps and Dems I guess) and then center right, further right, green left, more socialist left, etc. Proper choice.
I'll compare the UK to Germany here, in the early 1990s a further right (anti-EU) political party called UKIP was formed. By 2015 they managed to get 12.6% of the vote. And one seat. One. Out of 600 something seats. But they got like 1/8th of the votes.
In Germany a party in 2012 or 2013 was formed, further right, called the AfD. They got 12.6% of the vote in 2017. The same percentage, only it took them 5 years and not 25 years to get there. The speed is important, because people felt the system would listen to them, in the UK with FPTP they knew it wouldn't.
The AfD got 90 seats. Not one. They got what the people wanted, they got to represent 12.6% of the voters (well a little more because of those parties who got cut out, below 5%). In the UK the system told voters to ef off.