oreo
Gold Member
- Thread starter
- #121
Don't think of the GOP as a party for only lock-step "conservatives". Bush/Cheney proved that there are no "pure conservative administrations". Even Reagan was not a "pure conservative". The toughest conservative "principle" to keep is "fiscal restraint". The GOP congress tried to use "rescission?" to limit Obama's spending, which hurt the Defense department. Other than fiscal restraint, I'm not aware of any other principles that are currently being sacrificed.
Oh, I disagree. MOST of life is compromise.
And Trump has shown no fiscal restraint.
So let's look at the other concepts being sacrificed.
Free markets- When you admit you can't compete with foreign goods and want tariffs, that's an abandonment of free markets.
Libertarian principles? Sorry, that went out the window when Trump started throwing kids into concentration camps?
Family values? Um, right, when you support a guy who fucks porn stars and has cheated on all three of his wives and has a creepy obsession with his daughter, "Family Values" have gone right out the window.
Strong National Defense? Well, he's alienated NATO, alienated South Korea, sucked up to North Korea and Russia.
New principles that are better than the old principles: fair trade, not free trade. This new principle is better for the US economy than the globalist view.
So the new "populist" GOP stands for "America first" and prosperity for all.
Not really. You see, America was all for free trade when we produced the best products in the world the rest of the world wanted to buy. Then we were all for "Free Trade".
If left to their druthers, American consumers would rather buy cheap Chinese made stuff now, or want to buy German or Japanese cars because they are of better quality.
Now, I give Reagan some credit, he's the one who held Japan's feet to the fire on "Dumping" (selling goods in America at minimal profits to drive American competitors out of business)...
"Fair Trade" is subjective. The only "Fair" Trade is one both sides agrees to.
Continuing with the discussion of "conservative principles lost" under the Trump admin:
Free markets- When you admit you can't compete with foreign goods and want tariffs, that's an abandonment of free markets.
When the globalists gave tax breaks to move US factories overseas, and Obama said those jobs aren't coming back, and the US trade deficit was $500b a year and rising, its time for Trump to use the largest economy in the world to advantage. As the globalists fuel China's military buildup, including theft of intellectual property, they will realize too late that the US has become a second rate power. Then its too late.
Libertarian principles? Sorry, that went out the window when Trump started throwing kids into concentration camps?
I've been a repub a long time and don't recall any "libertarian principles", just conservative ones. When 4 out of 5 illegal kids apprehended are unaccompanied, you can't blame Trump for lavishing care on them while being held, blame the parents that sent them north. The care being given to them is 1000x better than the living conditions in their home country. Please lookup the definition of a "concentration camp".
Family values? Um, right, when you support a guy who fucks porn stars and has cheated on all three of his wives and has a creepy obsession with his daughter, "Family Values" have gone right out the window.
Have you seen regular TV lately? There are no more family values, especially for politicians. You're either a church goer or not, but its not a requirement. As the pope said, "who are we to judge"? i.e. scratch family values from your GOP set of principles. Trump was a very sexually active guy, so what, his wife is cool with it?
Strong National Defense? Well, he's alienated NATO, alienated South Korea, sucked up to North Korea and Russia.
Trump kept this principle to the point of sacrificing fiscal restraint. The Defense Budget is $717b in 2018 up from $524b in 2016. NATO is not alienated, they were told that the US is not continuing the free ride, they need to meet their obligations. Trump is right to demand that they pony up. Also, Germany has an agreement to buy gas from Russia which gives them needed cash. Bloomberg - Are you a robot?
Free Trade- America was all for free trade when we produced the best products in the world the rest of the world wanted to buy. Then we were all for "Free Trade".
Not sure when the US was a net manufacturing exporter, the 1950's?? Currently the US has a massive $500b trade deficit, which Trump is addressing by requiring "fair trade", and fair trade is what the voters want, since it means more good paying jobs.
Tariffs- American consumers would rather buy cheap Chinese made stuff, or buy German or Japanese cars because they are of better quality.
Not disagreeing with that claim, however, as Trump adds tariffs that levels the playing field. Foreign cars is the "mother-lode" for tariffs and no country wants tariffs on their cars, so we'll see how that plays out. Trump and the US has all the cards in this game, save for some farm subsidies. Populist tariffs for good jobs is a GOP win, not loss.
Now, I give Reagan some credit, he's the one who held Japan's feet to the fire on "Dumping" (selling goods in America at minimal profits to drive American competitors out of business)..."Fair Trade" is subjective. The only "Fair" Trade is one both sides agrees to
Agreed. Trump did the same anti-dumping tariffs on steel and aluminum. US union workers can't be more supportive, fair trade is as negotiated, such as with Mexico and Canada. We're still working on China. Bottom line: the US is no longer the trade chump of the world.
Looking at the new GOP "populist" principles:
Trade- fair trade as negotiated is a net positive for the US, free trade is a net negative unless its fair.
Family values- are encouraged, but no being judgmental. Pro-life is supported
Strong defense- supported
Fiscal restraint- encouraged, but not a requirement, supporting a strong economy is paramount
Enforce immigration laws-
Jobs- do whatever is necessary to develop and sustain well paying jobs
Strong foreign policy- fight terrorism, keep Russia at bay via sanctions, keep NK at bay with sanctions, manage China, manage the EU, etc.
Law & Justice- approve conservative judges and justices, keep the DOJ, IRS, and FBI from becoming arms of the democratic party, like under Obama
Energy & Environment- develop clean domestic energy sources, and avoid financial commitments like the Paris Climate Agreement
Healthcare- End Obamacare's high deductibles that prevents families from accessing healthcare
Infrastructure- need to see how the dems approach, may need to increase taxes to fund
Don't think of the GOP as a party for only lock-step "conservatives". Bush/Cheney proved that there are no "pure conservative administrations". Even Reagan was not a "pure conservative". The toughest conservative "principle" to keep is "fiscal restraint". The GOP congress tried to use "rescission?" to limit Obama's spending, which hurt the Defense department. Other than fiscal restraint, I'm not aware of any other principles that are currently being sacrificed.
Oh, I disagree. MOST of life is compromise.
And Trump has shown no fiscal restraint.
So let's look at the other concepts being sacrificed.
Free markets- When you admit you can't compete with foreign goods and want tariffs, that's an abandonment of free markets.
Libertarian principles? Sorry, that went out the window when Trump started throwing kids into concentration camps?
Family values? Um, right, when you support a guy who fucks porn stars and has cheated on all three of his wives and has a creepy obsession with his daughter, "Family Values" have gone right out the window.
Strong National Defense? Well, he's alienated NATO, alienated South Korea, sucked up to North Korea and Russia.
New principles that are better than the old principles: fair trade, not free trade. This new principle is better for the US economy than the globalist view.
So the new "populist" GOP stands for "America first" and prosperity for all.
Not really. You see, America was all for free trade when we produced the best products in the world the rest of the world wanted to buy. Then we were all for "Free Trade".
If left to their druthers, American consumers would rather buy cheap Chinese made stuff now, or want to buy German or Japanese cars because they are of better quality.
Now, I give Reagan some credit, he's the one who held Japan's feet to the fire on "Dumping" (selling goods in America at minimal profits to drive American competitors out of business)...
"Fair Trade" is subjective. The only "Fair" Trade is one both sides agrees to.
Continuing with the discussion of "conservative principles lost" under the Trump admin:
Free markets- When you admit you can't compete with foreign goods and want tariffs, that's an abandonment of free markets.
When the globalists gave tax breaks to move US factories overseas, and Obama said those jobs aren't coming back, and the US trade deficit was $500b a year and rising, its time for Trump to use the largest economy in the world to advantage. As the globalists fuel China's military buildup, including theft of intellectual property, they will realize too late that the US has become a second rate power. Then its too late.
Libertarian principles? Sorry, that went out the window when Trump started throwing kids into concentration camps?
I've been a repub a long time and don't recall any "libertarian principles", just conservative ones. When 4 out of 5 illegal kids apprehended are unaccompanied, you can't blame Trump for lavishing care on them while being held, blame the parents that sent them north. The care being given to them is 1000x better than the living conditions in their home country. Please lookup the definition of a "concentration camp".
Family values? Um, right, when you support a guy who fucks porn stars and has cheated on all three of his wives and has a creepy obsession with his daughter, "Family Values" have gone right out the window.
Have you seen regular TV lately? There are no more family values, especially for politicians. You're either a church goer or not, but its not a requirement. As the pope said, "who are we to judge"? i.e. scratch family values from your GOP set of principles. Trump was a very sexually active guy, so what, his wife is cool with it?
Strong National Defense? Well, he's alienated NATO, alienated South Korea, sucked up to North Korea and Russia.
Trump kept this principle to the point of sacrificing fiscal restraint. The Defense Budget is $717b in 2018 up from $524b in 2016. NATO is not alienated, they were told that the US is not continuing the free ride, they need to meet their obligations. Trump is right to demand that they pony up. Also, Germany has an agreement to buy gas from Russia which gives them needed cash. Bloomberg - Are you a robot?
Free Trade- America was all for free trade when we produced the best products in the world the rest of the world wanted to buy. Then we were all for "Free Trade".
Not sure when the US was a net manufacturing exporter, the 1950's?? Currently the US has a massive $500b trade deficit, which Trump is addressing by requiring "fair trade", and fair trade is what the voters want, since it means more good paying jobs.
Tariffs- American consumers would rather buy cheap Chinese made stuff, or buy German or Japanese cars because they are of better quality.
Not disagreeing with that claim, however, as Trump adds tariffs that levels the playing field. Foreign cars is the "mother-lode" for tariffs and no country wants tariffs on their cars, so we'll see how that plays out. Trump and the US has all the cards in this game, save for some farm subsidies. Populist tariffs for good jobs is a GOP win, not loss.
Now, I give Reagan some credit, he's the one who held Japan's feet to the fire on "Dumping" (selling goods in America at minimal profits to drive American competitors out of business)..."Fair Trade" is subjective. The only "Fair" Trade is one both sides agrees to
Agreed. Trump did the same anti-dumping tariffs on steel and aluminum. US union workers can't be more supportive, fair trade is as negotiated, such as with Mexico and Canada. We're still working on China. Bottom line: the US is no longer the trade chump of the world.
Looking at the new GOP "populist" principles:
Trade- fair trade as negotiated is a net positive for the US, free trade is a net negative unless its fair.
Family values- are encouraged, but no being judgmental. Pro-life is supported
Strong defense- supported
Fiscal restraint- encouraged, but not a requirement, supporting a strong economy is paramount
Enforce immigration laws-
Jobs- do whatever is necessary to develop and sustain well paying jobs
Strong foreign policy- fight terrorism, keep Russia at bay via sanctions, keep NK at bay with sanctions, manage China, manage the EU, etc.
Law & Justice- approve conservative judges and justices, keep the DOJ, IRS, and FBI from becoming arms of the democratic party, like under Obama
Energy & Environment- develop clean domestic energy sources, and avoid financial commitments like the Paris Climate Agreement
Healthcare- End Obamacare's high deductibles that prevents families from accessing healthcare
Infrastructure- need to see how the dems approach, may need to increase taxes to fund
You bring up some very good points. 86% of Evangelicals voted for Donald Trump. Basically in one fatal swipe, they burned down the Republican party's "family value platform" and obliterated the credibility of Evangelical churchs all across this country.
We had white male pastors all over this country promoting Donald Trump--telling their congregations--"you don't need to like him, just vote for him." And they did-- even after listening to the Hollywood access tape.
Even after Stormy Daniels and the playboy bunny payoff's they're still defending Trump.
Bill Graham jr., Mike Huckabee and others are still on the Trump train.
Last edited: