Roudy
Diamond Member
- Mar 16, 2012
- 63,167
- 20,332
- 2,250
Except there hasn't been a thing called Palestinian land or Palestinian people. Nice try though.Ashkenazi Jews are Jews who migrated east after the destruction of the Temple, Mizrahi, Sephardic and other Jews such as Persians are those that traveled West. Jews have managed to live and survive in diaspora for thousands of years.Again, goofball, Jews can't be Africaners since the land has been Jewish religious, spiritual, and cultural holy land for over 3000 years, and they've always kept a presence. Those that came after, the Romans, Crusaders, Arabs, and Ottomans, are the invaders.THat's in the history section of this forum. NOT in this thread. In all those other threads -- you're welcome to knock yourself rethinking what the BRITISH had in mind for their piece of the Ottoman Empire. Zionists were much quicker to FORM GOVERNMENTS and BUILD INFRASTRUCTURE and they were a Colonial Landlord's dream tenents. While the Palis never ever seemed to see any value in that type of effort. Their lack of Leadership and organization is the reason why they are "just an indigenous people" today -- instead of a nation.
Not doing that in this thread. It's been done in hundred of other forum pages.
So you think you can have a discussion about whether or not anti Zionism is anti semtism without coming to agreement about what you're talking about?
If some one like Roudy sees Jews as indigenous and I see them no different as Afrikaners were not even talking about the same thing.
What you want is people debate this question in the context that suits your view. That doesn't make any sense.
I'll ask you again, who are the "Jews"?
Because Ashkenazi Jews have not existed for 3,000 years. And Ashkenazi Jews have no ties to Palestine beyond their cultish beliefs
Jews are a race, religion, and an ethnicity.
Practicing endogamy may make you a separate "race" from "normal" Europeans. But that doesn't entitle you to Palestinian land. Or even mean you're not European
And again you have no ability to trace your line to Palestine. YOu've lived as a minority for the better part of two millenia. You have no blood claim to palestine because you have no palestinian blood
Again your faith and belief does not matter. Me believing I'm a Jew doesn't give me a claim to Palestinian land. Nor does it you. lol