rightwinger
Award Winning USMB Paid Messageboard Poster
- Aug 4, 2009
- 299,397
- 228,967
- 3,615
To paraphrase what you said before. Killing them won't bring the victims back. Some crimes do deserve a slow painful death. All I care about is that we are killing the right people every time. I would rather lock them up forever, away from society, than to take the chance of killing an innocent person.
Letting them live won't brings victims back either. However, if the guilty one thought it was good enough for their victims to die, why should they are anyone else have a problem if someone thinks the guilty one should die?
I'm all for not punishing an innocent person with death. However, those that believe like me still oppose the death penalty even when the guilty of the person being executed is not in question.
The problem is that it is ALWAYS in question because human beings make mistakes, some evidence is tampered with, eyewitnesses have been known to be quite inaccurate, some evidence can be contaminated, and nothing is 100%.
In many cases, it is 100%. For example, Dylann Roof, the Charleston, SC church shooter, is going to be tried and the death penalty is on the table both on the federal level and State level. There is absolutely no doubt that he did what he is accused of doing meaning it's 100%.
And they thought they were just as sure about the innocent people they killed. I don't have a problem with frying Root, but all executions aren't so unquestionable. I wouldn't have a problem with the death penalty if we were as sure about guilt as we are in his case.
Even in cases where there is no doubt like with Charleston, many still oppose the death penalty. When it's clear and absolute that the one being executed did the crime, the anti DP crowd still says no despite the evidence they say they want in order to support it is provided.
NO ONE is saying execute someone where there is doubt. I'm saying when there is absolutely no doubt, do the job and do it quickly. Opposition won't accept that.
The Death Penalty is barbaric
Eye for an eye justice ridiculed by most of the world
See those countries in red? They are our moral equivalents
