Arab commentator: When the state of Israel was established, there was no state called palestine—It did not exist.

[Sunni Man]

The author is a renowned scholar. You’re a renowned donkey.

You post like a small child. I'm done fooling with you. Bye ..

 

[Lee Edwin]

The author is a renowned scholar. You’re a renowned donkey.

You post like a small child. I'm done fooling with you. Bye ..

I don’t need to make a jackass out of you—You do such an excellent job! LMAO!

 

[Sunsettommy]

Palestine is a European name, not Middle Eastern. No place palestine has ever actually existed.

You zionist Juden get all hung up on the name of the land.
There was obviously Arab people who had lived on the land for many centuries.
What name you label them with isn't really a big deal. ...

He is correct, it was originally from Greece describing the land by name as shown in Wikipedia:

History of the name

Modern archaeology has identified 12 ancient inscriptions from Egyptian and Assyrian records recording likely cognates of Hebrew Pelesheth. The term "Peleset" (transliterated from hieroglyphs as P-r-s-t) is found in five inscriptions referring to a neighboring people or land starting from c. 1150 BCE during the Twentieth dynasty of Egypt. The first known mention is at the temple at Medinet Habu which refers to the Peleset among those who fought with Egypt in Ramesses III's reign,[1][2] and the last known is 300 years later on Padiiset's Statue. Seven known Assyrian inscriptions refer to the region of "Palashtu" or "Pilistu", beginning with Adad-nirari III in the Nimrud Slab in c. 800 BCE through to a treaty made by Esarhaddon more than a century later.[3][4] Neither the Egyptian nor the Assyrian sources provided clear regional boundaries for the term.Palestine (region) - Wikipedia

The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BCE Ancient Greece,[7][8] when Herodotus wrote of a "district of Syria, called Palaistinê" (Ancient Greek: Συρίη ἡ Παλαιστίνη καλεομένη)[9] in The Histories, which included the Judean mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley.[10][ii] Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition for the region in Meteorology, in which he included the Dead Sea.[12] Later Greek writers such as Polemon and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region, which was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder, Dio Chrysostom, Statius, Plutarch as well as Roman Judean writers Philo of Alexandria and Josephus.

LINK

 

[rylah]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

In other words before the State of Israel was established there was no state called Israel either..

And yet international law
defines it re-constitution.

 

[rylah]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

 

[rylah]

Where do you find these arab nut cases? ... ..

I tell ya,
those nut case Arabs who dare to admit facts...

 

[rylah]

Romans called the country Judea, signifying land of the Jews.

But after the failed Bar Kochba rebellion of the Jews in 132 CE.
The Roman's kicked all jews out of the land and renamed it Philistia, which later was anglicized into Palestine. ....

And after Arabs expelled Jews from all their holy cities
in the sanjak of Jerusalem in the mid 19th century, Jews returned a favor.

Romans had to send reinforcements from the Britain frontier to overpower sovereign Jews,
Arabs couldn't handle with all their forces at place against a bunch of former dhimmis.

 

[rylah]

Palestine is a European name, not Middle Eastern. No place palestine has ever actually existed.

You zionist Juden get all hung up on the name of the land.
There was obviously Arab people who had lived on the land for many centuries.
What name you label them with isn't really a big deal. ...

Well, you should ask Arabs why they hang on
to a name they can't even pronounce...

 

[rylah]

You‘re a total moron—I get it.
Israelites were indigenous to Israel...

It's a good sign when you call me names. it verifies you're losing the debate. ...
Nope... the Israeli's were not indigenous to the land.
The Torah says they invaded and attacked the people living there and killed them all. ...

Not exactly.

Cana'anites and Philistines were invaders,
the Torah says Israelites recovered the land of the Hebrews.

 

[Lee Edwin]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

maybe we should report it to a mod???

Feel free to.

My responses are perfectly on topic. Yours? Not so much.

It makes NO DIFFERENCE whether a "nation" called "Palestine" ever existed.

The people did and do and people are more important than splitting rhetorical hairs.

The Jewish Nation lived there. No palestine nation existed.

 

[rylah]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

So fact.

 

[rylah]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

And its like the six thousand times a day that the fictional "historic Palestine",
is intentionally repeated implying there was such an Arab country.

What is the intent in falsifying facts?

 

[rylah]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

The people lived in many other places...

View attachment 430948

Which means WHAT exactly? That they don't fit within neat geographical boundaries? Hate to break it to you, neither do Jews.

It means that it takes only being a Jew to have national association with the land,
as for Arabs it takes moving their residence, the opposite of indigeneity.

 

[rylah]

You‘re a total moron—I get it.
Israelites were indigenous to Israel...

It's a good sign when you call me names. it verifies you're losing the debate. ...
Nope... the Israeli's were not indigenous to the land.
The Torah says they invaded and attacked the people living there and killed them all. ...

Israelites were indigenous. Pin this on your pointy little head ⤵

View attachment 430949

There are many native peoples, possibly indigenous, to that region. What's your point?

Imagine, in 100 years a confederation of Native American tribes
decided to regain independence in their tribal lands.

And Elizabeth Warren went:
"look there're many native peoples..."

It's just something you say,
but really have no other indigenous civilization to contest Israel.

 

[Ben Thomson]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

Who wrote that??..let me guess..the Jews..

 

[Lee Edwin]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

Who wrote that??..let me guess..the Jews..

Abdullah al-Hadlaq is a Jew? Or, you’re a moron.

'There is no Palestine, no occupation,' says Kuwaiti writer

A Kuwaiti writer sparked outrage after claiming there is no such thing as Palestine, or an occupying entity and that Israelis are "a people returning to their promised land'.

english.alaraby.co.uk

 

[Lee Edwin]

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

The people lived in many other places...

View attachment 430948

Which means WHAT exactly? That they don't fit within neat geographical boundaries? Hate to break it to you, neither do Jews.

It means that it takes only being a Jew to have national association with the land,
as for Arabs it takes moving their residence, the opposite of indigeneity.

Indigeneity is a big word for this messageboard!

 

[Ben Thomson]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

Who wrote that??..let me guess..the Jews..

Abdullah al-Hadlaq is a Jew? Or, you’re a moron.

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

maybe we should report it to a mod???

Feel free to.

My responses are perfectly on topic. Yours? Not so much.

It makes NO DIFFERENCE whether a "nation" called "Palestine" ever existed.

The people did and do and people are more important than splitting rhetorical hairs.

The Jewish Nation lived there. No palestine nation existed.

Who keeps making this assertion that they constituted a 'nation' thousands of years ago? The Palestinians of today are decendants of a people that lived in that region going back as far as the jews. Before Abraham there were no Jews, Muslims or Christians. There were all 'one people' living in that land.

 

[Lee Edwin]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

Who wrote that??..let me guess..the Jews..

Abdullah al-Hadlaq is a Jew? Or, you’re a moron.

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

maybe we should report it to a mod???

Feel free to.

My responses are perfectly on topic. Yours? Not so much.

It makes NO DIFFERENCE whether a "nation" called "Palestine" ever existed.

The people did and do and people are more important than splitting rhetorical hairs.

The Jewish Nation lived there. No palestine nation existed.

Who keeps making this assertion that they constituted a 'nation' thousands of years ago? The Palestinians of today are decendants of a people that lived in that region going back as far as the jews. Before Abraham there were no Jews, Muslims or Christians. There were all 'one people' living in that land.

Ancient people of palestine, birdbrain?

 

[Ben Thomson]

You see any place named palestine on this administrative map of the Ottoman Empire, or did Ottoman Muslims obliterate it?

I sure don't see any place named Israel on the map. ...

Wear glasses...


Sahara Yahudin - The Jewish Desert

صحراء يهودا

The Judaean Desert or Judean Desert (Hebrew: Midbar Yehuda, both Desert of Judah or Judaean Desert; Arabic:‎ Sahara Yahudin صحراء يهودا ) is a desert in Israel and the West Bank that lies east of Jerusalem and descends to the Dead Sea. It stretches from the northeastern Negev to the east of Beit El, and is marked by natural terraces with escarpments. It ends in a steep escarpment dropping to the Dead Sea and the Jordan Valley. The Judaean Desert is crossed by numerous wadis from northeast to southeast and has many ravines, most of them deep, from 1,200 feet in the west to 600 feet in the east. The Judaean Desert is an area with a special morphological structure along the east of the Judaean Mountains.

Judaean Desert - Wikipedia

Who wrote that??..let me guess..the Jews..

Abdullah al-Hadlaq is a Jew? Or, you’re a moron.

Arab commentator: “When the State of Israel was established, there was no state called ‘palestine.’ Where did we get that name? It did not exist.”

So what?

such a thought provoking response,,, its almost like youre trolling,,

No. It's almost like this is the six thousandth thread on this. Wait, scratch the almost...it is.

What difference does it make, unless you are trying to erase the people who live there.

maybe we should report it to a mod???

Feel free to.

My responses are perfectly on topic. Yours? Not so much.

It makes NO DIFFERENCE whether a "nation" called "Palestine" ever existed.

The people did and do and people are more important than splitting rhetorical hairs.

The Jewish Nation lived there. No palestine nation existed.

Who keeps making this assertion that they constituted a 'nation' thousands of years ago? The Palestinians of today are decendants of a people that lived in that region going back as far as the jews. Before Abraham there were no Jews, Muslims or Christians. There were all 'one people' living in that land.

Ancient people of palestine, birdbrain?

View attachment 431557

' The genetic profile of Palestinians has, for the first time, been studied by using human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene variability and haplotypes. The comparison with other Mediterranean populations by using neighbor-joining dendrograms and correspondence analyses reveal that Palestinians are genetically very close to Jews and other Middle East populations, including Turks (Anatolians), Lebanese, Egyptians, Armenians, and Iranians. Archaeologic and genetic data support that both Jews and Palestinians came from the ancient Canaanites, who extensively mixed with Egyptians, Mesopotamian, and Anatolian peoples in ancient times. Thus, Palestinian-Jewish rivalry is based in cultural and religious, but not in genetic, differences'...The origin of Palestinians and their genetic relatedness with other Mediterranean populations - PubMed