The suburbs did not push the GOP over the top in 2016.It seems to be the case in PennsylvaniaIt seems the GOP is losing the suburbs that pushed them over the top in 2016
Rural votes did.
View attachment 288445
Donald Trump won narrowly in Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin. He won by getting rural voters and enough suburban voters. That coalition was shattered in 2018 as suburban voters went with Democrats in 2018. In 2019, the Virginia GOP again saw a massive defection of suburban voters and suburban voters in Kentucky split their ballots between a Republican for AG and a Democrat for Governor. The rural areas are dying while the suburban areas are growing.