You keep throwing around terms like “useless paper pushing” without providing a single tangible example or explaining which roles are supposedly worthless. You say these jobs “destroy value,” yet you give no evidence. At least own up to the fact that you have nothing but a vague guess based on your personal distaste for the public sector.
You act like it’s somehow self-evident that every government job can be eliminated and magically replaced by “real jobs” in the private sector. It’s not. People in these roles, from administrative clerks to safety inspectors to transportation planners, facilitate everything from small business loans to infrastructure maintenance. That’s not “output destroying.”
You keep downplaying the ripple effect of firing government employees, telling them to “tighten their belts.” Well, guess what happens when their paychecks stop? They quit buying from local stores, going to restaurants, or paying for home improvements. That economic activity vanishes, and private businesses get hurt. Fewer customers, less revenue, and eventually cutbacks or closures. It’s not rocket science: removing salaries from entire groups of workers drags down the surrounding economy.
Then you say “reducing government borrowing isn’t taking dollars out of the economy.” Actually, when the government spends less, the private sector gets fewer dollars overall. This isn’t about moral judgments on “borrowing”; it’s about basic arithmetic. When public employees lose jobs, the flow of money they once spent in your beloved private sector stops. That is literally money exiting the economy, to the detriment of local businesses.
Government employment, when done sensibly, provides services the private sector either can’t or won’t deliver without massive costs passed on to everyone else. And if you really want to see “output,” take a good, hard look at the countless ways government workers keep the broader economy functional every single day. Without the infrastructure these government workers are building and maintaining, there would be no modern market or capitalism.