Was Trump Right About Pulse Club and CCW Guns ?

protectionist

Diamond Member
Oct 20, 2013
58,626
19,345
2,250
Donald Trump said that if there had been people carrying guns in the Pulse Club, when Omar Matten went on his rampage, they could have stopped him. This was criticized widely by people (especially Democrats) saying that by Florida law it is illegal to carry guns inside bars/nightclubs.

1. This criticism is FALSE. Florida Statute 790.06 (12)(a)12 does say that a license issued under this section does not authorize any person to openly carry a handgun or carry a concealed weapon or firearm into a bar, HOWEVER, it also stipulates that this only applies to that portion of establishment which is where alcoholic beverages are being served. It does not apply to other places within the establishment not within or through the bar area. So you can sit at a dinner table, and legally have your gun in your pocket, as long as you have your CCW license with you.

F.S. 790.06

Jon H. Gutmacher, FLORIDA FIREARMS Law, Use & Ownership, 6th edition, Page 68.

2. If you are an official of the bar (owner, employee, security guard) you are entitled to have a gun there by Statute 790.25(3)(n)

F.S. 790.25

Some Trump critics have said that there was an off-duty cop present and that he traded gunfire with Mateen, and claimed this as a criticism that an armed person being present would not have helped. I saw one such bash in the Huffington Post which mentioned an alleged off-duty cop shooting his gun, but a source link was given to an LA Times article, which contained no mention of any off-duty cop, or anyone shooting a gun other than Mateen.

Just for the hell of it though, let's hypothetically imagine that the Huffington Post article and its LA Time link was true. I would say so what ? There are numerous instances wherin an armed person DID shoot back at a terrorist, and was successful at stopping the terrorist.

Here's 3 examples:

1. On July 2 2002, an Egyptian terrorist Ahmed Mohammed Hadayet, attacked an Israeli El Al ticket counter in Los Angeles Airport. He was carrying 2 handguns with 200 bullets on him. The airport was filled with people. Hadayet shot and killed 3 people and wounded a few others. He was shot dead by a security guard, right on the spot.

2. On September 24, 2014, at Vaughan Foods, in Moore, Oklahoma, a Muslim terrorist beheaded a woman, and was attacking a 2nd woman when he was shot and stopped by an employee of that company, Chief Operating Officer Mark Vaughan.

3. On May 3, 2015, at the Curtis Culwell Center in Garland, Texas, 2 ISIS terrorists were shot by a cop working security there and stopped. They were not killed initially but were killed (cut to pieces) by the Garland Police SWAT team that arrived after the security cop stopped the terrorists.
 
Of course Trump was right, these libtard gun grabbing Nazis dont even know what an assault weapon is.

What is disgraceful are the GOP sell outs that give in and treat the moron press seriously when they cant get what an assault weapon is correctly.

journalists-guide-to-firearms-identification_zps79h3hlmq.jpg
 
2 policemen had guns inside the establishment and a gunfight of sorts did take place from what I saw on the news... this is why the gunman retreated to one of the bathrooms.

AND Mr. Trump retracted or ''clarified'' what he said on people having guns in Pulse, and said he meant security and police.... NOT the customers drinking alcohol.... guess he didn't know about the police inside who had guns?
 
2 policemen had guns inside the establishment and a gunfight of sorts did take place from what I saw on the news... this is why the gunman retreated to one of the bathrooms.

AND Mr. Trump retracted or ''clarified'' what he said on people having guns in Pulse, and said he meant security and police.... NOT the customers drinking alcohol.... guess he didn't know about the police inside who had guns?
The only time I heard anything about anyone other than Mateen, having a gun inside, was the Huffington Post article which referred to an LA Times article, which came up empty. So far, no evidence of anyone having a gun inside other than Mateen, including in your post here now.

As for what Trump said before or after is neither here nor there. Fact is, as I described in the OP, it is legal to have guns in a bar by both bar officials or customers (if customers are away from the bar). In addition, the 3 examples I gave (and it could have been 33), show that Trump was right both in his comments, both before and after.
 
"Was Trump Right About Pulse Club and CCW Guns ?"

No.

In fact, the notion is nonsense.

And given Florida law, it’s likely illegal to carry concealed in such a venue.

The law notwithstanding, the notion is idiocy because training for a carry license in no manner addresses a situation which occurred at the Pulse nightclub.

Citizens have the right to carry a concealed firearm pursuant to the right of self-defense, not to act in the capacity of ‘law enforcement.’

Indeed, the idea of an armed citizen ‘saving the day’ by ‘dispatching’ the bad gay is a pathetic, baseless fantasy.
 
"Was Trump Right About Pulse Club and CCW Guns ?"

No. In fact, the notion is nonsense. And given Florida law, it’s likely illegal to carry concealed in such a venue. The law notwithstanding, the notion is idiocy because training for a carry license in no manner addresses a situation which occurred at the Pulse nightclub.

Citizens have the right to carry a concealed firearm pursuant to the right of self-defense, not to act in the capacity of ‘law enforcement.’ Indeed, the idea of an armed citizen ‘saving the day’ by ‘dispatching’ the bad gay is a pathetic, baseless fantasy.
This whole moronic post was 100% PROVEN WRONG by the OP. Dumbest post of the month.
 
Donald Trump said that if there had been people carrying guns in the Pulse Club, when Omar Matten went on his rampage, they could have stopped him. This was criticized widely by people (especially Democrats) saying that by Florida law it is illegal to carry guns inside bars/nightclubs.

1. This criticism is FALSE. Florida Statute 790.06 (12)(a)12 does say that a license issued under this section does not authorize any person to openly carry a handgun or carry a concealed weapon or firearm into a bar, HOWEVER, it also stipulates that this only applies to that portion of establishment which is where alcoholic beverages are being served. It does not apply to other places within the establishment not within or through the bar area. So you can sit at a dinner table, and legally have your gun in your pocket, as long as you have your CCW license with you.

F.S. 790.06

Jon H. Gutmacher, FLORIDA FIREARMS Law, Use & Ownership, 6th edition, Page 68.

2. If you are an official of the bar (owner, employee, security guard) you are entitled to have a gun there by Statute 790.25(3)(n)

F.S. 790.25

Some Trump critics have said that there was an off-duty cop present and that he traded gunfire with Mateen, and claimed this as a criticism that an armed person being present would not have helped. I saw one such bash in the Huffington Post which mentioned an alleged off-duty cop shooting his gun, but a source link was given to an LA Times article, which contained no mention of any off-duty cop, or anyone shooting a gun other than Mateen.

Just for the hell of it though, let's hypothetically imagine that the Huffington Post article and its LA Time link was true. I would say so what ? There are numerous instances wherin an armed person DID shoot back at a terrorist, and was successful at stopping the terrorist.

Here's 3 examples:

1. On July 2 2002, an Egyptian terrorist Ahmed Mohammed Hadayet, attacked an Israeli El Al ticket counter in Los Angeles Airport. He was carrying 2 handguns with 200 bullets on him. The airport was filled with people. Hadayet shot and killed 3 people and wounded a few others. He was shot dead by a security guard, right on the spot.

2. On September 24, 2014, at Vaughan Foods, in Moore, Oklahoma, a Muslim terrorist beheaded a woman, and was attacking a 2nd woman when he was shot and stopped by an employee of that company, Chief Operating Officer Mark Vaughan.

3. On May 3, 2015, at the Curtis Culwell Center in Garland, Texas, 2 ISIS terrorists were shot by a cop working security there and stopped. They were not killed initially but were killed (cut to pieces) by the Garland Police SWAT team that arrived after the security cop stopped the terrorists.

2am in a loud and crowded bar. Most everyone drunk and/or high. Off duty cop was out gunned and couldn't stop him. Wasted armed individuals would probably just load the place with friendly fire casualties. If they got the original shooter they might be shooting each other long after since you can't tell a good armed guy from a bad. Even the NRA said it was a dumb thing to suggest.
 
2 policemen had guns inside the establishment and a gunfight of sorts did take place from what I saw on the news... this is why the gunman retreated to one of the bathrooms.

AND Mr. Trump retracted or ''clarified'' what he said on people having guns in Pulse, and said he meant security and police.... NOT the customers drinking alcohol.... guess he didn't know about the police inside who had guns?
The only time I heard anything about anyone other than Mateen, having a gun inside, was the Huffington Post article which referred to an LA Times article, which came up empty. So far, no evidence of anyone having a gun inside other than Mateen, including in your post here now.

As for what Trump said before or after is neither here nor there. Fact is, as I described in the OP, it is legal to have guns in a bar by both bar officials or customers (if customers are away from the bar). In addition, the 3 examples I gave (and it could have been 33), show that Trump was right both in his comments, both before and after.


Around 2:02 a.m. ET: An officer working extra duty in uniform at the club hears gunshots and engages the shooter. The officer feels he is outgunned, retreats from the club, and calls for assistance. Two SWAT officers in a nearby patrol car are among units that respond and a gunbattle ensues.
 
Of course Trump was right, these libtard gun grabbing Nazis dont even know what an assault weapon is.

What is disgraceful are the GOP sell outs that give in and treat the moron press seriously when they cant get what an assault weapon is correctly.

journalists-guide-to-firearms-identification_zps79h3hlmq.jpg

Call the gun what you want, it killed 49 and injured over 50 in just a few minutes. It is a mass killing weapon, and that is what matters.
 
"Was Trump Right About Pulse Club and CCW Guns ?"
No.
In fact, the notion is nonsense.
And given Florida law, it’s likely illegal to carry concealed in such a venue.
Obviously, you aren't familiar with FL law.
Unless there was sign at the door, you can carry so long as you aren't at the bar.

The law notwithstanding, the notion is idiocy because training for a carry license in no manner addresses a situation which occurred at the Pulse nightclub.
Meaningless nonsense; it supposes that only people specially trained to deal with a situation like this can effectively respond to the Orlando attack.
 
Last edited:
2 policemen had guns inside the establishment and a gunfight of sorts did take place from what I saw on the news... this is why the gunman retreated to one of the bathrooms.

AND Mr. Trump retracted or ''clarified'' what he said on people having guns in Pulse, and said he meant security and police.... NOT the customers drinking alcohol.... guess he didn't know about the police inside who had guns?


Again.....40 stats allow people to carry gun where they serve alcohol.........if a restaruant servves beer how does that keep people from getting drunk while carrying agun.....


And Virginia passed a law last year allowing concealed carry in bars...and the bar crime rate went down 5.9%.......

You are wrong...again.
 
Of course Trump was right, these libtard gun grabbing Nazis dont even know what an assault weapon is.

What is disgraceful are the GOP sell outs that give in and treat the moron press seriously when they cant get what an assault weapon is correctly.

journalists-guide-to-firearms-identification_zps79h3hlmq.jpg

Call the gun what you want, it killed 49 and injured over 50 in just a few minutes. It is a mass killing weapon, and that is what matters.


And the Virginia Tech shooter murdered 32 people with a pistol....the weapon doesn't matter....the target area being a gun free zone matters.......
 
2 policemen had guns inside the establishment and a gunfight of sorts did take place from what I saw on the news... this is why the gunman retreated to one of the bathrooms.

AND Mr. Trump retracted or ''clarified'' what he said on people having guns in Pulse, and said he meant security and police.... NOT the customers drinking alcohol.... guess he didn't know about the police inside who had guns?


Again.....40 stats allow people to carry gun where they serve alcohol.........if a restaruant servves beer how does that keep people from getting drunk while carrying agun.....


And Virginia passed a law last year allowing concealed carry in bars...and the bar crime rate went down 5.9%.......

You are wrong...again.

Dave Sobelman to FOX6 News: “Some idiot felt the need to bring a gun into my restaurant & shot himself”
 
Of course Trump was right, these libtard gun grabbing Nazis dont even know what an assault weapon is.

What is disgraceful are the GOP sell outs that give in and treat the moron press seriously when they cant get what an assault weapon is correctly.

journalists-guide-to-firearms-identification_zps79h3hlmq.jpg

Call the gun what you want, it killed 49 and injured over 50 in just a few minutes. It is a mass killing weapon, and that is what matters.


And the Virginia Tech shooter murdered 32 people with a pistol....the weapon doesn't matter....the target area being a gun free zone matters.......

High capacity magazines.
 
2am in a loud and crowded bar. Most everyone drunk and/or high. Off duty cop was out gunned and couldn't stop him. Wasted armed individuals would probably just load the place with friendly fire casualties. If they got the original shooter they might be shooting each other long after since you can't tell a good armed guy from a bad. Even the NRA said it was a dumb thing to suggest.
What the NRA said was dumb to suggest was drinking people being armed. But that's not the suggestion. The suggestion is employees and non-drinking customers being armed. I sense some people aren't reading the OP. If they are, then they're dumber than a box of rocks.
 
Around 2:02 a.m. ET: An officer working extra duty in uniform at the club hears gunshots and engages the shooter. The officer feels he is outgunned, retreats from the club, and calls for assistance. Two SWAT officers in a nearby patrol car are among units that respond and a gunbattle ensues.
Would you mind telling us what you're talking about, and how it, in any way, relates to the OP/thread ?
 
Call the gun what you want, it killed 49 and injured over 50 in just a few minutes. It is a mass killing weapon, and that is what matters.
It could also be a "mass killing weapon" in cases of self-defense.
 

Forum List

Back
Top