Vietnam War was unwinnable

RetiredGySgt

Diamond Member
Joined
May 6, 2007
Messages
47,156
Reaction score
9,092
Points
2,040
Location
North Carolina
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
both have KOREA in their names
So what two DIFFERENT Countries. You amaze me at just HOW FUCKING STUPID you are.
 
OP
harmonica

harmonica

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2017
Messages
28,990
Reaction score
5,846
Points
290
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
anyway--I've provided much evidence--you provide babble......
.....Vietnam unwinnable and we certainly did not want an unlimited war with China--that would've been disastrous for the US
 
OP
harmonica

harmonica

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2017
Messages
28,990
Reaction score
5,846
Points
290
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
both have KOREA in their names
So what two DIFFERENT Countries. You amaze me at just HOW FUCKING STUPID you are.
..I keep providing more evidence and you don't like it...''stop engaging harmonica'''waaaaa waaaaaaa .....I'm providing MORE proof and you cry
 

RetiredGySgt

Diamond Member
Joined
May 6, 2007
Messages
47,156
Reaction score
9,092
Points
2,040
Location
North Carolina
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
anyway--I've provided much evidence--you provide babble......
.....Vietnam unwinnable and we certainly did not want an unlimited war with China--that would've been disastrous for the US
You do not even read your own links which usually disprove what ever you linked to prove. We won In Vietnam and we won In Korea. By 68 there was no insurgency left in South Vietnam and it fell in 75 NOT to an uprising or insurgency but to an INVASION of 25 North Vietnamese Divisions.
 
OP
harmonica

harmonica

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2017
Messages
28,990
Reaction score
5,846
Points
290
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
anyway--I've provided much evidence--you provide babble......
.....Vietnam unwinnable and we certainly did not want an unlimited war with China--that would've been disastrous for the US
You do not even read your own links which usually disprove what ever you linked to prove. We won In Vietnam and we won In Korea. By 68 there was no insurgency left in South Vietnam and it fell in 75 NOT to an uprising or insurgency but to an INVASION of 25 North Vietnamese Divisions.
..doesn't matter if we LOST to an insurgency or or an uprising or the NVA --we still lost --as stated--we couldn't stay there forever and the North knew that.
.....and as it states in the same book, and as I've stated many times--the North didn't have to win--just not lose ..it's real easy not to lose
....
 
OP
harmonica

harmonica

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2017
Messages
28,990
Reaction score
5,846
Points
290
very respected Gen. Bradley on MacArthur's plans for the Korean War and escalating it:
page 218 Anatomy of Victory
MacArthur's plan would ''involve the country in the wrong war at the wrong place at the wrong time'''''
..same with Nam
Are you pretending that Gen. Bradley's opinion is fact? What exactly did he have to say about either Vietnam?
....his quote was on Korea---which you people said we should start a massive war with China-you are geniuses
You quoted his opinion; not fact.
And history says that China started a war with us when it launched an unprovoked surprise attack against our troops. WTF is "you people"?
how little history you know
..the US helped the nationalists in their civil war......then the US had troops near their border = threatening China = akin to Russian missiles in Cuba
...you people want a major war with China---500 million people/etc???!! VERY dumb
Again you FUCKING RETARD North and South Korea are 2 DIFFERENT Countries. When North Korea invaded it was NOT a civil war.
both have KOREA in their names
So what two DIFFERENT Countries. You amaze me at just HOW FUCKING STUPID you are.
.....like I said, they just reopened the library and I haven't been there for a long time....I just happened to see this book in the military section, so I picked it up...and I just got to that Bradley quote today
 
OP
harmonica

harmonica

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2017
Messages
28,990
Reaction score
5,846
Points
290
..another interesting ''statistic page 223:
'''''by 1953......only 36% of the American public supported an unpopular war''''
..this is just plain common sense and logical----no end in sight/no objectives stated/etc ---just like Vietnam
 

Most reactions - Past 7 days

Forum List

Top