PoliticalChic
Diamond Member
Especially to the young?
Why are the young so enamored with Socialism/Communism/Liberalism?
It may not be what seems to be the answer, free stuff.
The Answer may be something inherent to the human condition: a desire to be unique, and independent, and to make your own rules, and not have to answer to anyone else.
1.When Albert Camus wrote âThe Rebel,â he put his finger on an aspect of human nature that most of us have, more so as youth, but, still, throughout our lives. We yearn to stand out, to be different, âŚwe see it when the prettiest girl runs off with the âbad boy,â or when the wild haired radical is the one everyone is talking about. True, family, and the desire for success often smooths the edges off, moderates how âdifferentâ one chooses to be, and sometimes, later on, when weâve given up most of that rebellion, we might come to resent those who actually carry it offâŚ..but in our youth, we have it.
Itâs all about the degree and desire to rebel.
2. Freud claimed he could document and explain that need to rebel, relating it to a biological phenomenonâŚ. âThe Rebel Instinct: How Each Generation's Need To Out-Rebel The Previous Generation Is Pushing Society To Wild Extremesâ The Rebel Instinct: How Each Generation's Need To Out-Rebel The Previous Generation Is Pushing Society To Wild Extremes
But whether it is psychological or biologicalâŚâŚ.it appears, most significantly, to be political.
3. A tip of the hat to Freud: there is no disputing the desire to stop taking orders from parents. OK. But it grows, in many, to the desire to not have to show respect, take orders from, or to mirror the style and tradition of an older, more successful generation. Perhaps the claim that socialists/communists are all about greed, to take from the successful without the work that went into that success...âYou didnât build that!â âŚisnât just to get the material thingsâŚ
........itâs the psychological reward of rebellion.
Perhaps the rebel wants to gain that success by a different path, one that doesnât require looking like, sounding like, and behaving like, our elders, that explains the 50% of Democrats who are socialists. Enter Bernie Sanders, stage Left.
NowâŚ..get this, the fly in their ointment:
The problem for those rebels is that they have given up the intellect and the education that reveals what Socialism, Communism, Progressivism produces for societies, always:
....serfs, slavesâŚ.or corpses.
Why are the young so enamored with Socialism/Communism/Liberalism?
It may not be what seems to be the answer, free stuff.
The Answer may be something inherent to the human condition: a desire to be unique, and independent, and to make your own rules, and not have to answer to anyone else.
1.When Albert Camus wrote âThe Rebel,â he put his finger on an aspect of human nature that most of us have, more so as youth, but, still, throughout our lives. We yearn to stand out, to be different, âŚwe see it when the prettiest girl runs off with the âbad boy,â or when the wild haired radical is the one everyone is talking about. True, family, and the desire for success often smooths the edges off, moderates how âdifferentâ one chooses to be, and sometimes, later on, when weâve given up most of that rebellion, we might come to resent those who actually carry it offâŚ..but in our youth, we have it.
Itâs all about the degree and desire to rebel.
2. Freud claimed he could document and explain that need to rebel, relating it to a biological phenomenonâŚ. âThe Rebel Instinct: How Each Generation's Need To Out-Rebel The Previous Generation Is Pushing Society To Wild Extremesâ The Rebel Instinct: How Each Generation's Need To Out-Rebel The Previous Generation Is Pushing Society To Wild Extremes
But whether it is psychological or biologicalâŚâŚ.it appears, most significantly, to be political.
3. A tip of the hat to Freud: there is no disputing the desire to stop taking orders from parents. OK. But it grows, in many, to the desire to not have to show respect, take orders from, or to mirror the style and tradition of an older, more successful generation. Perhaps the claim that socialists/communists are all about greed, to take from the successful without the work that went into that success...âYou didnât build that!â âŚisnât just to get the material thingsâŚ
........itâs the psychological reward of rebellion.
Perhaps the rebel wants to gain that success by a different path, one that doesnât require looking like, sounding like, and behaving like, our elders, that explains the 50% of Democrats who are socialists. Enter Bernie Sanders, stage Left.
NowâŚ..get this, the fly in their ointment:
The problem for those rebels is that they have given up the intellect and the education that reveals what Socialism, Communism, Progressivism produces for societies, always:
....serfs, slavesâŚ.or corpses.