Why does the Left hate Jews?

[Pogo]

"National Review"

lol

That the best you've got as an excuse for nothing to say?

Uh --- you want "nothing to say", check your own OP.

 

[IcebergSlim]

"National Review"

lol

And Kevin Williamson to boot.....

Meet Schnatzie.....she is entirely undiscriminating in her choice of sources....

 

[IcebergSlim]

Left hand? Left turns? Could you try to elaborate what left is and where?

Opposite to right. Duh.

Ah an intellectual eh?

You don't want to discuss anything, I take it?

You're trolling.

Have you ever been sanctioned for trolling, Liebling?

 

[dani67]

In the light of what us happening in the UK Labour Party.

Why the Left Hates Jews, by Kevin D. Williamson, National Review

hate israel or hate zionist isnt hate jew.
for example.most amercian moslem love berni sanders.but they hate zionist and israel

 

[Syriusly]

Ah so Mindful is part of the camp that labels any criticism of Israel as being the 'Left hate the Jews".

While I support the right of Israel to exist- and even to exist as a Jewish homeland- that doesn't mean that I can't criticize actions of Israel I disagree with, and that run against the interests of the United States.

Nor does it mean I have to ignore the legitimate rights of the non-Jewish residents of Israel and Palestine.

Neither the Jews or Muslims in Israel and Palestine are going anywhere- they both have a legitimate right to be there- they both need to find a resolution to their conflict.

 

[Mindful]

Ah so Mindful is part of the camp that labels any criticism of Israel as being the 'Left hate the Jews".

While I support the right of Israel to exist- and even to exist as a Jewish homeland- that doesn't mean that I can't criticize actions of Israel I disagree with, and that run against the interests of the United States.

Nor does it mean I have to ignore the legitimate rights of the non-Jewish residents of Israel and Palestine.

Neither the Jews or Muslims in Israel and Palestine are going anywhere- they both have a legitimate right to be there- they both need to find a resolution to their conflict.

That lame duck argument has been done to death.

Criticism is not the same as demonisation.

 

[Phoenall]

They just want jews out of their group, so they are offending them on purpose. They couldnt care less about palestine.

Much deeper than that as the majority of Jews wont convert out of their religion. So they wont become neo Marxists or muslims, making them a danger to full world domination. If they cant be changed then they become an oasis for others and defeat the bloodless coup. So they make up LIES, BLOOD LIBELS and PROPAGANDA to smooth the way for the next holocaust

 

[Mindful]

They just want jews out of their group, so they are offending them on purpose. They couldnt care less about palestine.

Much deeper than that as the majority of Jews wont convert out of their religion. So they wont become neo Marxists or muslims, making them a danger to full world domination. If they cant be changed then they become an oasis for others and defeat the bloodless coup. So they make up LIES, BLOOD LIBELS and PROPAGANDA to smooth the way for the next holocaust

There were the usual stock phrases in reaction to Jew topics being regurgitated over and over again, ad nauseum.

I should have known better.

 

[there4eyeM]

"Why does the left hate the Jews?"
Probably for the same reason as the 'right'; i.e., no good reason.

 

[Phoenall]

They just want jews out of their group, so they are offending them on purpose. They couldnt care less about palestine.

Much deeper than that as the majority of Jews wont convert out of their religion. So they wont become neo Marxists or muslims, making them a danger to full world domination. If they cant be changed then they become an oasis for others and defeat the bloodless coup. So they make up LIES, BLOOD LIBELS and PROPAGANDA to smooth the way for the next holocaust

 

[Phoenall]

They just want jews out of their group, so they are offending them on purpose. They couldnt care less about palestine.

Who does? The Left?

They just want jews out of their group, so they are offending them on purpose. They couldnt care less about palestine.

Who does? The Left?

Yes, the Left. Apparently a large group of gentiles in British Labour want them out.

Not quite a large group of socialists of the old school want the neo Marxist of a Jewish background out. People like Ed Miliband who would sell the UK down the river if it meant he got a penny more.

 

[Phoenall]

I'm as left as they come and I don't hate Jews. I know MANY Jewish liberals.

That's what they all say.

Left in the USA is nothing like the Left in the UK and Europe.

Then maybe you should be posting this nonsense on a European forum.

Apparently the British Labour Party has a large faction of jew haters right now. Its not global but it also would not be unique.

They hate the religious Jews yes, but welcome the non religious Jews like prodigal sons

 

[Phoenall]

In the light of what us happening in the UK Labour Party.

Why the Left Hates Jews, by Kevin D. Williamson, National Review

Considering that most Jews in the United States are what would be called 'the Left'- why do you imagine that the Left hates the Jews?

The American left is what the rest of the world calls right leaning centrist. Your witch hunts under Mcarthy saw to that

 

[Tommy Tainant]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

 

[Mindful]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

What kept you? Trotting out the usual party line script.

If there's no anti semitism in the Labour Party, as Diane Abbott keeps parroting out, why is there going to be an enquiry?

Jeremy Corbyn terrifies? Surely you jest. Just look at the sight of him. A surly petulant relic from a bygone age.

He should be put out to pasture with the the other two. Livingstone and Galloway.

 

[Tommy Tainant]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

What kept you? Trotting out the usual party line script.

If there's no anti semitism in the Labour Party, as Diane Abbott keeps parroting out, why is there going to be an enquiry?

Jeremy Corbyn terrifies? Surely you jest. Just look at the sight of him. A surly petulant relic from a bygone age.

He should be put out to pasture with the the other two. Livingstone and Galloway.

I think that they are terrified of negative press reaction.

The enquiry will find that there is no basis to the allegation and recommend that party spokesman follow a specific line when talking about Israel/Palestine relations.

I would also suggest that bringing Hitler into the conversation, in any form, is not going to advance the discussion.

What cant be allowed to happen is that genuine concerns about Israeli government actions are shouted down under the guise of something else.

I realise that I will be called anti Semitic for stating that. I give it 5 posts at most.

What is your view Mindful ? I have no idea what your opinion is and yet you started the thread.

 

[Mindful]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

What kept you? Trotting out the usual party line script.

If there's no anti semitism in the Labour Party, as Diane Abbott keeps parroting out, why is there going to be an enquiry?

Jeremy Corbyn terrifies? Surely you jest. Just look at the sight of him. A surly petulant relic from a bygone age.

He should be put out to pasture with the the other two. Livingstone and Galloway.

I think that they are terrified of negative press reaction.

The enquiry will find that there is no basis to the allegation and recommend that party spokesman follow a specific line when talking about Israel/Palestine relations.

I would also suggest that bringing Hitler into the conversation, in any form, is not going to advance the discussion.

What cant be allowed to happen is that genuine concerns about Israeli government actions are shouted down under the guise of something else.

I realise that I will be called anti Semitic for stating that. I give it 5 posts at most.

What is your view Mindful ? I have no idea what your opinion is and yet you started the thread.

I learnt long ago to not attempt a "normal" discussion with types like you.

But it's obvious anti-semitism is dressed up as anti-Zionism, to be used as a Trojan Horse for Jew hatred.

"Oh, I've nothing against Jews" lol. Why would you have? Why should you have?

 

[Tommy Tainant]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

What kept you? Trotting out the usual party line script.

If there's no anti semitism in the Labour Party, as Diane Abbott keeps parroting out, why is there going to be an enquiry?

Jeremy Corbyn terrifies? Surely you jest. Just look at the sight of him. A surly petulant relic from a bygone age.

He should be put out to pasture with the the other two. Livingstone and Galloway.

I think that they are terrified of negative press reaction.

The enquiry will find that there is no basis to the allegation and recommend that party spokesman follow a specific line when talking about Israel/Palestine relations.

I would also suggest that bringing Hitler into the conversation, in any form, is not going to advance the discussion.

What cant be allowed to happen is that genuine concerns about Israeli government actions are shouted down under the guise of something else.

I realise that I will be called anti Semitic for stating that. I give it 5 posts at most.

What is your view Mindful ? I have no idea what your opinion is and yet you started the thread.

I learnt long ago to not attempt a "normal" discussion with types like you.

But it's obvious anti-semitism is dressed up as anti-Zionism, to be used as a Trojan Horse for Jew hatred.

"Oh, I've nothing against Jews" lol. Why would you have? Why should you have?

Hopefully somebody will translate that for me at some point.

 

[Mindful]

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

The background to all of this is the current political situation in the UK.

The ruling Tory party is in a mess. They are split over Europe. Cameron is a lame duck PM and his cabinet colleagues are ripping themselves up in a jostle for the throne.
The Chancellor just had a big part of his budget ripped up. The health service is in revolt with Doctors on strike for the first time in a generation.
The plan to privatise all our schools is falling apart with even their own MPs speaking against it.
Cheap Chinese steel is killing our own industry but the Tories are so far in thrall to Beijing that they opposed short term protection from the EU to our own industry.
The Hillsborough inquest has just returned a damning verdict on the tories pin up Thatcher and her campaign of lies.
Its an absolute mess.

Obviously there needs to be a story for our right wing media to focus on.

Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments - BBC News

And there you go. There is no anti semitism in the Labour Party. Im not a member and never have been but it is absurd to suggest that there is a problem. The "problem" is Jeremy Corbyn who terrifies those on the right as well as the right wing of his own party. He has to be stopped at all costs.

What kept you? Trotting out the usual party line script.

If there's no anti semitism in the Labour Party, as Diane Abbott keeps parroting out, why is there going to be an enquiry?

Jeremy Corbyn terrifies? Surely you jest. Just look at the sight of him. A surly petulant relic from a bygone age.

He should be put out to pasture with the the other two. Livingstone and Galloway.

I think that they are terrified of negative press reaction.

The enquiry will find that there is no basis to the allegation and recommend that party spokesman follow a specific line when talking about Israel/Palestine relations.

I would also suggest that bringing Hitler into the conversation, in any form, is not going to advance the discussion.

What cant be allowed to happen is that genuine concerns about Israeli government actions are shouted down under the guise of something else.

I realise that I will be called anti Semitic for stating that. I give it 5 posts at most.

What is your view Mindful ? I have no idea what your opinion is and yet you started the thread.

I learnt long ago to not attempt a "normal" discussion with types like you.

But it's obvious anti-semitism is dressed up as anti-Zionism, to be used as a Trojan Horse for Jew hatred.

"Oh, I've nothing against Jews" lol. Why would you have? Why should you have?

Hopefully somebody will translate that for me at some point.

 

[Syriusly]

Ah so Mindful is part of the camp that labels any criticism of Israel as being the 'Left hate the Jews".

While I support the right of Israel to exist- and even to exist as a Jewish homeland- that doesn't mean that I can't criticize actions of Israel I disagree with, and that run against the interests of the United States.

Nor does it mean I have to ignore the legitimate rights of the non-Jewish residents of Israel and Palestine.

Neither the Jews or Muslims in Israel and Palestine are going anywhere- they both have a legitimate right to be there- they both need to find a resolution to their conflict.

That lame duck argument has been done to death.

Criticism is not the same as demonisation.

The 'left hates the jews' idiocy has been done to death but it sure doesn't stop you from posting that crap again.

You are the one who started the crap with your demonization of the left as hating Jews- so once again:

Ah so Mindful is part of the camp that labels any criticism of Israel as being the 'Left hate the Jews".

While I support the right of Israel to exist- and even to exist as a Jewish homeland- that doesn't mean that I can't criticize actions of Israel I disagree with, and that run against the interests of the United States.

Nor does it mean I have to ignore the legitimate rights of the non-Jewish residents of Israel and Palestine.

Neither the Jews or Muslims in Israel and Palestine are going anywhere- they both have a legitimate right to be there- they both need to find a resolution to their conflict.