MMA guys take fighting to a different level than boxers. We all saw James Tony get embarrassed. Even though he was way past his prime, he was still one of the best pure boxers in the heavy weight/light heavy weight division of all time.
I wouldnt put the idea to bed based on Toney's performance...that would be ridiculous.
He was old, punchy and came into it INCREDIBLY out of shape.
A half dozen world class heavyweights in their Prime ...fighting in MMA... would settle it. It could go either way...but a boxers hands are slick and dangerous.
For littler guys...MMA has a clean advantage over boxing because there's less knockout power in general across the division.
Floyd Mayweather isnt knocking anyone out, for example...he hits like a girl and his hands always break. His last k.o. was hitting a man who was paused with his hands down, not counting Conor's loss due to exhaustion
randy Coture was old too. In general these guys in MMA are better fighters. We’re now at a point where MMA and boxers are in terrific shape, so that doesn’t matter. The boxers are susceptible to take down moves, and don’t know what to do when they’re on the ground,
Part 2 of that is true, but take down/grappling defense is rather journeyman that anyone coordinated has little issue with
thats why chuck liddel rarely didnt have a fist fight
boxers are creatures of habit. They’re not used to defending shin kicks, takedowns and submissions. The MMA guys have more in their arsenal, both of us can agree on that, and they’re just as tough as boxers these days, in general.
The creature of habit thing is kind of a charicature, and sorta implies that in a 12 to 17wk training camp...any man, let alone just a boxer...wouldn't have the wherewithall to switch a fighting strategy. Thats not true, man...I can tell you from experience it doesnt even take 1 whole sparring session of a different discipline to convert your brain to being fully engaged in the new set of rules, for moves.
Id say...skillset advantage goes to the MMA guy but the tactical striking of an MMA guy with his hands, particularly, is no place close to a boxer of similar status in his respective field. Thats what makes the cross over interesting...the overall skillset is advantageous to the MMA folks and the footwork and hand strikes of the boxers would be advantageous.
Not to mention...I wouldnt count some boxers out on the mats, either...because most of the elite ones are freak athletes in general.
Its probably like...boxers in their prime vs. mma in their prime....mma wins 30 outta 50 or something like that