I’m on the fence here, my view is evolving because this is such a complex issue and it is viewed not as a medical issue but a moral one, assigning all kinds of moral failings on transgender people, attacking their rights to exist and be themselves in the public sphere with out persecution.
Where I am on youth is evolving.
People who are truly transgender are a tiny minority, and the difficulty seems to be figuring out who really is that minority. The Hippocratic oath says to do no harm.
Any treatment has a risk for bad side effects. I am not sure how much solid research on youth has been done with long term follow up on these affects. So maybe, hitting a pause there is what is needed but it needs to be driven by the medical community, not politicians unless in conjunction with the medical community.
I oppose surgery for those under 18.
I also oppose discontinuing treatment for those already under treatment, and are improving, because unless is their choice or you can show evidence that is doing harm, that is cruelty to the child.
I oppose banning or restricting these treatments for adults. Passing laws restricting insurance from covering hormone treatments for adults is just being cruel.
I support allowing social transition, including pronouns and names. If it is a fad, it will pass. Passing laws forbidding it is simple cruelty. It harms no one and further isolates the child.
Ultimately though, decisions must be made by the child, parents, and medical community in line with best practices guidelines. And those guidelines for youth seem to be changing, at least in other countries. I suspect they will change here.
On women’s sports, I’ve already stated that I oppose transgender women competing against biological women.
On bathrooms and locker rooms, simple solution…repeatedly ignored. Add a unisex/family bathroom.
If a trans woman looks like a woman and has fully transitioned...she is hardly “swinging her dick” around in front of everyone and forcing her to to use the men’s room puts her at the same risk as any other woman.